Zürcher Nachrichten - 'TikTok is having a bad war,' say disinformation experts

EUR -
AED 4.001562
AFN 76.943849
ALL 100.305017
AMD 422.317248
ANG 1.961698
AOA 950.687425
ARS 1006.673081
AUD 1.63176
AWG 1.961
AZN 1.854316
BAM 1.95588
BBD 2.19771
BDT 127.993915
BGN 1.957378
BHD 0.410317
BIF 3134.884157
BMD 1.089444
BND 1.464173
BOB 7.521307
BRL 6.039595
BSD 1.088454
BTN 91.062119
BWP 14.739737
BYN 3.562178
BYR 21353.112089
BZD 2.19401
CAD 1.495192
CDF 3083.127736
CHF 0.96819
CLF 0.037203
CLP 1026.539609
CNY 7.92211
CNH 7.941125
COP 4410.583352
CRC 571.123325
CUC 1.089444
CUP 28.870279
CVE 110.269504
CZK 25.229365
DJF 193.799694
DKK 7.461687
DOP 64.442632
DZD 146.516329
EGP 52.521035
ERN 16.341667
ETB 62.396748
FJD 2.43567
FKP 0.839483
GBP 0.842952
GEL 2.957771
GGP 0.839483
GHS 16.794686
GIP 0.839483
GMD 73.876425
GNF 9368.952652
GTQ 8.457345
GYD 227.7193
HKD 8.505985
HNL 26.958101
HRK 7.525829
HTG 143.677187
HUF 390.396938
IDR 17663.926198
ILS 3.968127
IMP 0.839483
INR 91.156654
IQD 1425.858234
IRR 45857.443114
ISK 149.744297
JEP 0.839483
JMD 170.098508
JOD 0.772092
JPY 171.61583
KES 139.863149
KGS 92.213526
KHR 4472.223702
KMF 493.246552
KPW 980.500426
KRW 1512.982362
KWD 0.333174
KYD 0.907045
KZT 518.58594
LAK 24136.985786
LBP 97473.375645
LKR 330.463497
LRD 212.420625
LSL 19.964999
LTL 3.216846
LVL 0.658994
LYD 5.249263
MAD 10.725138
MDL 19.265964
MGA 4903.245262
MKD 61.617517
MMK 3538.473221
MNT 3758.583882
MOP 8.754958
MRU 42.950754
MUR 50.844594
MVR 16.723146
MWK 1887.394408
MXN 19.626561
MYR 5.101321
MZN 69.615493
NAD 19.964999
NGN 1770.717264
NIO 40.059798
NOK 11.886496
NPR 145.698951
NZD 1.81438
OMR 0.418951
PAB 1.088444
PEN 4.075748
PGK 4.263213
PHP 63.629551
PKR 302.706141
PLN 4.290232
PYG 8230.411687
QAR 3.972562
RON 4.971353
RSD 117.054843
RUB 95.717967
RWF 1426.171337
SAR 4.086395
SBD 9.214091
SCR 15.374279
SDG 638.414245
SEK 11.617967
SGD 1.465052
SHP 0.839483
SLE 24.890868
SLL 22845.110316
SOS 622.031114
SRD 32.365225
STD 22549.301453
SVC 9.524476
SYP 2737.262378
SZL 19.968999
THB 39.557299
TJS 11.575873
TMT 3.82395
TND 3.374438
TOP 2.574468
TRY 36.047561
TTD 7.392336
TWD 35.800569
TZS 2924.774948
UAH 45.162359
UGX 4022.16427
USD 1.089444
UYU 43.861791
UZS 13715.497211
VEF 3946569.914016
VES 40.651179
VND 27601.076264
VUV 129.34107
WST 3.054376
XAF 655.989813
XAG 0.037303
XAU 0.000452
XCD 2.944278
XDR 0.821041
XOF 655.989813
XPF 119.331742
YER 272.742197
ZAR 19.864729
ZMK 9806.322524
ZMW 27.78339
ZWL 350.800683
  • RBGPF

