Zürcher Nachrichten - War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand

EUR -
AED 4.317808
AFN 76.994475
ALL 96.189964
AMD 448.7811
ANG 2.104722
AOA 1077.985852
ARS 1704.836554
AUD 1.773409
AWG 2.116003
AZN 2.007197
BAM 1.9543
BBD 2.367312
BDT 143.640939
BGN 1.953544
BHD 0.443191
BIF 3485.527834
BMD 1.175557
BND 1.515391
BOB 8.121523
BRL 6.421132
BSD 1.175363
BTN 106.812813
BWP 15.523619
BYN 3.444453
BYR 23040.925982
BZD 2.363915
CAD 1.616703
CDF 2645.004589
CHF 0.934556
CLF 0.027368
CLP 1073.648601
CNY 8.284448
CNH 8.269941
COP 4520.018388
CRC 586.532218
CUC 1.175557
CUP 31.152272
CVE 110.721405
CZK 24.324665
DJF 208.920182
DKK 7.471185
DOP 74.470932
DZD 152.190865
EGP 55.705908
ERN 17.633362
ETB 182.27006
FJD 2.684964
FKP 0.878605
GBP 0.876131
GEL 3.168094
GGP 0.878605
GHS 13.548259
GIP 0.878605
GMD 86.404864
GNF 10216.182599
GTQ 9.000783
GYD 245.903882
HKD 9.145496
HNL 30.811895
HRK 7.529561
HTG 153.931817
HUF 385.673373
IDR 19576.558183
ILS 3.794346
IMP 0.878605
INR 106.897786
IQD 1539.980257
IRR 49502.723816
ISK 147.990962
JEP 0.878605
JMD 188.656761
JOD 0.83352
JPY 181.871704
KES 151.541393
KGS 102.802907
KHR 4706.932036
KMF 493.73405
KPW 1058.001998
KRW 1732.783652
KWD 0.360285
KYD 0.979519
KZT 605.856806
LAK 25468.45215
LBP 105271.169589
LKR 363.860641
LRD 208.367869
LSL 19.761085
LTL 3.471115
LVL 0.711083
LYD 6.371567
MAD 10.794561
MDL 19.793214
MGA 5301.763793
MKD 61.443207
MMK 2468.395605
MNT 4169.516512
MOP 9.418189
MRU 46.728714
MUR 54.016691
MVR 18.102491
MWK 2041.943832
MXN 21.114822
MYR 4.802741
MZN 75.12987
NAD 19.760977
NGN 1708.425936
NIO 43.175966
NOK 11.970655
NPR 170.9007
NZD 2.032451
OMR 0.451998
PAB 1.175363
PEN 3.963393
PGK 4.99994
PHP 68.878852
PKR 329.449854
PLN 4.213221
PYG 7894.938542
QAR 4.28021
RON 5.09216
RSD 117.362953
RUB 93.516769
RWF 1706.909415
SAR 4.409202
SBD 9.592601
SCR 16.789394
SDG 707.092237
SEK 10.92522
SGD 1.51537
SHP 0.881973
SLE 28.155038
SLL 24650.856215
SOS 671.827144
SRD 45.468202
STD 24331.665734
STN 24.921818
SVC 10.285191
SYP 12999.86794
SZL 19.761454
THB 36.971654
TJS 10.801685
TMT 4.114451
TND 3.42263
TOP 2.830461
TRY 50.209937
TTD 7.973641
TWD 36.98652
TZS 2903.626567
UAH 49.570363
UGX 4184.787067
USD 1.175557
UYU 45.984695
UZS 14253.633675
VES 314.39079
VND 30970.06097
VUV 142.785345
WST 3.267242
XAF 655.434266
XAG 0.01851
XAU 0.000273
XCD 3.177003
XCG 2.118311
XDR 0.816048
XOF 656.55533
XPF 119.331742
YER 280.312047
ZAR 19.695537
ZMK 10581.505648
ZMW 27.004463
ZWL 378.529019
  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • CMSD

