Zürcher Nachrichten - The Crans-Montana fire: a Swiss tragedy that raises questions

EUR -
AED 4.209885
AFN 73.365394
ALL 95.800427
AMD 434.810135
ANG 2.052024
AOA 1051.183724
ARS 1598.50641
AUD 1.626713
AWG 2.063391
AZN 1.947207
BAM 1.953378
BBD 2.323185
BDT 141.504531
BGN 1.95943
BHD 0.433007
BIF 3420.030365
BMD 1.146329
BND 1.472863
BOB 7.970021
BRL 6.020654
BSD 1.153501
BTN 106.960496
BWP 15.642741
BYN 3.51583
BYR 22468.039124
BZD 2.319889
CAD 1.57482
CDF 2602.165752
CHF 0.907972
CLF 0.026582
CLP 1049.612476
CNY 7.878773
CNH 7.9149
COP 4250.987392
CRC 538.737696
CUC 1.146329
CUP 30.377706
CVE 110.140913
CZK 24.490508
DJF 205.406504
DKK 7.472199
DOP 69.737212
DZD 152.109771
EGP 59.887707
ERN 17.194928
ETB 180.107514
FJD 2.543471
FKP 0.860518
GBP 0.863971
GEL 3.112258
GGP 0.860518
GHS 12.573834
GIP 0.860518
GMD 84.828354
GNF 10109.448326
GTQ 8.835046
GYD 241.308138
HKD 8.982372
HNL 30.529135
HRK 7.53562
HTG 151.172215
HUF 393.484721
IDR 19465.804713
ILS 3.571696
IMP 0.860518
INR 106.909466
IQD 1510.897797
IRR 1507422.012458
ISK 143.210624
JEP 0.860518
JMD 181.110967
JOD 0.812738
JPY 182.425616
KES 148.540909
KGS 100.246273
KHR 4619.178761
KMF 490.628658
KPW 1031.681894
KRW 1716.839053
KWD 0.351705
KYD 0.961167
KZT 556.431947
LAK 24750.842591
LBP 103308.072843
LKR 359.160429
LRD 211.072202
LSL 19.253652
LTL 3.38481
LVL 0.693402
LYD 7.36035
MAD 10.79374
MDL 20.111097
MGA 4804.006802
MKD 61.678772
MMK 2406.99123
MNT 4110.55331
MOP 9.311709
MRU 46.037948
MUR 53.315552
MVR 17.722448
MWK 2000.12111
MXN 20.429093
MYR 4.509088
MZN 73.24617
NAD 19.253652
NGN 1562.365449
NIO 42.445698
NOK 10.962603
NPR 171.151362
NZD 1.970192
OMR 0.44076
PAB 1.153401
PEN 3.938916
PGK 4.976805
PHP 68.88116
PKR 322.223587
PLN 4.278385
PYG 7455.251146
QAR 4.194175
RON 5.097377
RSD 117.455107
RUB 99.295938
RWF 1683.742604
SAR 4.304888
SBD 9.222488
SCR 15.618637
SDG 688.943139
SEK 10.766085
SGD 1.470602
SHP 0.860043
SLE 28.257533
SLL 24037.948451
SOS 659.211952
SRD 42.843994
STD 23726.686075
STN 24.474455
SVC 10.091982
SYP 126.702276
SZL 19.258983
THB 37.545686
TJS 11.032071
TMT 4.01215
TND 3.394076
TOP 2.760083
TRY 50.805882
TTD 7.818737
TWD 36.621185
TZS 2980.431311
UAH 50.726176
UGX 4339.111483
USD 1.146329
UYU 46.707379
UZS 14065.153958
VES 516.928642
VND 30148.440253
VUV 136.881277
WST 3.132022
XAF 655.273063
XAG 0.016044
XAU 0.000244
XCD 3.09801
XCG 2.078676
XDR 0.814953
XOF 655.275918
XPF 119.331742
YER 273.48536
ZAR 19.420295
ZMK 10318.333563
ZMW 22.556555
ZWL 369.117318
  • RBGPF