    56.4600

    56.46

    +100%

  • GSK

    -0.0100

    39.35

    -0.03%

  • NGG

    0.8400

    61.79

    +1.36%

  • RIO

    -0.5900

    63.78

    -0.93%

  • CMSC

    0.0160

    24.31

    +0.07%

  • RELX

    -0.0700

    45.01

    -0.16%

  • CMSD

    -0.0200

    24.45

    -0.08%

  • SCS

    -0.1600

    13.54

    -1.18%

  • AZN

    0.6500

    78.71

    +0.83%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0250

    5.785

    -0.43%

  • BTI

    0.1600

    33.2

    +0.48%

  • BCC

    -1.2600

    130.84

    -0.96%

  • BCE

    -0.1200

    33.21

    -0.36%

  • VOD

    -0.0500

    9.04

    -0.55%

  • BP

    -0.2100

    35.38

    -0.59%

  • JRI

    0.1400

    12.42

    +1.13%

'TikTok is having a bad war,' say disinformation experts
'TikTok is having a bad war,' say disinformation experts

'TikTok is having a bad war,' say disinformation experts

The war in Ukraine has rapidly positioned TikTok as the number one source of misinformation thanks to its gigantic number of users and minimal filtering of content, experts say.

Text size:

Every day, Shayan Sardarizadeh, a journalist with the BBC's disinformation team, ploughs through a hallucinatory mix of fake and misleading information about the war being spewed out on the video-sharing site.

"TikTok is really not having a good war," he told AFP.

"I haven't seen another platform with so much false content," he added.

"We've seen it all: videos from past conflicts being recycled, genuine footage presented in a misleading way, things that are so obviously false but still get tens of millions of views."

He said the most disturbing were fake live-streams in which users pretended to be on the ground in Ukraine, but were actually using footage from other conflicts or even video games -- and then asking for money to support their "reporting".

"Millions tune in and watch. They even add fake gunshots and explosions," said Sardarizadeh.

Anastasiya Zhyrmont of Access Now, an advocacy group, said it was no excuse to say that the war came as a surprise.

"This conflict has been escalating since 2014 and these problems of Kremlin propaganda and misinformation have been raised with TikTok long before the invasion," she told AFP.

"They've promised to double their efforts and partner with content checkers, but I'm not sure they are taking this obligation seriously," she added.

- 'No context' -

Zhyrmont said the problem may lie with the lack of Ukrainian language content moderators, making it trickier for TikTok to spot false information.

TikTok told AFP that it has Russian and Ukrainian speakers, but did not say how many, and said it had added resources specifically focused on the war, but did not provide details.

But some say the very nature of TikTok makes it problematic when subject matter becomes more serious than funny skits and dance routines.

"The way you consume information on TikTok -- scrolling from one video to another really quickly -- means there is no context on any given piece of content," said Chine Labbe of NewsGuard, which tracks online misinformation.

NewsGuard ran an experiment to see how long it would take for new users to start receiving false information if they lingered on videos about the war.

The answer was 40 minutes.

"NewsGuard's findings add to the body of evidence that TikTok's lack of effective content-labelling and moderation, coupled with its skill at pushing users to content that keeps them on the app, have made the platform fertile ground for the spread of disinformation," it concluded in its report.

TikTok recognises the problem.

In a blog post on March 4, it said it was using "a combination of technology and people to protect our platform" and partnering with independent fact-checkers to provide more context.

- 'Really troubling' -

In the meantime, the particular concern with TikTok is the age of its users: a third in the United States, for example, are 19 or younger.

"It's hard enough for adults to decipher the real from the propaganda in Ukraine. For a young user to be fed all this false information is really troubling," said Labbe.

All those interviewed emphasised that misinformation is rampant across all social media, but that TikTok had done even less than Facebook, Instagram or Twitter to combat it.

TikTok's relative infancy also means its own users have not yet joined the fight as they have on other platforms.

"There are communities on Twitter and Instagram who are involved in disinformation," said Sardarizadeh.

"Some are starting to do fact-checking and educate people on TikTok, but we're talking about a dozen or two dozen, compared with hundreds on Twitter."

A.P.Huber--NZN