Zürcher Nachrichten - UK church court to decide on slave-link memorial

EUR -
AED 4.269035
AFN 80.781812
ALL 97.456094
AMD 446.576198
ANG 2.080099
AOA 1065.794205
ARS 1494.414015
AUD 1.786168
AWG 2.092071
AZN 1.980459
BAM 1.952133
BBD 2.345793
BDT 141.045021
BGN 1.956323
BHD 0.438891
BIF 3400.777093
BMD 1.162261
BND 1.491298
BOB 8.027918
BRL 6.486354
BSD 1.161817
BTN 100.019096
BWP 15.598695
BYN 3.802157
BYR 22780.325028
BZD 2.333716
CAD 1.596192
CDF 3354.287055
CHF 0.932713
CLF 0.029182
CLP 1119.862642
CNY 8.342655
CNH 8.346165
COP 4657.181754
CRC 586.298532
CUC 1.162261
CUP 30.799929
CVE 110.589638
CZK 24.634179
DJF 206.557568
DKK 7.463699
DOP 70.259163
DZD 151.496486
EGP 57.439973
ERN 17.433922
ETB 158.653194
FJD 2.621369
FKP 0.866542
GBP 0.866454
GEL 3.150183
GGP 0.866542
GHS 12.116623
GIP 0.866542
GMD 83.106172
GNF 10060.535793
GTQ 8.920242
GYD 243.073343
HKD 9.117767
HNL 30.626041
HRK 7.533319
HTG 152.54342
HUF 398.923459
IDR 18977.696027
ILS 3.902549
IMP 0.866542
INR 100.129761
IQD 1522.56254
IRR 48945.741055
ISK 142.354235
JEP 0.866542
JMD 185.790958
JOD 0.824089
JPY 172.949203
KES 150.51728
KGS 101.640213
KHR 4672.291561
KMF 491.989694
KPW 1046.077104
KRW 1616.942576
KWD 0.355234
KYD 0.968181
KZT 619.356427
LAK 25064.169244
LBP 104080.516031
LKR 350.521482
LRD 233.614962
LSL 20.595717
LTL 3.431856
LVL 0.703041
LYD 6.311522
MAD 10.521377
MDL 19.762872
MGA 5148.818764
MKD 61.444565
MMK 2439.88243
MNT 4168.596049
MOP 9.392835
MRU 46.281692
MUR 53.119698
MVR 17.903172
MWK 2018.271404
MXN 21.795313
MYR 4.935007
MZN 74.338683
NAD 20.595712
NGN 1779.387897
NIO 42.713547
NOK 11.840776
NPR 160.030354
NZD 1.948796
OMR 0.447149
PAB 1.161817
PEN 4.142886
PGK 4.804212
PHP 66.377189
PKR 331.157397
PLN 4.244708
PYG 8992.106697
QAR 4.231334
RON 5.072695
RSD 117.06767
RUB 91.265035
RWF 1670.750879
SAR 4.359791
SBD 9.64543
SCR 16.424358
SDG 697.942292
SEK 11.235354
SGD 1.492697
SHP 0.913355
SLE 26.62005
SLL 24372.046713
SOS 664.236693
SRD 43.245469
STD 24056.466061
STN 24.843339
SVC 10.165902
SYP 15112.221726
SZL 20.595702
THB 37.634455
TJS 11.182492
TMT 4.079538
TND 3.367657
TOP 2.722137
TRY 46.923174
TTD 7.887182
TWD 34.181766
TZS 3028.605902
UAH 48.520146
UGX 4163.178714
USD 1.162261
UYU 46.822036
UZS 14728.762822
VES 135.943958
VND 30404.760344
VUV 139.137302
WST 3.060577
XAF 654.732599
XAG 0.030439
XAU 0.000347
XCD 3.14107
XCG 2.093866
XDR 0.81565
XOF 654.353599
XPF 119.331742
YER 280.163552
ZAR 20.584075
ZMK 10461.752209
ZMW 26.750744
ZWL 374.247723
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

UK church court to decide on slave-link memorial
UK church court to decide on slave-link memorial

UK church court to decide on slave-link memorial

An ecclesiastical judge on Wednesday began hearing arguments for and against the removal of a Cambridge University college chapel memorial honouring a donor with slave trade links.

Text size:

The case is being heard by a Church of England court convened in the chapel in question at Jesus College because the item, an ornate marble plaque to Tobias Rustat, is on Church property.

Rustat was a 17th century slave-trade investor and a major donor to the college, which was founded in 1496.

The hearing comes as Britain reckons with the toxic legacy of its colonial past, and just weeks after four protesters were cleared of criminal damage for toppling a statue of 17th-century slave trader Edward Colston in Bristol.

Both Colston and Rustat were leading figures in the Royal Africa Company, which made a fortune from the trade in transporting some 150,000 human beings from West Africa.

Jesus College last year handed back a Benin Bronze cockerel sculpture to a Nigerian delegation, after it was looted in a 19th-century British expedition.

The memorial to Rustat, who was a courtier to king Charles II, dominates the west wall of the 12th-century college chapel.

The college said he "had financial and administrative involvement in the trading of enslaved human beings over a substantial period of time".

- 'Heightened feelings' -

After an introductory prayer, lawyer Mark Hill, representing the college, said it wants to display the plaque, featuring a portrait of Rustat, in another building with information on historical context.

This would mean Rustat's "life and his contribution to the college can be more fully understood", he argued at the hearing, which is expected to last several days.

Hill stressed the plan was "not in any way to erase the name of Rustat, who was a generous benefactor to the college".

A group of graduate students stood outside, holding placards with slogans backing the college's plan: "Moving not erasing" and "Churches are people not marble".

"The Rustat memorial is an obstruction to the whole college community enjoying the use of the Chapel," said one student, who declined to give his name.

The college chapel's dean James Crockford said the college acted due to "heightened feelings" about the memorial, with some students "disturbed and upset by being faced with it".

"The inscription on the memorial behind me focuses very much on the financial virtues of Tobias Rustat," he said.

The epitaph, commissioned by Rustat himself, says he earned a fortune "by God's blessing, the King's Valour and his industry".

It makes no mention of slavery, which Britain outlawed in 1833.

- 'Cancelling' a donor? -

Some alumni and descendants of Rustat however oppose removal of the memorial, arguing Rustat's donations were not profits from slavery.

In court, lawyer Justin Gau was representing a group of around 65 former students, whom he is not naming.

He attacked the college's initial proposal to put the memorial in a wine cellar and questioned the need for the chapel to be a "safe space".

"Why cannot Rustat's whole life be put into context in this building?" he asked.

Crockford said any student entering or exiting the chapel "would have to face not only the memorial but also the contextualising efforts of the college", adding he did not believe this would be "fair".

Some preservationists have criticised the planned removal, since the memorial is believed to be the work of Grinling Gibbons, a renowned Anglo-Dutch sculptor and wood carver.

The right-wing tabloid the Daily Mail has criticised the college's proposal as a move to "cancel" a historical donor, a charge the college has denied.

The newspaper also accused the college of hypocrisy since it has accepted large donations from China.

Rustat gave around £3,230 (some £500,000 or $675,000 in current money) to Jesus College, mostly to fund scholarships for children of clergy.

The Cambridge University Library said in a statement that Rustat also gave it an endowment in 1667 and was now in discussions about the fund and a statue at the original site of the facility.

"No firm decisions have been taken but preliminary inquiries are being made with Historic England to understand the process for removing a statue from the exterior of a Grade I listed building," it added.

U.Ammann--NZN