Zürcher Nachrichten - Experts sound alarm over baby tongue surgery

EUR -
AED 4.250954
AFN 80.435512
ALL 98.809074
AMD 443.82205
ANG 2.071292
AOA 1061.293252
ARS 1370.785005
AUD 1.77269
AWG 2.083237
AZN 1.967404
BAM 1.952104
BBD 2.336277
BDT 141.402303
BGN 1.955699
BHD 0.436402
BIF 3403.777952
BMD 1.157354
BND 1.479779
BOB 7.995759
BRL 6.415094
BSD 1.157094
BTN 98.889495
BWP 15.438572
BYN 3.786682
BYR 22684.137321
BZD 2.32427
CAD 1.574158
CDF 3329.707612
CHF 0.939534
CLF 0.028056
CLP 1076.65187
CNY 8.325195
CNH 8.302493
COP 4821.247196
CRC 586.182666
CUC 1.157354
CUP 30.66988
CVE 111.511761
CZK 24.774294
DJF 205.684821
DKK 7.458961
DOP 68.572802
DZD 150.562291
EGP 57.602434
ERN 17.360309
ETB 155.83751
FJD 2.592762
FKP 0.853789
GBP 0.85143
GEL 3.165368
GGP 0.853789
GHS 11.891794
GIP 0.853789
GMD 81.590962
GNF 10016.898276
GTQ 8.892166
GYD 242.078569
HKD 9.084598
HNL 30.211636
HRK 7.534027
HTG 151.813249
HUF 401.45657
IDR 18771.123634
ILS 4.115597
IMP 0.853789
INR 99.062621
IQD 1516.133668
IRR 48724.601512
ISK 144.021195
JEP 0.853789
JMD 185.269256
JOD 0.820543
JPY 166.157258
KES 149.87624
KGS 101.21017
KHR 4649.677892
KMF 495.935758
KPW 1041.597361
KRW 1569.985055
KWD 0.353942
KYD 0.964262
KZT 591.29081
LAK 24987.271706
LBP 103698.913271
LKR 346.09628
LRD 231.012119
LSL 20.484822
LTL 3.417365
LVL 0.700071
LYD 6.295806
MAD 10.565451
MDL 19.821218
MGA 5196.519521
MKD 61.524147
MMK 2429.651047
MNT 4142.854691
MOP 9.355168
MRU 45.860132
MUR 53.030448
MVR 17.829027
MWK 2010.323434
MXN 21.895169
MYR 4.885245
MZN 74.013003
NAD 20.491273
NGN 1782.544991
NIO 42.584806
NOK 11.508913
NPR 158.220464
NZD 1.909183
OMR 0.44501
PAB 1.157094
PEN 4.205242
PGK 4.780997
PHP 64.463443
PKR 326.779047
PLN 4.271015
PYG 9233.51948
QAR 4.213636
RON 5.027199
RSD 117.243414
RUB 92.587515
RWF 1647.493341
SAR 4.341759
SBD 9.656823
SCR 16.909186
SDG 694.993322
SEK 10.93413
SGD 1.480429
SHP 0.909498
SLE 25.49075
SLL 24269.133796
SOS 661.429868
SRD 43.28098
STD 23954.889973
SVC 10.124832
SYP 15047.885194
SZL 20.496359
THB 37.455451
TJS 11.727147
TMT 4.050739
TND 3.385275
TOP 2.710639
TRY 45.545812
TTD 7.850037
TWD 34.234886
TZS 2991.760342
UAH 47.975874
UGX 4149.145009
USD 1.157354
UYU 47.809489
UZS 14663.674554
VES 115.983298
VND 30134.603342
VUV 138.692267
WST 3.178675
XAF 654.709046
XAG 0.03192
XAU 0.000342
XCD 3.127807
XDR 0.819602
XOF 664.321199
XPF 119.331742
YER 281.642355
ZAR 20.573407
ZMK 10417.597821
ZMW 28.435798
ZWL 372.667498
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Experts sound alarm over baby tongue surgery
Experts sound alarm over baby tongue surgery / Photo: PEDRO PARDO - AFP/File

Experts sound alarm over baby tongue surgery

Lea had no problems breastfeeding her newborn son when she took him to see an osteopath in Paris, who nonetheless recommended surgery to cut a "too thick" strip of tissue under his tongue.

Text size:

She said the osteopath indicated that "we don't really know why, but it's always better to have it cut".

The procedure, which is used to treat a condition called "tongue tie" that can make breastfeeding painful, has exploded in popularity in recent years but doctors warn it is often unnecessary, backed by little research and being pushed by for-profit consultants without medical training.

Called a frenotomy, the simple procedure involves snipping the thin band of tissue that connects the bottom of the tongue to the floor of the mouth.

France's National Academy of Medicine warned last month that this "aggressive and potentially dangerous procedure for newborns and infants" has seen a "spectacular increase" throughout the world.

A 2018 study found that the diagnosis of tongue tie, also known as ankyloglossia, had increased more than 10-fold in numerous countries in just a decade.

The increased awareness of the condition propelled a surge in procedures to fix it -- a report in Australia found that the number of frenotomies increased by 420 percent from 2006 to 2016.

The standard procedure, when there is a visible tight band, can be useful when tongue tie is clearly affecting a baby's ability to feed.

- 'Quick fix' -

But Lyndsay Fraser, an ear, nose, and throat surgeon in Scotland, warned that there were "potentially significant risks" from a deeper dissection at the tongue's base to divide posterior tongue tie and that in her opinion it "has no evidence base and should not be routinely offered".

Fraser told AFP she believed its rising popularity has been driven by mothers finding information on the internet -- "often factually incorrect and driven by private industry" -- as well as "extreme pressure on mums to breastfeed" and "our inclination as a society to medicalise every difficult aspect of childcare rather than just providing support".

Many mothers are "disappointed to be told there is no tongue tie and therefore no 'quick fix' to the feeding issue," Fraser said.

"Many will see private practitioners who will then divide a tongue tie for a sum of money."

Virginie Rigourd, a paediatrician at a Paris hospital, said that osteopaths and breastfeeding counsellors had contributed to the rise in frenotomies.

The website of one French breastfeeding counsellor claims that not having a frenotomy "jeopardises breastfeeding and the health of both babies and mothers," offering a 100-euro ($105) training course on the subject.

"It's not something new, it's been going on several years now," Rigourd said. "It probably started in the United States and Canada and spread."

"There is a return to breastfeeding but there is also a lack of well-trained staff to inform mothers, so there are also increasing problems" like mothers finding breastfeeding painful, Rigourd added.

- Lack of quality research -

Cochrane, a British organisation that reviews medical research, found that existing research on the procedure had "serious methodological shortcomings".

"No study was able to report whether frenotomy led to long‐term successful breastfeeding," Cochrane said.

The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine, a global organisation of doctors, last year lamented the "lack of high-quality evidence-based studies".

It said that "frenotomy can be an effective way to increase maternal comfort and breast milk transfer by the infant", but the decision to undertake the procedure "requires a high level of clinical skill, judgement and discernment".

The procedure, however, is still being offered to mothers without breastfeeding issues.

Lea turned down her osteopath's suggestion of a "preventative" frenotomy in 2018, but said she understood how other new parents might give in to the pressure.

"You want what's best for your child -- if someone tells you that having part of your child's tongue cut is best, even for no obvious reason, you go for it," she told AFP.

T.Gerber--NZN