Zürcher Nachrichten - Lightning advance: swathes of Hanoi demolished for development

EUR -
AED 4.275144
AFN 72.745556
ALL 95.457948
AMD 426.635522
ANG 2.084269
AOA 1068.640686
ARS 1631.971778
AUD 1.626307
AWG 2.095374
AZN 1.976602
BAM 1.955963
BBD 2.336195
BDT 142.56187
BGN 1.943949
BHD 0.437436
BIF 3453.971119
BMD 1.164097
BND 1.485662
BOB 8.014667
BRL 5.860529
BSD 1.159897
BTN 110.931236
BWP 15.687306
BYN 3.184665
BYR 22816.299685
BZD 2.332794
CAD 1.60735
CDF 2625.038955
CHF 0.913199
CLF 0.026489
CLP 1042.544593
CNY 7.909748
CNH 7.903351
COP 4272.75575
CRC 524.943707
CUC 1.164097
CUP 30.848568
CVE 110.274181
CZK 24.290634
DJF 206.547197
DKK 7.47313
DOP 68.365692
DZD 155.019907
EGP 61.644132
ERN 17.461454
ETB 186.991569
FJD 2.568115
FKP 0.866187
GBP 0.864825
GEL 3.096267
GGP 0.866187
GHS 13.467121
GIP 0.866187
GMD 84.400611
GNF 10170.215057
GTQ 8.844736
GYD 242.630201
HKD 9.120571
HNL 30.859569
HRK 7.559528
HTG 151.957921
HUF 358.799094
IDR 20602.885796
ILS 3.365381
IMP 0.866187
INR 111.404655
IQD 1519.426507
IRR 1540565.867654
ISK 144.068241
JEP 0.866187
JMD 183.105245
JOD 0.825375
JPY 184.84404
KES 150.552535
KGS 101.8002
KHR 4650.384613
KMF 494.741022
KPW 1047.688444
KRW 1769.834184
KWD 0.3603
KYD 0.96658
KZT 547.755606
LAK 25420.116479
LBP 103893.850202
LKR 387.972303
LRD 212.257673
LSL 19.132093
LTL 3.437276
LVL 0.704151
LYD 7.391615
MAD 10.700491
MDL 20.118675
MGA 4873.40576
MKD 61.645133
MMK 2443.983394
MNT 4167.358107
MOP 9.361879
MRU 46.349859
MUR 55.154755
MVR 17.922958
MWK 2011.267458
MXN 20.121223
MYR 4.619019
MZN 74.383855
NAD 19.132093
NGN 1597.431838
NIO 42.701897
NOK 10.724586
NPR 177.489778
NZD 1.980088
OMR 0.447887
PAB 1.159897
PEN 3.954629
PGK 5.058421
PHP 71.561748
PKR 322.930287
PLN 4.239391
PYG 7068.588531
QAR 4.240753
RON 5.266836
RSD 117.419776
RUB 82.63688
RWF 1695.741187
SAR 4.353762
SBD 9.365372
SCR 15.937327
SDG 699.038816
SEK 10.850361
SGD 1.488705
SHP 0.869116
SLE 28.639035
SLL 24410.532871
SOS 662.855189
SRD 43.250815
STD 24094.455998
STN 24.512569
SVC 10.148845
SYP 128.661922
SZL 19.127593
THB 38.066138
TJS 10.775497
TMT 4.074339
TND 3.395483
TOP 2.802866
TRY 53.206319
TTD 7.872655
TWD 36.616086
TZS 3033.252549
UAH 51.335374
UGX 4392.365708
USD 1.164097
UYU 46.433866
UZS 13916.158659
VES 612.560026
VND 30691.415367
VUV 136.726161
WST 3.171929
XAF 656.01162
XAG 0.015416
XAU 0.000258
XCD 3.14603
XCG 2.090474
XDR 0.815868
XOF 656.01162
XPF 119.331742
YER 277.811761
ZAR 19.062029
ZMK 10478.273203
ZMW 21.834818
ZWL 374.838734
  • CMSD

