Zürcher Nachrichten - At Milan Fashion Week, industry's darker side goes unmentioned

EUR -
AED 4.250593
AFN 72.324867
ALL 95.930454
AMD 436.637368
ANG 2.071496
AOA 1061.158156
ARS 1617.145032
AUD 1.665045
AWG 2.085575
AZN 1.971949
BAM 1.953338
BBD 2.331262
BDT 142.030979
BGN 1.978023
BHD 0.436948
BIF 3434.010038
BMD 1.157206
BND 1.481046
BOB 8.015931
BRL 6.108085
BSD 1.157441
BTN 108.457108
BWP 15.860489
BYN 3.42671
BYR 22681.245746
BZD 2.327966
CAD 1.594856
CDF 2635.536793
CHF 0.916224
CLF 0.026909
CLP 1062.52355
CNY 7.976273
CNH 7.986744
COP 4289.833615
CRC 539.324876
CUC 1.157206
CUP 30.66597
CVE 110.368555
CZK 24.458023
DJF 205.658378
DKK 7.472359
DOP 69.287759
DZD 153.613393
EGP 60.854389
ERN 17.358096
ETB 182.115406
FJD 2.576756
FKP 0.864491
GBP 0.865538
GEL 3.141849
GGP 0.864491
GHS 12.61934
GIP 0.864491
GMD 84.47616
GNF 10160.272133
GTQ 8.863828
GYD 242.250938
HKD 9.056587
HNL 30.689286
HRK 7.538506
HTG 151.770015
HUF 391.574297
IDR 19578.775346
ILS 3.616675
IMP 0.864491
INR 108.945427
IQD 1515.940404
IRR 1521784.29691
ISK 143.783137
JEP 0.864491
JMD 182.659769
JOD 0.820422
JPY 184.13698
KES 149.857154
KGS 101.195963
KHR 4646.183459
KMF 491.81255
KPW 1041.452386
KRW 1737.904695
KWD 0.354834
KYD 0.964613
KZT 558.775699
LAK 24937.798398
LBP 103627.834229
LKR 363.834554
LRD 212.461728
LSL 19.499067
LTL 3.41693
LVL 0.699982
LYD 7.400305
MAD 10.833822
MDL 20.245095
MGA 4819.76486
MKD 61.649193
MMK 2429.704088
MNT 4130.036574
MOP 9.328386
MRU 46.41584
MUR 56.923438
MVR 17.878826
MWK 2010.068175
MXN 20.624886
MYR 4.578484
MZN 73.94226
NAD 19.464141
NGN 1596.824364
NIO 42.492237
NOK 11.24966
NPR 173.52728
NZD 1.994342
OMR 0.444953
PAB 1.157441
PEN 4.018968
PGK 4.982357
PHP 69.517947
PKR 323.150002
PLN 4.277843
PYG 7552.480583
QAR 4.216841
RON 5.09437
RSD 117.422922
RUB 93.154734
RWF 1689.521367
SAR 4.343819
SBD 9.317499
SCR 16.673401
SDG 695.480938
SEK 10.833142
SGD 1.482144
SHP 0.868205
SLE 28.409612
SLL 24266.052459
SOS 661.347025
SRD 43.210374
STD 23951.836413
STN 25.030375
SVC 10.128234
SYP 128.423928
SZL 19.499125
THB 37.8852
TJS 11.106389
TMT 4.050222
TND 3.361709
TOP 2.786275
TRY 51.314926
TTD 7.864156
TWD 36.992649
TZS 2974.020449
UAH 50.834846
UGX 4334.536595
USD 1.157206
UYU 47.170545
UZS 14123.703968
VES 528.269768
VND 30500.489496
VUV 138.237827
WST 3.181015
XAF 655.134076
XAG 0.016648
XAU 0.000264
XCD 3.127408
XCG 2.086089
XDR 0.814857
XOF 657.873131
XPF 119.331742
YER 276.167476
ZAR 19.76026
ZMK 10416.242604
ZMW 21.90539
ZWL 372.619994
  • CMSD

