Zürcher Nachrichten - Europe to cut funds for Poland over unpaid fine

EUR -
AED 4.235403
AFN 79.363955
ALL 97.487163
AMD 442.360586
ANG 2.063732
AOA 1057.407949
ARS 1489.237275
AUD 1.777494
AWG 2.078493
AZN 1.962137
BAM 1.955141
BBD 2.329215
BDT 141.43236
BGN 1.952577
BHD 0.434715
BIF 3438.871478
BMD 1.153117
BND 1.487199
BOB 7.971384
BRL 6.439691
BSD 1.153611
BTN 100.83391
BWP 15.593883
BYN 3.775228
BYR 22601.085083
BZD 2.31724
CAD 1.590471
CDF 3332.506966
CHF 0.929993
CLF 0.028226
CLP 1107.30368
CNY 8.275806
CNH 8.290776
COP 4773.833478
CRC 583.208611
CUC 1.153117
CUP 30.55759
CVE 110.227871
CZK 24.559112
DJF 205.422587
DKK 7.461783
DOP 70.296321
DZD 150.269881
EGP 56.147783
ERN 17.296749
ETB 160.038481
FJD 2.605409
FKP 0.864513
GBP 0.86211
GEL 3.13682
GGP 0.864513
GHS 12.113025
GIP 0.864513
GMD 83.024321
GNF 10007.629044
GTQ 8.851019
GYD 241.350797
HKD 9.051907
HNL 30.34178
HRK 7.535269
HTG 151.37901
HUF 398.77481
IDR 18924.949407
ILS 3.881851
IMP 0.864513
INR 100.816412
IQD 1511.190973
IRR 48560.584773
ISK 142.202557
JEP 0.864513
JMD 184.589424
JOD 0.817536
JPY 171.011222
KES 149.04039
KGS 100.840022
KHR 4620.483712
KMF 491.802937
KPW 1037.708708
KRW 1595.763973
KWD 0.352279
KYD 0.961385
KZT 627.104205
LAK 24899.828712
LBP 103361.080364
LKR 348.522604
LRD 231.297105
LSL 20.615056
LTL 3.404853
LVL 0.697509
LYD 6.274941
MAD 10.488158
MDL 19.680542
MGA 5091.329197
MKD 61.540605
MMK 2420.279605
MNT 4140.247065
MOP 9.32776
MRU 46.039492
MUR 52.789849
MVR 17.759913
MWK 2000.343554
MXN 21.617471
MYR 4.889038
MZN 73.753269
NAD 20.615056
NGN 1768.350541
NIO 42.455699
NOK 11.780885
NPR 161.332657
NZD 1.939202
OMR 0.443371
PAB 1.153621
PEN 4.09752
PGK 4.774433
PHP 66.350301
PKR 327.442005
PLN 4.267406
PYG 8640.089685
QAR 4.194987
RON 5.073023
RSD 117.183152
RUB 94.20923
RWF 1668.052601
SAR 4.325588
SBD 9.506481
SCR 16.931234
SDG 692.445632
SEK 11.142629
SGD 1.486765
SHP 0.906169
SLE 26.522168
SLL 24180.282798
SOS 659.27793
SRD 42.302605
STD 23867.185194
STN 24.491963
SVC 10.0936
SYP 14992.763444
SZL 20.604238
THB 37.464179
TJS 11.028281
TMT 4.047439
TND 3.402854
TOP 2.700712
TRY 46.79501
TTD 7.828431
TWD 34.271201
TZS 2963.510065
UAH 48.160995
UGX 4135.696601
USD 1.153117
UYU 46.16445
UZS 14420.14274
VES 141.472703
VND 30214.537341
VUV 137.769629
WST 3.179275
XAF 655.741808
XAG 0.030413
XAU 0.000346
XCD 3.116356
XCG 2.079
XDR 0.799582
XOF 655.736123
XPF 119.331742
YER 277.497077
ZAR 20.599619
ZMK 10379.429112
ZMW 26.503303
ZWL 371.30307
  • CMSC