    -0.0200

    23.345

    -0.09%

  • RBGPF

    3.3200

    81

    +4.1%

  • NGG

    -0.4500

    75.58

    -0.6%

  • CMSC

    -0.0140

    23.286

    -0.06%

  • BCC

    0.4250

    75.755

    +0.56%

  • JRI

    -0.0400

    13.52

    -0.3%

  • GSK

    -0.5850

    48.655

    -1.2%

  • BCE

    -0.1500

    23.46

    -0.64%

  • RIO

    0.1100

    75.93

    +0.14%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1000

    14.8

    -0.68%

  • RELX

    -0.3100

    40.77

    -0.76%

  • VOD

    -0.0150

    12.685

    -0.12%

  • BTI

    -0.4850

    57.255

    -0.85%

  • AZN

    -1.0000

    90.56

    -1.1%

  • BP

    -1.4550

    33.795

    -4.31%

War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand
War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand / Photo: Lillian SUWANRUMPHA - AFP/File

War of words: Myanmar migrants face disinformation in Thailand

More than a million people have fled Myanmar's brutal civil war to seek shelter and work in neighbouring Thailand, where experts say nationalists are using disinformation to fuel prejudice against them.

Text size:

Social media platforms have been flooded by false claims that Myanmar migrant workers were demanding a 700-baht ($21) minimum daily wage -- almost twice that paid to Thais.

One of them attracted millions of views, and a former Thai intelligence heavyweight was among those who shared the images.

Analysts say some Thai authorities deliberately reinforce the nationalistic ideologies that drive xenophobia in the country -- which was invaded by Burma in the 18th century.

That history has mutated into modern fears that workers from Myanmar are "stealing" jobs.

Linn, a 37-year-old factory worker in Bangkok, is still only making the official minimum wage of 400 baht a day after 17 years in Thailand.

"The clip claiming that Myanmar workers are demanding 700 baht is a fabrication", he said.

Nantiwat Samart, ex-deputy director of Thailand's National Intelligence Agency, was among those who amplified the claim.

Last month, he reuploaded three images from different events, falsely alleging they were of migrant workers demanding 700 baht a day.

"Thais have aided war refugees long enough," he posted on Facebook.

"They all should return from whence they came so that Thais have more jobs."

His post garnered almost 500 comments and was shared nearly 15,000 times, more than any other on the issue.

AFP debunked all of his images, but he did not respond to requests for comment.

- 'Hate speech' -

Thailand and Myanmar share many aspects of culture and religion, but their history also includes centuries of warfare.

Burmese forces invaded in the 16th century, followed by years of battles, including in 1767 when they burned the capital, killed civilians and soldiers and took thousands prisoner.

The story of Burmese aggression is embedded in Thai consciousness from school onwards.

Myanmar labour rights expert Hnin Wut Yee said authorities seek to exploit historical resentments.

"Referring to history or warning against these foreign invasions can trigger the nationalist mindset, or could sustain a sense of togetherness in defence of external enemies," she told AFP.

Migrants from Myanmar have long sought low-paid jobs in the richer neighbour, facing similar fears and prejudices as immigrants around the world.

Since Myanmar was plunged into civil war by a military coup in 2021, millions more have been displaced. Many fled to Thailand.

Thailand's Foreign Workers Administration Office says the number of registered migrant workers from Myanmar has soared from 1.5 million in 2020 to 2.3 million four years later.

The UN's International Organization for Migration (IOM) estimates another 1.8 million are working illegally, without them or their employers paying taxes or social security, and without legal protection.

IOM says Thailand has seen a "surge in anti-migrant sentiment and hate speech targeted towards Myanmar nationals", primarily fuelled by disinformation on social media.

- 'Coordinated campaign' -

Many migrants earn much less than the official minimum, taking low-paid, difficult and dangerous work that Thais are reluctant to do, but many still see them as a threat to their jobs or pay.

Growing migrant numbers are driving anti-migrant misinformation, according to Lalita Hanwong, a historian at Kasetsart University and security advisor to the Thai government.

"This is a coordinated campaign designed to curb the number of Burmese in Thailand," she said, by framing them as "national security threats".

AFP fact-checkers found that the videos of supposed minimum wage protests were old and were of other events.

The most widely circulated was actually shot by a Myanmar migrant demonstrating against high visa and work permit fees.

"I don't want someone to take advantage by manipulating my video," they told AFP, asking for anonymity out of concerns for their job and security.

"Also, I don't want negative impacts in my life because my video was used the wrong way."

The workers have endured prejudice for decades.

"Some Thais really like us due to our diligence and loyalty to our employers," said Cho, a 40-year-old garment worker in Bangkok.

"But at the same time, some may perceive us negatively, that we are taking their jobs."

F.Schneider--NZN