    -0.0800

    22.66

    -0.35%

  • CMSC

    -0.0600

    22.82

    -0.26%

  • RBGPF

    -13.5000

    69

    -19.57%

  • BCC

    1.6950

    73.575

    +2.3%

  • JRI

    0.1400

    11.82

    +1.18%

  • RYCEF

    -0.4500

    15.6

    -2.88%

  • BCE

    0.1050

    25.865

    +0.41%

  • RIO

    0.7350

    86.575

    +0.85%

  • RELX

    -1.3150

    32.495

    -4.05%

  • BTI

    0.1300

    58.05

    +0.22%

  • NGG

    0.4300

    82.49

    +0.52%

  • BP

    1.0910

    44.661

    +2.44%

  • AZN

    1.0850

    185.155

    +0.59%

  • VOD

    0.1800

    14.66

    +1.23%

  • GSK

    0.9350

    52.925

    +1.77%

At Milan Fashion Week, industry's darker side goes unmentioned
At Milan Fashion Week, industry's darker side goes unmentioned / Photo: MIGUEL MEDINA - AFP

At Milan Fashion Week, industry's darker side goes unmentioned

Artisans in white coats greeted guests at the Tod's fashion show in Milan Friday, crafting the Made in Italy leather and needlework items for which the company -- and country -- is renowned.

Text size:

But despite that display of handcraft, there has been little mention at Milan Fashion Week of some of the industry's forgotten workers -- whom prosecutors found were working in sweatshop conditions at subcontractors for many Italian luxury brands, including Tod's.

With the glamorous catwalks, celebrities and excess of finery on display, the possibility of the recent investigations uncovering labour abuses being on anyone's mind appeared slim.

After the show, Tod's founder and chairman Diego Della Valle told AFP the company's decision to highlight its artisanal heritage was in no way linked to the recent investigations.

"No controversy -- I think we'll do good things together with the courts and trade associations. I think we're on the right track," Della Valle said.

On Tuesday, Tod's submitted to a Milan court a list of measures it was undertaking to reinforce its supply chain, including the creation of a platform to better trace supplier activity and expanded audits.

"I think that by working together like this, everyone will be involved in finding a solution," he said, adding that Italy's laws needed revising "to protect people and artisans".

- 'Product first' -

Many international guests at the show had not heard mention of the accusations of migrant labour exploitation levelled last year at over a dozen of luxury's biggest names, including Gucci, Loro Piana, Prada, Dolce & Gabbana and Ferragamo.

Allegations include around-the-clock working hours and substandard pay, breaches of safety measures and makeshift sleeping areas inside small workshops.

Asked whether it would matter to the luxury consumer, the vice president and fashion director at Nordstrom, Rickie De Sole, suggested the answer might be yes and no.

"I think the integrity of Made in Italy is incredibly important and I think that at the end of the day, to the customer, it's product first, right?" she told AFP.

Influential fashion critic and journalist Suzy Menkes, sitting in the front row, cautioned that she hadn't followed the cases in Italy but said "people do care when there are specific things that have come to light".

"But I don't think it's any different from food and various other things, where one hopes that the bigger the company is, that the more they're serious about it."

A Hong Kong content creator dressed head to toe in Tod's, 26-year-old Stephanie Hui, said people were "desensitised" to stories of sweatshop conditions in the fashion industry, with consumers feeling powerless to effect change.

"It takes a lot of people to band together to like really make a change. It's not really in our control, but definitely I think if consumers stop spending as much they'll kind of give the brands a wake-up call," she said.

- 'Want to be seen' -

Fashion industry insiders say that controlling every link in the supply chain is more complicated the bigger the company.

Stefano Aimone, CEO and creative director of Agnona, told AFP in an interview this that it depends on the company's scale.

"When you’re smaller, you have more control and can really check and know all your employees and consultants by name. When you're dealing with 400, they're just numbers, and it's unthinkable to control everything," he said.

"Something will slip through regardless, because even if you have contracts with such-and-such subcontractor, you don’t know what they then do in turn," said Aimone.

Asked whether fashion customers paid attention, Aimone said that despite some headlines, it remained "a B (business) to B (business) issue".

"The end customer doesn't know."

And even if supply chains were better known, the customer might not care, said Iuliana Stetco, 21, a fashion marketing student in Milan.

"They want to be seen, they want to be seen wearing a certain type of brand, a certain label, and so as a result they don’t care much."

O.Pereira--NZN