Zürcher Nachrichten - Indonesia's delayed new capital risks 'white elephant' status

EUR -
AED 4.337789
AFN 77.955631
ALL 96.755197
AMD 449.01782
ANG 2.11436
AOA 1083.11748
ARS 1714.991769
AUD 1.680903
AWG 2.126077
AZN 2.003623
BAM 1.955442
BBD 2.389263
BDT 145.083447
BGN 1.983595
BHD 0.445336
BIF 3528.88785
BMD 1.181154
BND 1.507992
BOB 8.226494
BRL 6.218962
BSD 1.186283
BTN 108.480146
BWP 15.624848
BYN 3.396778
BYR 23150.614952
BZD 2.385763
CAD 1.615163
CDF 2545.386154
CHF 0.918343
CLF 0.025875
CLP 1021.698128
CNY 8.204888
CNH 8.188343
COP 4286.407228
CRC 589.051003
CUC 1.181154
CUP 31.300576
CVE 110.244823
CZK 24.295626
DJF 211.241338
DKK 7.468671
DOP 74.984682
DZD 153.383359
EGP 55.514703
ERN 17.717307
ETB 185.059273
FJD 2.594346
FKP 0.861952
GBP 0.863246
GEL 3.183183
GGP 0.861952
GHS 13.007619
GIP 0.861952
GMD 86.794294
GNF 10417.295638
GTQ 9.102334
GYD 248.184577
HKD 9.228207
HNL 31.338674
HRK 7.536001
HTG 155.592055
HUF 380.589611
IDR 19798.264169
ILS 3.650461
IMP 0.861952
INR 106.427274
IQD 1554.009005
IRR 49756.105026
ISK 145.211105
JEP 0.861952
JMD 186.399493
JOD 0.837475
JPY 183.743887
KES 152.309797
KGS 103.291835
KHR 4779.827963
KMF 493.722575
KPW 1063.038442
KRW 1708.456332
KWD 0.362804
KYD 0.988515
KZT 599.055432
LAK 25511.330892
LBP 105750.711543
LKR 367.351212
LRD 220.049726
LSL 18.992424
LTL 3.487641
LVL 0.714468
LYD 7.494628
MAD 10.81772
MDL 20.083324
MGA 5293.997707
MKD 61.622244
MMK 2480.407042
MNT 4210.370736
MOP 9.543113
MRU 47.141891
MUR 54.202952
MVR 18.248559
MWK 2058.465599
MXN 20.457462
MYR 4.63843
MZN 75.298821
NAD 18.992585
NGN 1651.572071
NIO 43.685847
NOK 11.416147
NPR 173.703506
NZD 1.95266
OMR 0.454167
PAB 1.186283
PEN 3.995469
PGK 5.087074
PHP 69.722921
PKR 332.307261
PLN 4.219601
PYG 7887.556412
QAR 4.336506
RON 5.096325
RSD 117.438577
RUB 90.651241
RWF 1735.619524
SAR 4.429389
SBD 9.517857
SCR 16.416211
SDG 710.460956
SEK 10.539004
SGD 1.499433
SHP 0.886171
SLE 28.908779
SLL 24768.204249
SOS 678.498558
SRD 44.913357
STD 24447.499419
STN 24.514815
SVC 10.380056
SYP 13063.05918
SZL 18.997677
THB 37.156767
TJS 11.079572
TMT 4.14585
TND 3.422474
TOP 2.843935
TRY 51.371947
TTD 8.031598
TWD 37.277802
TZS 3055.101843
UAH 51.12635
UGX 4237.224499
USD 1.181154
UYU 46.021577
UZS 14502.345767
VES 438.964675
VND 30707.046542
VUV 140.742405
WST 3.201849
XAF 656.348104
XAG 0.013527
XAU 0.00024
XCD 3.192127
XCG 2.1379
XDR 0.816262
XOF 655.836968
XPF 119.331742
YER 281.557585
ZAR 18.87159
ZMK 10631.795497
ZMW 23.279739
ZWL 380.331049
  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • CMSC

    -0.0100

    23.75

    -0.04%

  • RIO

    1.4900

    92.52

    +1.61%

  • BCE

    -0.0300

    25.83

    -0.12%

  • RBGPF

    0.1000

    82.5

    +0.12%

  • CMSD

    0.0300

    24.08

    +0.12%

  • BCC

    0.9400

    81.75

    +1.15%

  • BTI

    0.3100

    60.99

    +0.51%

  • NGG

    -0.6600

    84.61

    -0.78%

  • JRI

    0.0700

    13.15

    +0.53%

  • RYCEF

    0.7000

    16.7

    +4.19%

  • GSK

    0.8700

    52.47

    +1.66%

  • AZN

    1.3100

    188.41

    +0.7%

  • RELX

    -0.2700

    35.53

    -0.76%

  • BP

    -0.1800

    37.7

    -0.48%

  • VOD

    0.2600

    14.91

    +1.74%

Indonesia's delayed new capital risks 'white elephant' status
Indonesia's delayed new capital risks 'white elephant' status / Photo: YASUYOSHI CHIBA - AFP

