Zürcher Nachrichten - Calls for accountability over lethal Hong Kong fire silenced

EUR -
AED 4.182424
AFN 71.747202
ALL 94.274446
AMD 418.606876
ANG 2.038998
AOA 1044.323919
ARS 1684.21044
AUD 1.652521
AWG 2.051351
AZN 1.936967
BAM 1.955841
BBD 2.297098
BDT 140.28292
BGN 1.925657
BHD 0.430009
BIF 3387.18128
BMD 1.138849
BND 1.475666
BOB 7.881095
BRL 5.889671
BSD 1.140554
BTN 107.048758
BWP 15.499731
BYN 3.307841
BYR 22321.434635
BZD 2.293798
CAD 1.615873
CDF 2582.337129
CHF 0.922034
CLF 0.026693
CLP 1050.57616
CNY 7.742064
CNH 7.742708
COP 3922.764367
CRC 517.810779
CUC 1.138849
CUP 30.179491
CVE 110.266327
CZK 24.264301
DJF 203.098686
DKK 7.473905
DOP 67.011395
DZD 152.03283
EGP 56.438155
ERN 17.082731
ETB 183.876364
FJD 2.580748
FKP 0.862882
GBP 0.862456
GEL 3.012228
GGP 0.862882
GHS 12.859268
GIP 0.862882
GMD 83.135615
GNF 9993.16414
GTQ 8.701143
GYD 238.684968
HKD 8.931022
HNL 30.516305
HRK 7.533481
HTG 149.053941
HUF 353.741778
IDR 20321.616308
ILS 3.418881
IMP 0.862882
INR 107.457555
IQD 1494.031099
IRR 1566201.682791
ISK 143.995737
JEP 0.862882
JMD 179.627682
JOD 0.807477
JPY 184.246386
KES 147.458617
KGS 99.592816
KHR 4577.813912
KMF 494.260225
KPW 1024.964234
KRW 1757.835106
KWD 0.352599
KYD 0.950416
KZT 553.369089
LAK 25033.41118
LBP 102133.868024
LKR 383.366297
LRD 207.743412
LSL 18.747308
LTL 3.362725
LVL 0.688878
LYD 7.321313
MAD 10.694429
MDL 20.221332
MGA 4824.227501
MKD 61.640342
MMK 2390.740475
MNT 4076.66141
MOP 9.212892
MRU 45.516947
MUR 54.072666
MVR 17.595216
MWK 1977.693264
MXN 19.930496
MYR 4.623827
MZN 72.78137
NAD 18.747308
NGN 1571.064816
NIO 41.970689
NOK 11.317767
NPR 171.278565
NZD 2.017715
OMR 0.438319
PAB 1.140514
PEN 3.889064
PGK 5.00506
PHP 69.696973
PKR 317.409168
PLN 4.288918
PYG 6961.297718
QAR 4.15725
RON 5.240182
RSD 117.382443
RUB 88.602622
RWF 1670.278767
SAR 4.283083
SBD 9.169956
SCR 16.018533
SDG 683.308623
SEK 11.085923
SGD 1.473761
SHP 0.850266
SLE 28.240558
SLL 23881.092111
SOS 651.827877
SRD 42.687398
STD 23571.868885
STN 24.500295
SVC 9.979164
SYP 125.879336
SZL 18.736884
THB 37.969788
TJS 10.555273
TMT 3.98597
TND 3.380341
TOP 2.742075
TRY 53.119665
TTD 7.751127
TWD 36.304235
TZS 2994.915834
UAH 51.194114
UGX 4186.087136
USD 1.138849
UYU 45.780752
UZS 13699.285159
VES 706.943734
VND 29958.554057
VUV 135.761504
WST 3.167003
XAF 655.987935
XAG 0.019387
XAU 0.00028
XCD 3.077796
XCG 2.055443
XDR 0.815838
XOF 655.985055
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.757777
ZAR 18.756331
ZMK 10251.003886
ZMW 20.544879
ZWL 366.708819
  • CMSC

