Zürcher Nachrichten - University tragedy brings to light 'dinosaur' student issue

EUR -
AED 4.317172
AFN 81.101136
ALL 97.497998
AMD 451.886403
ANG 2.103485
AOA 1077.822195
ARS 1439.251804
AUD 1.790072
AWG 2.118621
AZN 2.00888
BAM 1.949413
BBD 2.373524
BDT 144.20753
BGN 1.953075
BHD 0.443036
BIF 3455.61449
BMD 1.175379
BND 1.496796
BOB 8.123385
BRL 6.366673
BSD 1.175549
BTN 100.230612
BWP 15.529122
BYN 3.847096
BYR 23037.429933
BZD 2.361363
CAD 1.59603
CDF 3390.968525
CHF 0.935596
CLF 0.028377
CLP 1089.047714
CNY 8.422061
CNH 8.42621
COP 4687.294226
CRC 593.455647
CUC 1.175379
CUP 31.147546
CVE 110.338699
CZK 24.625328
DJF 209.334154
DKK 7.46154
DOP 70.346533
DZD 152.611698
EGP 58.009427
ERN 17.630686
ETB 159.205241
FJD 2.63073
FKP 0.86285
GBP 0.861253
GEL 3.197233
GGP 0.86285
GHS 12.164864
GIP 0.86285
GMD 84.042508
GNF 10174.081249
GTQ 9.038387
GYD 245.944207
HKD 9.226761
HNL 30.771734
HRK 7.536295
HTG 154.354285
HUF 399.234548
IDR 19067.469559
ILS 3.924097
IMP 0.86285
INR 100.441426
IQD 1539.746592
IRR 49512.844136
ISK 142.420591
JEP 0.86285
JMD 187.804691
JOD 0.833377
JPY 170.511659
KES 152.215209
KGS 102.786773
KHR 4726.19952
KMF 491.308716
KPW 1057.87242
KRW 1603.22884
KWD 0.358949
KYD 0.97969
KZT 610.81876
LAK 25335.296421
LBP 105313.965912
LKR 352.674524
LRD 235.661915
LSL 20.651284
LTL 3.470589
LVL 0.710975
LYD 6.323243
MAD 10.550496
MDL 19.796141
MGA 5212.805794
MKD 61.491268
MMK 2467.363196
MNT 4214.065759
MOP 9.50446
MRU 46.656187
MUR 52.70421
MVR 18.107465
MWK 2041.04342
MXN 21.941918
MYR 4.9636
MZN 75.177106
NAD 20.65172
NGN 1802.514001
NIO 43.195186
NOK 11.837919
NPR 160.368581
NZD 1.939361
OMR 0.451912
PAB 1.175549
PEN 4.179669
PGK 4.930721
PHP 66.313691
PKR 333.748609
PLN 4.241147
PYG 9372.293338
QAR 4.279081
RON 5.059298
RSD 117.193538
RUB 92.939942
RWF 1685.493598
SAR 4.407953
SBD 9.799046
SCR 16.575436
SDG 705.813148
SEK 11.254672
SGD 1.499125
SHP 0.923663
SLE 26.386973
SLL 24647.115888
SOS 671.732821
SRD 43.706526
STD 24327.973839
SVC 10.286299
SYP 15282.020337
SZL 20.651339
THB 38.153396
TJS 11.39696
TMT 4.125581
TND 3.393903
TOP 2.752858
TRY 46.820215
TTD 7.964904
TWD 33.967238
TZS 3093.055842
UAH 49.084882
UGX 4217.183145
USD 1.175379
UYU 47.095699
UZS 14815.65333
VES 128.672858
VND 30794.93185
VUV 139.810289
WST 3.057785
XAF 653.814891
XAG 0.032027
XAU 0.000353
XCD 3.176521
XDR 0.81264
XOF 654.095276
XPF 119.331742
YER 284.617826
ZAR 20.595362
ZMK 10579.825236
ZMW 28.360083
ZWL 378.471584
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

University tragedy brings to light 'dinosaur' student issue
University tragedy brings to light 'dinosaur' student issue / Photo: JORGE BERNAL - AFP

University tragedy brings to light 'dinosaur' student issue

After four people died in a Bolivian university stampede, an investigation into the role of a 52-year-old student has relaunched the debate over "dinosaur" students who never graduate.

Text size:

On May 9, someone provoked panic in a crowded amphitheatre when they threw a tear gas grenade during a student assembly at the Tomas Frias university in the southern city of Potosi.

Four people died and 70 were injured in the ensuing stampede.

Soon after, it was revealed that student union leader Max Mendoza, 52, had played a part in organizing the assembly, sparking further controversy.

In his 33 years as a student, Mendoza has never graduated, claimed legislator Hector Arce, who brandished a notebook of the union leader's marks: since 1989 he had failed more than 200 subjects and received a grade of zero more than 100 times.

The president of the Bolivian University Confederation, Mendoza is alleged to have called the student general assembly in a bid to promote the interest of fellow leaders loyal to him.

The meeting turned fractious before the smoke bomb was thrown.

Mendoza was placed in pre-trial detention on May 21, accused of several offenses including abuse of office and embezzlement.

- 'Freeloaders' -

But Mendoza's case is merely the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the thousands of "dinosaurs" staying on seemingly forever at university.

The term has been used for years in universities before it caught on at a national level, says Beymar Quisberth, a sociology student at the San Francisco Xabier university in Sucre.

According to local media, many student leaders drag out their studies in order to maintain their roles and keep the associated benefits.

It is free to attend public universities in Bolivia, and students receive discounted health care.

But students also take on management roles that include salaries.

Mendoza pockets a monthly salary of 21,869 bolivianos (around $3,150), similar to that of a rector, for his role as head of the executive committee that coordinates Bolivia's higher education institutions.

Another person accused of being a "dinosaur," Alvaro Quelali, 37, is a student leader at the San Andres university in La Paz and has apparently been studying for 20 years.

In Bolivia "it's a business being a university manager. Why study (and graduate) when you have so many benefits," said Arce.

Many students have jobs and professions outside of university and merely register as a student in order to maintain their benefits, with no intention of actually studying.

Even if they fail the final exams, they can repeat the trick the next year.

"They're freeloaders, it's a disgrace," said Gabriela Paz, 20, a student at the Faculty of Law and Political Sciences.

"These people stay at university to keep receiving handouts," added Mateo Siles, 21.

- 'Deep crisis' -

San Andres university rector Oscar Heredia says it is not just student leaders but also ordinary students who remain at university for many years.

Of the university's more than 81,000 students, 23 percent have been there more than 11 years and 6.7 percent more than 20 years.

One thousand have even been there more than 30 years and around 100 more than 40 years.

"It's something that worries us, but it's a broad issue," Heredia told AFP.

Karen Apaza, an engineering student at San Andres, says she is campaigning against "these dinosaurs who live off the university for more than 20 years."

It is a familiar scene around the country.

The Gabriel Rene Moreno university in the city of Santa Cruz has 90,000 students, of whom three percent have been there more than 10 years.

Guido Zambrana, the professor of medicine at San Andres, says it is important "to recognize that we are going through a deep crisis."

He says it's time to wipe the slate clean and "dismantle the whole structure of corruption, bad management and the co-management (between students and teachers) that has been deteriorating for decades."

"University is obsolete, it's anachronistic and does not meet the current needs" of Bolivia.

G.Kuhn--NZN