Zürcher Nachrichten - War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand

EUR -
AED 4.154466
AFN 79.136385
ALL 97.881276
AMD 433.971726
ANG 2.024329
AOA 1037.792925
ARS 1285.124849
AUD 1.757857
AWG 2.037417
AZN 1.924318
BAM 1.949798
BBD 2.284567
BDT 137.819997
BGN 1.949677
BHD 0.426439
BIF 3367.492983
BMD 1.131113
BND 1.455558
BOB 7.819137
BRL 6.475394
BSD 1.131547
BTN 96.452783
BWP 15.188646
BYN 3.702999
BYR 22169.813988
BZD 2.272863
CAD 1.564403
CDF 3240.63891
CHF 0.930437
CLF 0.027804
CLP 1066.95669
CNY 8.148875
CNH 8.126628
COP 4723.900982
CRC 575.5435
CUC 1.131113
CUP 29.974493
CVE 109.927569
CZK 24.916148
DJF 201.495058
DKK 7.459447
DOP 66.824287
DZD 149.848827
EGP 56.4437
ERN 16.966694
ETB 153.178814
FJD 2.556259
FKP 0.842559
GBP 0.839065
GEL 3.099512
GGP 0.842559
GHS 12.502843
GIP 0.842559
GMD 81.440531
GNF 9801.825858
GTQ 8.685263
GYD 236.727532
HKD 8.858831
HNL 29.452333
HRK 7.523054
HTG 148.054227
HUF 403.754129
IDR 18394.554822
ILS 4.096835
IMP 0.842559
INR 96.66463
IQD 1482.237051
IRR 47648.133424
ISK 144.974968
JEP 0.842559
JMD 179.80648
JOD 0.801954
JPY 161.207914
KES 146.128258
KGS 98.916094
KHR 4529.177412
KMF 491.46865
KPW 1017.956233
KRW 1557.112848
KWD 0.346867
KYD 0.942922
KZT 578.718693
LAK 24446.392104
LBP 101382.490976
LKR 338.747194
LRD 226.299357
LSL 20.252853
LTL 3.339883
LVL 0.684199
LYD 6.181969
MAD 10.400682
MDL 19.620121
MGA 5059.558743
MKD 61.251137
MMK 2374.898079
MNT 4043.521341
MOP 9.125749
MRU 44.998476
MUR 51.703067
MVR 17.486899
MWK 1962.012139
MXN 21.881318
MYR 4.785746
MZN 72.289707
NAD 20.252853
NGN 1798.051114
NIO 41.642543
NOK 11.529185
NPR 154.326013
NZD 1.902034
OMR 0.435415
PAB 1.131547
PEN 4.139829
PGK 4.63872
PHP 62.646662
PKR 318.914647
PLN 4.262452
PYG 9027.290014
QAR 4.124041
RON 5.051698
RSD 116.863345
RUB 90.074459
RWF 1620.853321
SAR 4.242235
SBD 9.445661
SCR 16.078697
SDG 679.235046
SEK 10.836752
SGD 1.456619
SHP 0.888877
SLE 25.699049
SLL 23718.873427
SOS 646.626562
SRD 41.455594
STD 23411.754535
SVC 9.900522
SYP 14705.822636
SZL 20.248026
THB 36.814357
TJS 11.597904
TMT 3.964551
TND 3.382089
TOP 2.649178
TRY 44.148798
TTD 7.691526
TWD 33.959458
TZS 3051.173817
UAH 46.96723
UGX 4130.285245
USD 1.131113
UYU 47.005298
UZS 14601.051822
VES 107.282134
VND 29356.905727
VUV 137.052207
WST 3.130475
XAF 653.961177
XAG 0.034236
XAU 0.000337
XCD 3.056889
XDR 0.814632
XOF 653.949649
XPF 119.331742
YER 275.821673
ZAR 20.342818
ZMK 10181.400748
ZMW 30.946554
ZWL 364.217911
  • RBGPF

