Florida Trial: Dwain Hall’s Messages Reveal Attempt to Mail Murder Weapon
A Florida jury heard Facebook messages from Dwain Hall, who is accused of murdering British woman Sonia Exelby, in which he asked a friend to hold a package containing the suspected murder weapon. The exchanges occurred days before Exelby’s body was discovered in Marion County, with Hall referencing an impending "big storm" and instructing his friend that the box must not be opened.
A Florida court has heard a series of Facebook messages exchanged between Dwain Hall, 54, and his friend Rick Snyder in October last year, revealing Hall’s attempts to conceal evidence before the discovery of British national Sonia Exelby’s body.
The messages, presented during Hall’s trial in Ocala for the kidnap and murder of Exelby, show Hall asking Snyder for his address in Ohio so he could mail a parcel containing what prosecutors allege is the suspected murder weapon. In one exchange, Hall told Snyder he could not discuss details openly because his phone "may be tapped" and warned that there "might be a big storm coming" for him.
Hall sent a photograph of a UPS shipping label to confirm the package had been dispatched. He instructed Snyder to keep the box safe without opening it, describing its contents as "very precious and valuable personal items." Hall added that he would need the contents returned in six months "if this storm passes over with no lingering fallout," and told Snyder to contact his wife, Ginger, regarding the return if the situation worsened.
The day before Exelby’s body was found on October 17, Snyder messaged Hall noting that he seemed "jumpy." Hall replied that the anxiety stemmed from the box containing "two of my most prized possessions." When Snyder asked how he could help "unf*** yourself out of whatever mess you are in," Hall responded: "I don’t know because I don’t know what kind of mess it is yet. For now, just hold on to the box. If anybody asked about the box that isn’t Ginger, it doesn’t exist."
Snyder later confirmed receipt of the package, noting it appeared to be a delivery from Walmart. Hall replied with "LOL, I know best way to secretly send something."
Investigators traced these digital clues to Washington County, Ohio, where local detectives executed a search warrant at Snyder’s property on November 4, 2025. Inside a dresser in Snyder’s bedroom, they found the package inside a cloth bag.
The contents included a knife in a sheath and a bracelet belonging to Hall. A crime laboratory biologist testified that both Hall and Exelby were "possible contributors" to a mixed DNA profile found on the bracelet. Additionally, DNA from all three individuals—Hall, Exelby, and Snyder—was identified as possible contributors to material found on the knife sheath.
The jury was shown an image of the black knife, which had the phrase "Dorkworf pointy end goes in the other guy" printed in capital letters on the blade. The biologist explained that she removed the handle because she had information suggesting the item might have been cleaned. Testing a sample from reddish-brown staining under the handle revealed chemical indications of blood. DNA analysis of this sample excluded Hall as the source but matched the DNA profile of Sonia Exelby.
Prosecutors have described Hall as a predator who manipulated Exelby, a 32-year-old woman from Southsea, Portsmouth, who struggled with mental illness and had a history of self-harm. They allege he stabbed her to death "for his own sadistic pleasure" after meeting her on a fetish website.
Exelby was reported missing from her home on October 12 last year. Police determined she had left the United Kingdom before her body was discovered by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17. She had been stabbed four times in the left side, with wounds reaching up to seven inches deep.
Hall was identified through the use of Exelby’s credit card at a roadside assistance company he owned. Location data from the Life360 app presented to the jury showed Hall visited the burial site on October 12. Earlier that same day, security camera footage placed him at a Lowe’s hardware store in Ocala, where he purchased a large tarpaulin. The court has also heard that Hall bought a shovel and rope shortly before Exelby arrived in Florida.
During the proceedings, a clinical neuropsychologist testified that Exelby’s level of vulnerability was "exceptionally high."
H.Roth--NZN