    0.0150

    22.625

    +0.07%

  • RIO

    -1.0000

    61.27

    -1.63%

  • VOD

    -0.0450

    11.065

    -0.41%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1800

    13.2

    -1.36%

  • SCS

    0.1300

    10.64

    +1.22%

  • SCU

    0.0000

    12.72

    0%

  • RELX

    -0.1400

    51.78

    -0.27%

  • GSK

    1.3350

    39.005

    +3.42%

  • BTI

    0.2250

    52.995

    +0.42%

  • CMSD

    -0.0690

    23.051

    -0.3%

  • NGG

    -0.0400

    70.48

    -0.06%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    13.06

    0%

  • BCE

    -0.0800

    23.58

    -0.34%

  • BCC

    -0.1900

    85.95

    -0.22%

  • AZN

    2.2450

    76.225

    +2.95%

  • RBGPF

    -3.5200

    74.03

    -4.75%

  • BP

    -0.6950

    32.265

    -2.15%

Europe to cut funds for Poland over unpaid fine
Europe to cut funds for Poland over unpaid fine

Europe to cut funds for Poland over unpaid fine

The European Commission said Tuesday it would take the unprecedented step of tapping into EU funding earmarked for Poland to collect a fine Warsaw racked up for refusing to close a coal mine.

Text size:

The EU executive has informed Poland of its decision, which will be carried out next week, a commission spokesman, Balazs Ujvari, told AFP.

Polish government spokesman Piotr Muller said Warsaw would use "all possible legal means to appeal against this," Poland's PAP news agency reported.

The cut will amount to nearly 15 million euros ($17 million) for the period between September 20 and October 19 last year. The total unpaid fine amounts to around 70 million euros including interest, according to an AFP calculation.

The Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) hit Poland with the 500,000-euro a day fine last September for refusing to comply with an order to close its Turow mine producing lignite, or brown coal.

Poland's neighbours, the Czech Republic and Germany, had complained of environmental damage the mine caused, affecting groundwater levels and creating dust and noise.

Last week, Poland signed a deal with the Czech Republic to end the dispute over the mine, which was confirmed by the court on Tuesday.

But that did not erase the CJEU fine, which Warsaw has insisted it will not pay.

- 'No legal basis' -

"From the very beginning, Poland has emphasised that the decisions taken by the CJEU had no legal or factual basis," Muller said.

"They go beyond the EU treaties and violate the treaty guarantees of energy security."

But the EU justice commissioner, Didier Reynders, insisted that the European Commission -- the Brussels executive and guardian of the EU treaties -- must be seen to uphold the decisions of the court.

"If the member state does not pay, it is obvious that we must organise, as we have said from the start, the withholding of funds," he told AFP.

"If we don't do this, no one would pay their fines anymore, obviously," he said.

Ujvari said the levied amount covering the period September 20 to October 19 would be recovered from Poland's EU funding. That comes to 14.5 million euros plus interest, which takes it close to a total of 15 million euros.

By tapping Poland's EU funding, he said, "the commission fulfils its legal obligation to collect financial penalties imposed by the court".

- Another fine -

Poland has been hit with another CJEU fine, of one million euros per day, for refusing to suspend a national Supreme Court chamber contested by Brussels.

There, too, the commission has warned it will recover the fine amount -- currently over 100 million euros -- from Poland's EU funding if it goes unpaid.

Poland's president, Andrzej Duda, has proposed a law to scrap the Supreme Court chamber in hopes of drawing a line under the dispute, which views the body as undermining judicial independence and rolling back democratic norms.

But the changes still have to be approved by Polish lawmakers, and legal observers queried whether it was merely a rebranding exercise.

Under the proposal outlined by Duda, the "disciplinary chamber" would be replaced by a different body called the "Chamber of Professional Responsibility" with 11 judges.

Poland's populist government insists reforms are needed for the judiciary to root out corruption and the legacy of judges appointed while the country was still under communist rule.

On the Turow mine deal with the Czech Republic, Poland has agreed to pay the Czechs 45 million euros in compensation in return for Prague withdrawing its complaint.

The European Court of Justice tweeted on Tuesday to confirm it had closed the case "following an amicable agreement between the Czech Republic and Poland".

Poland is reluctant to close the mine as it feeds a power station that provides around seven percent of the country's electricity needs.

Poland relies on coal to meet up to 80 percent of its energy, but has vowed to develop green energy sources and to shut its last mine by 2049, in line with EU emissions targets.

D.Smith--NZN