    -0.1160

    21.93

    -0.53%

  • NGG

    -0.4100

    83.01

    -0.49%

  • AZN

    2.7300

    188.41

    +1.45%

  • GSK

    0.6100

    52.5

    +1.16%

  • RIO

    -1.3700

    93.74

    -1.46%

  • BCE

    -0.2800

    22.92

    -1.22%

  • RBGPF

    3.7000

    65

    +5.69%

  • CMSD

    -0.1600

    21.77

    -0.73%

  • RELX

    0.4200

    31.34

    +1.34%

  • BTI

    0.2800

    62.76

    +0.45%

  • BCC

    1.2600

    81.02

    +1.56%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    13.89

    +0.22%

  • JRI

    0.2100

    12.79

    +1.64%

  • RYCEF

    0.3900

    18.39

    +2.12%

  • BP

    -0.5900

    37.13

    -1.59%

Calls for accountability over lethal Hong Kong fire silenced
Calls for accountability over lethal Hong Kong fire silenced / Photo: Dale DE LA REY - AFP

Calls for accountability over lethal Hong Kong fire silenced

Not long before he was reportedly detained, Miles Kwan approached commuters outside a Hong Kong train station, urging them to demand accountability for the deadly inferno that tore through nearby apartment blocks.

Text size:

"We all feel unhappy that (Hong Kong) has come to this and we want things to improve," the 24-year-old student told AFP on Friday, while handing out flyers that called for an independent probe into the blaze, which killed at least 128 people this week.

"We need to be frank about how today's Hong Kong is riddled with holes, inside and out."

Kwan and other organisers' demands turned into an online petition that gained more than 10,000 signatures in less than a day.

But local media reported on Saturday night that Kwan was arrested on suspicion of sedition by national security police and the text of the online petition had been deleted, showing how under Beijing's watchful eye, dissenting voices in Hong Kong can vanish as quickly as they appear.

Police declined to confirm the arrest, saying only that they "will take actions according to actual circumstances and in accordance with the law".

AFP's attempts to reach Kwan by phone on Sunday morning went unanswered.

Hong Kong was once home to spirited political activism, but that has faded since Beijing imposed a strict national security law in 2020 following huge pro-democracy protests in the Chinese finance hub.

Kwan was reportedly detained not long after Beijing's national security arm in Hong Kong publicly condemned "anti-China forces" for exploiting the disaster and "inciting social division and stirring hatred against authorities."

Asked on Friday if he feared being arrested, Kwan told AFP he was only "proposing very basic demands".

"If these ideas are deemed seditious or 'crossing the line', then I feel I can't predict the consequences of anything anymore, and I can only do what I truly believe."

- Grenfell comparisons -

Kwan and a handful of activists gave out flyers at the train station near the charred residential estate on Friday, demanding government accountability, an independent probe into possible corruption, proper resettlement for residents and a review of construction oversight.

The demands reflected a belief that the fire was "not an accident" but a man-made disaster, he said.

Authorities have arrested 11 people in connection to the blaze that tore through the high-rise blocks of Wang Fuk Court, the world's deadliest residential building fire since 1980.

Hong Kong has previously used judge-led commissions of inquiry (COI) to undertake complex fact-finding exercises in a public forum -- a practice left over from British colonial rule.

By contrast, city officials have so far announced only an inter-departmental task force to investigate the blaze.

When Britain was grappling with public fury over the devastating Grenfell Tower fire in 2017, which killed 72 people, the government announced a public inquiry.

Lawyer Imran Khan, who represented the bereaved and survivors in the inquiry, told AFP "the lessons from Grenfell apply around the world" as all governments need to ensure high-rise residential buildings are safe.

Khan said a public inquiry with court-like powers was a better option for the situation in Hong Kong because "an internal investigation will not get to the truth and there will be no faith in it by the bereaved, survivors and residents".

Based on his experience with Grenfell residents, he said, "without justice they cannot grieve".

At the Hong Kong station on Friday, many commuters took the flyers demanding action, though few stopped to chat with Kwan or his companions.

Near the site of the blaze a short walk away, a long queue snaked through a park as mourners brought flowers and handwritten notes of remembrance.

One unsigned note left on the ground read, "This is not just an accident, it is the evil fruit of an unjust system, which landed on you. It's not right."

T.L.Marti--NZN