    3.2000

    66.2

    +4.83%

  • CMSC

    -0.0950

    21.865

    -0.43%

  • BCC

    -0.9200

    86.41

    -1.06%

  • GSK

    -0.1350

    38.785

    -0.35%

  • SCS

    -0.0700

    10.08

    -0.69%

  • BTI

    0.6300

    45.23

    +1.39%

  • CMSD

    -0.1200

    21.61

    -0.56%

  • RIO

    0.5250

    61.645

    +0.85%

  • JRI

    0.0050

    12.645

    +0.04%

  • BP

    0.1150

    29.055

    +0.4%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1100

    11.2

    -0.98%

  • NGG

    0.9100

    74.54

    +1.22%

  • AZN

    0.4500

    70.4

    +0.64%

  • BCE

    0.0500

    21.52

    +0.23%

  • RELX

    0.6300

    55.61

    +1.13%

  • VOD

    -0.0750

    10.465

    -0.72%

War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand
War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand / Photo: Lillian SUWANRUMPHA - AFP/File

War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand

More than a million people have fled Myanmar's brutal civil war to seek shelter and work in neighbouring Thailand, where experts say nationalists are using disinformation to fuel prejudice against them.

Text size:

Social media platforms have been flooded by false claims that Myanmar migrant workers were demanding a 700-baht ($21) minimum daily wage -- almost twice that paid to Thais.

One of them attracted millions of views, and a former Thai intelligence heavyweight was among those who shared the images.

Analysts say some Thai authorities deliberately reinforce the nationalistic ideologies that drive xenophobia in the country -- which was invaded by Burma in the 18th century.

That history has mutated into modern fears that workers from Myanmar are "stealing" jobs.

Linn, a 37-year-old factory worker in Bangkok, is still only making the official minimum wage of 400 baht a day after 17 years in Thailand.

"The clip claiming that Myanmar workers are demanding 700 baht is a fabrication", he said.

Nantiwat Samart, ex-deputy director of Thailand's National Intelligence Agency, was among those who amplified the claim.

Last month, he reuploaded three images from different events, falsely alleging they were of migrant workers demanding 700 baht a day.

"Thais have aided war refugees long enough," he posted on Facebook.

"They all should return from whence they came so that Thais have more jobs."

His post garnered almost 500 comments and was shared nearly 15,000 times, more than any other on the issue.

AFP debunked all of his images, but he did not respond to requests for comment.

- 'Hate speech' -

Thailand and Myanmar share many aspects of culture and religion, but their history also includes centuries of warfare.

Burmese forces invaded in the 16th century, followed by years of battles, including in 1767 when they burned the capital, killed civilians and soldiers and took thousands prisoner.

The story of Burmese aggression is embedded in Thai consciousness from school onwards.

Myanmar labour rights expert Hnin Wut Yee said authorities seek to exploit historical resentments.

"Referring to history or warning against these foreign invasions can trigger the nationalist mindset, or could sustain a sense of togetherness in defence of external enemies," she told AFP.

Migrants from Myanmar have long sought low-paid jobs in the richer neighbour, facing similar fears and prejudices as immigrants around the world.

Since Myanmar was plunged into civil war by a military coup in 2021, millions more have been displaced. Many fled to Thailand.

Thailand's Foreign Workers Administration Office says the number of registered migrant workers from Myanmar has soared from 1.5 million in 2020 to 2.3 million four years later.

The UN's International Organization for Migration (IOM) estimates another 1.8 million are working illegally, without them or their employers paying taxes or social security, and without legal protection.

IOM says Thailand has seen a "surge in anti-migrant sentiment and hate speech targeted towards Myanmar nationals", primarily fuelled by disinformation on social media.

- 'Coordinated campaign' -

Many migrants earn much less than the official minimum, taking low-paid, difficult and dangerous work that Thais are reluctant to do, but many still see them as a threat to their jobs or pay.

Growing migrant numbers are driving anti-migrant misinformation, according to Lalita Hanwong, a historian at Kasetsart University and security advisor to the Thai government.

"This is a coordinated campaign designed to curb the number of Burmese in Thailand," she said, by framing them as "national security threats".

AFP fact-checkers found that the videos of supposed minimum wage protests were old and were of other events.

The most widely circulated was actually shot by a Myanmar migrant demonstrating against high visa and work permit fees.

"I don't want someone to take advantage by manipulating my video," they told AFP, asking for anonymity out of concerns for their job and security.

"Also, I don't want negative impacts in my life because my video was used the wrong way."

The workers have endured prejudice for decades.

"Some Thais really like us due to our diligence and loyalty to our employers," said Cho, a 40-year-old garment worker in Bangkok.

"But at the same time, some may perceive us negatively, that we are taking their jobs."

F.Schneider--NZN