Zürcher Nachrichten - 'Fix the system': Indonesia parents seek justice after cough syrup crisis

EUR -
AED 4.350475
AFN 77.000016
ALL 96.454975
AMD 452.047591
ANG 2.120545
AOA 1086.286213
ARS 1725.238026
AUD 1.710479
AWG 2.135258
AZN 2.007664
BAM 1.951672
BBD 2.40163
BDT 145.711773
BGN 1.989397
BHD 0.449557
BIF 3532.68688
BMD 1.184609
BND 1.510131
BOB 8.239571
BRL 6.269424
BSD 1.192242
BTN 109.499298
BWP 15.600223
BYN 3.39623
BYR 23218.339784
BZD 2.398137
CAD 1.618478
CDF 2683.139764
CHF 0.916298
CLF 0.026022
CLP 1027.494776
CNY 8.235107
CNH 8.235012
COP 4347.219511
CRC 590.460955
CUC 1.184609
CUP 31.392143
CVE 110.03271
CZK 24.351003
DJF 212.331747
DKK 7.467676
DOP 75.072465
DZD 154.147531
EGP 55.878723
ERN 17.769138
ETB 185.235695
FJD 2.611648
FKP 0.865278
GBP 0.866695
GEL 3.192536
GGP 0.865278
GHS 13.062424
GIP 0.865278
GMD 86.476639
GNF 10463.043965
GTQ 9.145731
GYD 249.464409
HKD 9.250553
HNL 31.472956
HRK 7.534477
HTG 156.052534
HUF 381.797757
IDR 19913.694806
ILS 3.686918
IMP 0.865278
INR 108.607225
IQD 1562.095668
IRR 49901.661585
ISK 145.008115
JEP 0.865278
JMD 186.857891
JOD 0.839889
JPY 183.519063
KES 153.939966
KGS 103.594234
KHR 4794.938126
KMF 491.612449
KPW 1066.148258
KRW 1730.03927
KWD 0.36358
KYD 0.99369
KZT 599.696388
LAK 25660.935532
LBP 106778.978995
LKR 368.751529
LRD 214.927175
LSL 18.932911
LTL 3.497842
LVL 0.716558
LYD 7.482204
MAD 10.81612
MDL 20.055745
MGA 5328.75048
MKD 61.509887
MMK 2488.068394
MNT 4224.768089
MOP 9.588717
MRU 47.577162
MUR 54.077512
MVR 18.314459
MWK 2067.635018
MXN 20.751444
MYR 4.669768
MZN 75.530403
NAD 18.932592
NGN 1654.756728
NIO 43.877925
NOK 11.494689
NPR 175.200353
NZD 1.973375
OMR 0.457075
PAB 1.192378
PEN 3.986667
PGK 5.10431
PHP 69.772884
PKR 333.562994
PLN 4.217072
PYG 7987.138359
QAR 4.347422
RON 5.089195
RSD 117.152186
RUB 90.544141
RWF 1739.763902
SAR 4.443236
SBD 9.538015
SCR 17.104588
SDG 712.542061
SEK 10.581202
SGD 1.50757
SHP 0.888764
SLE 28.815636
SLL 24840.661178
SOS 681.469978
SRD 45.074975
STD 24519.018157
STN 24.448799
SVC 10.432843
SYP 13101.273866
SZL 18.924811
THB 37.603637
TJS 11.131048
TMT 4.146132
TND 3.425967
TOP 2.852254
TRY 51.525118
TTD 8.095909
TWD 37.508269
TZS 3057.464743
UAH 51.10611
UGX 4263.000384
USD 1.184609
UYU 46.272704
UZS 14577.164634
VES 409.805368
VND 30762.5233
VUV 140.721447
WST 3.211216
XAF 654.588912
XAG 0.015713
XAU 0.000262
XCD 3.201465
XCG 2.148954
XDR 0.814081
XOF 654.575127
XPF 119.331742
YER 282.321978
ZAR 19.247058
ZMK 10662.910096
ZMW 23.400599
ZWL 381.44367
  • RBGPF