Indonesia's delayed new capital risks 'white elephant' status

A year after it was inaugurated, Indonesia's would-be new capital Nusantara attracts tourists and construction workers, but most of its architecturally arresting presidential palace and freshly built avenues sit silent.

Text size:

The legacy project of former president Joko Widodo is battling a slashed budget, slowed construction and a deficit of interest from a new leader focused on social mega-projects.

That has raised questions about whether the city, carved out of the jungle to replace crowded and rapidly sinking Jakarta, will ever see its promised potential.

"The political will on IKN right now feels muted," said Dedi Dinarto, senior associate at public policy advisory firm Global Counsel, referring to the new capital's official name: Ibu Kota Nusantara.

President Prabowo Subianto "is clearly putting his chips on welfare instead".

Just over 1,000 city authority employees live in Nusantara, along with a few hundred more ministry workers and service and medical employees.

That's far short of Jakarta's 12 million residents, and the new city's goal of two million inhabitants by 2045.

Prabowo mentioned IKN just once in his first state of the nation speech, and has slashed funding for the project.

Official budgets show a cut from 43.4 trillion rupiah ($2.66 billion) in 2024 to just 6.3 trillion rupiah in 2026. The authority had requested more than 21 trillion rupiah for 2026's budget.

Significant foreign funding has also proved elusive despite overtures to allies in the Middle East and Asia.

"Prabowo feels that this is not his legacy. It's not his big push and he has more programmes that he wants to push," an official involved in the city's construction told AFP on condition of anonymity.

"I'm still 50-50 on it (being finished)," the official added, saying the budget cuts mean "a lot of things will not be completed".

- 'Your loss' -

The former president, known popularly as Jokowi, revived the long-proposed capital move when he won a second term in 2019.

But despite a rush to build, the city was not inaugurated as Indonesia's new capital on August 17 last year as expected.

"In Joko Widodo's time it was very fast-moving, now in Prabowo's time... it's not as fast," said Sofian Sibarani, the city's designer.

Just 800 of the planned 6,600 hectares of the core government area have been developed on or prepared for construction, he said.

Nusantara officials are undeterred, and tout the city as Indonesia's future power centre.

City authority head Basuki Hadimuljono told AFP that projects in a smaller executive area housing the palace and ministries in the government core were "already 97-98 percent" complete.

He claimed Prabowo wants to move in 2028 before the next presidential election, once the legislative and judicial areas are finished.

As president-elect, Prabowo said he wanted to "continue, if possible finish" the capital move, but since taking office he has yet to express any plans to sign the presidential decree needed to shift from Jakarta.

"It would be signed after the legislative and judicial areas are completed" in 2028, said Basuki.

"If you do not want to move here, or you have a doubt, it is your loss," he added.

Some government employees have expressed reservations about moving to an unfinished jungle city, located around 1,200 kilometres (745 miles) from Jakarta.

But city employee Helena, who like many Indonesians goes by one name, insisted her unfinished tower block offers "an amazing level of comfort".

"And the facilities we get are more than enough," the 45-year-old told AFP.

The city now has three functioning hospitals, coffee shops, a toll road to nearby Balikpapan city and an airport waiting for commercial flight approval.

A planned shopping mall and cinema remain unbuilt.

- 'Really cool' -

Outside the palace in the ceremonial plaza, dozens of tourists were taking in the promised new capital with gusto.

"I am happy and proud... IKN is really cool," said Ronald Telaumbanua, 38, who travelled from Sulawesi island.

The striking presidential palace, modelled after the mythical Garuda bird, is a draw for photographs, but the city's lush green centrepiece offers little else.

Businesses counting on a boom of arrivals say they are struggling.

"During the Jokowi era, there were many workers, and there were numerous visits. Almost every day was busy," said Abduh Rajab, 57, a snack seller near the developed city centre.

"My earnings have dropped significantly, by almost 60 percent. But I have to stay optimistic. I hope the construction will continue."

Dedi said former general Prabowo was likely to remain focused on flagship policies, such as offering free meals to children and pregnant women.

"That means IKN will not see breakneck development anytime soon," he said.

"Without strong momentum, it risks drifting into white elephant territory."

P.Gashi--NZN