    0.0100

    22.73

    +0.04%

  • GSK

    -0.1500

    51.38

    -0.29%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    63.5

    0%

  • NGG

    0.1900

    86.61

    +0.22%

  • CMSC

    0.0100

    22.66

    +0.04%

  • RYCEF

    0.1600

    16.64

    +0.96%

  • RIO

    -0.5300

    104.23

    -0.51%

  • RELX

    -0.3300

    33.01

    -1%

  • VOD

    -0.1700

    14.94

    -1.14%

  • BTI

    -0.3700

    65.36

    -0.57%

  • BCE

    0.2100

    24.6

    +0.85%

  • BCC

    0.0500

    67.16

    +0.07%

  • JRI

    0.0500

    12.87

    +0.39%

  • AZN

    -2.7200

    187.03

    -1.45%

  • BP

    -0.5100

    44.36

    -1.15%

Lightning advance: swathes of Hanoi demolished for development
Lightning advance: swathes of Hanoi demolished for development / Photo: Nhac NGUYEN - AFP

Lightning advance: swathes of Hanoi demolished for development

Rows of townhouses torn down in hours, roads ripped up by bulldozers and city blocks reduced to rubble in the name of progress -- giant construction sites litter Hanoi as it races ahead with urban renewal.

Text size:

A "100-year master plan" for the Vietnamese capital includes new bridges, subway lines and riverside developments.

Hundreds of thousands could be displaced to make way for construction, authorities say, as the city of eight million prepares to accommodate twice as many people by 2045.

Communist leaders hope Vietnam will be a developed country by then, buoyed by breakneck growth and spurred by their huge infrastructure investments.

But the speed of implementation has unnerved residents, made some homeless and left many more fearing the same fate.

"I have never seen authorities acting that quick," said Hung, a 51-year-old businessman whose house was torn down last month for a $750 million bridge spanning the Red River.

"My dad had lived there all his life, he got to know every corner, everyone, now he saw it all demolished in a blink," he added, asking to be identified only by his first name.

He said he received 10 billion dong ($380,000) as compensation along with a rural plot of land -- but that the home's market value was nearly triple that.

The city having another bridge is "good for all, but not for us", he added.

"We are unlucky to be the sufferers in this giant restructuring of Hanoi."

- No joke -

A city of less than half a million for most of its thousand-year history, Hanoi grew dramatically in the 1980s and 1990s as Vietnam underwent market-oriented reforms.

Many migrants from the countryside built homes on land they did not formally own, creating sprawling, semi-planned neighbourhoods with narrow, winding streets.

The city has since formalised construction and embarked on multiple rounds of renovation.

But those plans "were often joked about because they stayed as posters on the wall and little was implemented", according to Danielle Labbe, an urban planning professor at the University of Montreal who focuses on Vietnam.

Now the 100-year master plan is charging ahead.

Top leader To Lam has declared a "new growth model" that includes a major building blitz. He preaches less red tape and faster decision-making, leading to a flurry of project approvals, analysts say.

With seven new bridges planned and more than 1,200 kilometres (746 miles) of metro and rail lines, the Hanoi redevelopment is expected to cost more than $2.5 trillion over two decades.

Roads are also being widened and drainage systems improved in anticipation of flooding risks stemming from climate change.

More than 11,000 hectares along the river is slated to become a network of residential developments and parks -- with roughly 250,000 residents relocated to make way.

State media reported that overall, as many 860,000 could be uprooted. Authorities denied the figure but did not specify an alternative.

Hanoi's architecture and planning department did not immediately respond to AFP requests for comment.

Many Hanoi residents support modernisation, with Labbe calling the population "very pro-development".

But the rapid pace of change and lack of public consultation has bred resentment.

The master plan ran to more than 1,000 pages, according to Labbe, but was only "opened for comment for something like 10 or 15 days".

"Plans didn't use to be approved and implemented so fast," she said.

- 'No greater pain' -

Ho Chi Minh City also has a 100-year master plan, as Vietnam embarks on an infrastructure drive that parallels its giant Communist neighbour to the north, both in scale and execution.

"To me, the influence of Chinese planning is very clear," said Labbe.

Retired house cleaner Phan received her final eviction notice in February and her four-storey home is slated for demolition this week.

The 10-person, three-generation household split up and moved in with other relatives.

Authorities offered a slight discount on a much smaller apartment costing $76,000.

But because like many they did not have title to the land under their home, they were only compensated $19,000 for building costs.

"So now the family is in a very difficult situation and has to borrow money," said Phan, 69.

"Our family used to eat together, sit together, and live happily as three generations under one roof," she said, breaking into tears.

"Now the family is broken apart, everyone scattered in different places. There is no pain greater than this."

R.Schmid--NZN