    1.3800

    83.78

    +1.65%

  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • CMSD

    -0.0400

    24.05

    -0.17%

  • BCC

    0.5100

    80.81

    +0.63%

  • CMSC

    0.0500

    23.76

    +0.21%

  • RELX

    -0.3700

    35.8

    -1.03%

  • BTI

    0.4600

    60.68

    +0.76%

  • JRI

    0.1400

    13.08

    +1.07%

  • RYCEF

    -0.4300

    16

    -2.69%

  • RIO

    -4.1000

    91.03

    -4.5%

  • NGG

    0.2000

    85.27

    +0.23%

  • BCE

    0.3700

    25.86

    +1.43%

  • VOD

    -0.0600

    14.65

    -0.41%

  • GSK

    0.9400

    51.6

    +1.82%

  • BP

    -0.1600

    37.88

    -0.42%

  • AZN

    0.1800

    92.77

    +0.19%

'Fix the system': Indonesia parents seek justice after cough syrup crisis
'Fix the system': Indonesia parents seek justice after cough syrup crisis / Photo: BAY ISMOYO - AFP

'Fix the system': Indonesia parents seek justice after cough syrup crisis

Dinosaur-themed birthday decorations still hang on the walls of Safitri Puspa Rani's Indonesian home, where the family celebrated their youngest son's birthday last year.

Text size:

"Knock knock! Hey everyone! It's my eighth birthday!" said a beaming Panghegar Bhumi in a video in September, while making a heart-shaped gesture with his arms.

A month later he died from acute kidney injury, days after a doctor prescribed him a cough syrup containing ingredients that have been linked to more than 200 child deaths in Indonesia, according to the country's health ministry.

"I whispered in his ears: 'The medicine is coming, please hang in there a little bit more'," Rani said, crying in her home in West Java province as she recalled the final days of her son's life.

"But I lied, there was no medicine."

The 42-year-old mother is among more than two dozen Indonesian families seeking justice for their children, whom they allege were either killed or sickened by contaminated cough syrups.

Their class-action lawsuit targets the country's health ministry, food and drug agency, and eight companies they accuse of selling the syrups -- which the World Health Organization said contain an "unacceptable amount" of diethylene glycol and ethylene glycol.

"These contaminants are toxic chemicals used as industrial solvents and antifreeze agents that can be fatal even taken in small amounts, and should never be found in medicines," the WHO said in January.

Since October last year, the WHO has issued alerts for The Gambia, Indonesia and Uzbekistan over syrups containing the two chemicals.

Five-year-old Farrazka was required to undergo dialysis for his failing kidneys after he took one of the medicines, his mother Indah Septian told AFP.

"When I heard that he had to have dialysis, I was so confused and did not know what to do. He is just a kid," Septian said at her home.

"Now he gets easily fatigued even when he only does a bit of activity," the 31-year-old said.

But Septian and her husband Riski Agri consider themselves luckier than other families.

"Until today I still wake up in the middle of the night and check on him. We almost lost him," 34-year-old Agri said.

- 'Not a priority' -

Since the government sounded the alarm in October, Indonesia's food and drug agency has recalled 105 products after tests revealed excessive amounts of the two chemicals.

It has also revoked the licenses of six pharmaceutical firms.

Police have launched an investigation into five companies and arrested four suspects.

But the plaintiffs say that is not enough.

"From the beginning, this case was not considered a priority," said Awan Puryadi, the lawyer representing the families.

"All of the victims who are still alive, and are still being treated, must all be covered by the government for the rest of their lives."

They are seeking compensation of 2 billion rupiah ($131,000) for every person killed and 1 billion rupiah for every person injured.

In a hearing last month, parents wore black shirts that read "I thought it was medicine, it was poison".

The next hearing is scheduled for March 9.

One of the accused companies in the lawsuit contacted by AFP denied putting the chemicals in its cough syrups and blamed a distributor for any contamination.

Indonesia's drug regulator, like the WHO, says the chemicals should never be used in syrup medicines because they can be toxic for humans.

But it says in the event of contamination during production, the chemicals can be consumed safely up to a level of 0.1 milligrams per millilitre.

Four other companies named in the lawsuit did not respond to a request for comment and AFP was not able to reach three firms. The seven have not commented publicly on the lawsuit or the allegations.

- Expensive treatments -

Without compensation, the injured children's parents face treatment costs that many cannot afford.

Eighteen-month-old Raivan was unable to move after he consumed cough syrup prescribed by a paediatrician in May, said his mother Resti Safriti.

He is now fed through a tube, and breathes through another in his neck.

In the hopes of replicating physical therapy techniques, his parents resort to rocking him on an exercise ball in their Jakarta home.

"We could not afford therapy, so we do what we can with what we have at home," Resti said.

Resti and her husband had to leave their jobs to take care of him, and she begged the government to "fix the system" that has led to her child's suffering.

"Don't let other parents and children go through this," she said. "What if this happened to your own child?"

J.Hasler--NZN