    0.1000

    82.5

    +0.12%

  • VOD

    -0.3800

    14.37

    -2.64%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2100

    16.6

    -1.27%

  • RELX

    -0.4300

    33.86

    -1.27%

  • CMSC

    -0.1200

    22.83

    -0.53%

  • BCE

    -0.2600

    25.75

    -1.01%

  • GSK

    -1.3500

    52.06

    -2.59%

  • BTI

    -2.4600

    58.09

    -4.23%

  • BCC

    -1.0800

    71.84

    -1.5%

  • RIO

    -2.0800

    87.72

    -2.37%

  • NGG

    -3.0200

    87.4

    -3.46%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    22.89

    +0.04%

  • AZN

    -2.8700

    188.42

    -1.52%

  • JRI

    -0.1370

    12.323

    -1.11%

  • BP

    0.7600

    44.61

    +1.7%

The Crans-Montana fire: a Swiss tragedy that raises questions
The Crans-Montana fire: a Swiss tragedy that raises questions / Photo: MAXIME SCHMID - AFP

The Crans-Montana fire: a Swiss tragedy that raises questions

The deadly fire that ripped through a crowded bar in the Swiss ski resort town of Crans-Montana raises numerous questions.

Text size:

Around 40 people were killed and over 100 others injured in the blaze at the New Year's party.

As investigators begin the gruelling task of identifying the victims and trying to determine what happened, here are some of the main issues they will seek to probe.

- How did the tragedy occur? -

"It was around 1:30 am (0030 GMT) when smoke was spotted" coming out of Le Constellation bar at the heart of the upscale resort, police commander Frederic Gisler told reporters.

A few seconds later, a witness contacted the police.

"Immediately, the red alarm, which mobilises the fire department, was triggered," Gisler said, adding that firefighters "quickly contained the blaze" while the injured were being treated.

Authorities said they launched an investigation into the fire, and declined to speculate on what caused the tragedy.

Several witness accounts, broadcast by various Swiss, French and Italian media, meanwhile seemed to point to sparklers that were apparently mounted on top of champagne bottles and held aloft by restaurant staff as part of a regular "show" put on for patrons who made special orders to their tables.

"I think there were some ladies, waitresses, with champagne bottles and little sparklers. They got too close to the ceiling, and suddenly it all caught fire," Axel, who was present at the time of the incident, told the Italian media outlet Local Team.

- Was the establishment up to scratch? -

Le Constellation, located on the ground floor of a residential building, has a capacity of 300 people, plus another 40 people on its terrace, according to the Crans-Montana website.

Several witnesses said the event space in the basement of the establishment, where the fire began, was connected with the ground floor by only a staircase, which some described as "narrow".

But Wallis's chief prosecutor Beatrice Pilloud did not confirm this, stressing that the cause of the tragedy was still being investigated.

Responding to questions from reporters, she said she had seen the site herself.

"What exactly constitutes a narrow staircase?" she asked, stressing that the probe would "determine whether all safety standards were met".

Pilloud also said it was "too early" to comment on whether emergency exits met the required standards, or whether the necessary procedures had been followed before organising the New Year's event.

Multiple sources told AFP on Thursday that the bar owners are French nationals: a couple originally from Corsica who, according to a relative, are safe and sound, but who have been unreachable since the tragedy.

- Who are the victims? -

Authorities have not yet released any information on the victims' identities, but the bar was a popular spot for tourists and was known to draw a young crowd.

"Given the international nature of the Crans resort, we can expect foreign nationals to be among the victims," Gisler said.

He said Swiss authorities were "in close contact with the victims' families, whom we are informing in real time, as well as with the various embassies involved".

Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani told Italian broadcaster Rete 4 that around 15 Italians had been injured in the fire, and a similar number remained missing.

The French foreign ministry said nine French citizens figured among the injured, and eight others remained unaccounted for.

Given the bar's usually youthful clientele, questions were also being raised about the possible presence of minors at the time of the tragedy.

Stephane Ganzer, head of Wallis's security department, did not confirm that.

But, he told reporters, "you can imagine that on New Year's Eve, in a ski resort, the population is undoubtedly quite young".

R.Schmid--NZN