Zürcher Nachrichten - For Ukraine doctors, treating injured Russians a necessary evil

EUR -
AED 4.209159
AFN 72.773034
ALL 94.431675
AMD 421.885636
ANG 2.05173
AOA 1051.991701
ARS 1679.34687
AUD 1.633189
AWG 2.065593
AZN 1.952681
BAM 1.954674
BBD 2.307371
BDT 140.619012
BGN 1.937681
BHD 0.43205
BIF 3420.6906
BMD 1.14596
BND 1.479048
BOB 7.916475
BRL 5.904334
BSD 1.14564
BTN 107.994975
BWP 15.568626
BYN 3.183167
BYR 22460.816
BZD 2.303983
CAD 1.622108
CDF 2612.789215
CHF 0.9253
CLF 0.026277
CLP 1034.183515
CNY 7.757696
CNH 7.774879
COP 3956.633173
CRC 519.700685
CUC 1.14596
CUP 30.36794
CVE 110.475006
CZK 24.169562
DJF 203.660462
DKK 7.467653
DOP 66.928515
DZD 152.808082
EGP 57.282517
ERN 17.1894
ETB 181.491461
FJD 2.561798
FKP 0.866014
GBP 0.868497
GEL 3.037242
GGP 0.866014
GHS 12.863447
GIP 0.866014
GMD 84.232473
GNF 10055.799407
GTQ 8.738967
GYD 239.643026
HKD 8.980682
HNL 30.579988
HRK 7.526782
HTG 149.643815
HUF 351.603891
IDR 20428.226748
ILS 3.391767
IMP 0.866014
INR 108.098984
IQD 1501.2076
IRR 1575695.000404
ISK 143.852801
JEP 0.866014
JMD 181.015746
JOD 0.812531
JPY 184.849123
KES 148.29158
KGS 100.214642
KHR 4595.300002
KMF 492.194168
KPW 1031.364401
KRW 1750.626233
KWD 0.352876
KYD 0.954625
KZT 559.063379
LAK 25274.1482
LBP 102620.7184
LKR 382.339797
LRD 208.737051
LSL 18.799519
LTL 3.383722
LVL 0.69318
LYD 7.30554
MAD 10.571526
MDL 20.230819
MGA 4813.032397
MKD 61.575685
MMK 2405.919948
MNT 4103.020778
MOP 9.248973
MRU 45.907592
MUR 54.83462
MVR 17.705515
MWK 1990.532915
MXN 19.855474
MYR 4.741872
MZN 73.238736
NAD 18.798015
NGN 1559.010254
NIO 41.954027
NOK 11.093117
NPR 172.79648
NZD 1.99756
OMR 0.441175
PAB 1.145645
PEN 3.877973
PGK 5.028186
PHP 69.578685
PKR 318.949361
PLN 4.255809
PYG 7035.009672
QAR 4.171872
RON 5.234864
RSD 117.083161
RUB 83.773397
RWF 1677.68544
SAR 4.295334
SBD 9.23807
SCR 15.68047
SDG 688.153192
SEK 10.976945
SGD 1.481043
SHP 0.855575
SLE 28.362935
SLL 24030.212419
SOS 654.920337
SRD 42.861773
STD 23719.058316
STN 24.523544
SVC 10.024227
SYP 126.665363
SZL 18.797925
THB 37.691047
TJS 10.625427
TMT 4.01086
TND 3.336749
TOP 2.759197
TRY 53.216322
TTD 7.76856
TWD 36.344165
TZS 3015.003614
UAH 51.46476
UGX 4169.598577
USD 1.14596
UYU 45.80362
UZS 13757.250183
VES 695.176764
VND 30150.2076
VUV 135.375615
WST 3.153446
XAF 655.579428
XAG 0.017669
XAU 0.000275
XCD 3.097015
XCG 2.064611
XDR 0.806409
XOF 647.46778
XPF 119.331742
YER 273.430168
ZAR 18.894019
ZMK 10315.017349
ZMW 20.535263
ZWL 368.998652
  • CMSC

    0.0500

    22.37

    +0.22%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    22.29

    0%

  • RELX

    -0.8300

    31.18

    -2.66%

  • NGG

    -1.2400

    79.44

    -1.56%

  • BCC

    3.8500

    74.66

    +5.16%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0300

    18.4

    -0.16%

  • RBGPF

    -0.5300

    60.61

    -0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0500

    12.67

    +0.39%

  • GSK

    -1.4800

    50.67

    -2.92%

  • RIO

    -2.5900

    100.08

    -2.59%

  • VOD

    -0.2300

    14.3

    -1.61%

  • BCE

    0.0000

    23.28

    0%

  • BTI

    -0.5800

    58.91

    -0.98%

  • AZN

    -2.9600

    174.93

    -1.69%

  • BP

    -1.0400

    39.1

    -2.66%

For Ukraine doctors, treating injured Russians a necessary evil
For Ukraine doctors, treating injured Russians a necessary evil / Photo: Ed JONES - AFP/File

For Ukraine doctors, treating injured Russians a necessary evil

For more than two months, Dr Farad Ali-Shakh has spent his waking hours tending wounded Ukrainian soldiers and civilians. He also treats injured Russians, albeit reluctantly, who could be part of future prisoner exchanges.

Text size:

This young doctor says he "practically lives" at the military hospital in Zaporizhzhia, a large city in southern Ukraine which lies just a few dozen kilometres from the front.

At night, the distant thud of shelling can sometimes be heard here.

Since Russia largely withdrew from northern Ukraine to refocus on the eastern Donbas region and the south, this industrial city has become a rallying point for those fleeing the violence or wounded in war.

Ali-Shakh says he works 20 hours every day, which can mean operating on up to 20 patients, one after the other.

Since the Russian invasion on February 24, thick tarpaulins have been hung up in front of the hospital's windows to make it less visible from the skies at night when it could become a target for Russian forces.

But the tarpaulins are also there to protect people from flying glass in the event of a bombing after the first houses in Zaporizhzhia were hit in a Russian strike last week.

It means the hospital is largely in darkness most of the time, even during the day. Conversations take place by the light of a desk lamp and patients' X-rays give off a ghostly hue.

And the scant light makes the photos on the doctor's mobile look even more grisly.

- 'Animals' -

One photo shows an almost totally severed leg, which is only attached by a piece of skin.

"That's something we see a lot here," Ali-Shakh says. "We were able to reconnect the blood vessels then reattach the skin."

Another shows a patient whose arm was almost cut in two, which was also saved, he explains soberly.

Asked about the emotional impact of constantly dealing with such horrific wounds, he shrugs.

"We have learnt to deal with such injuries. We are doing a difficult job but we're helping our country," he says before volunteering another surprising piece of information.

"We even treat Russian soldiers. But maybe we shouldn't. Maybe we should just leave them so they can fertilise our land."

When it comes to treating enemy soldiers, the young doctor admits to feeling a certain "lack of motivation".

"But if you help them recover, you can exchange them for Ukrainian soldiers" held captive by the Russians, he says.

Throughout the hospital, boxes of clothing and medical supplies give a sense of the ongoing emergency at the hospital.

But they are also an indication of the limited resources the surgeons must use to treat these "animals", sighs Major Viktor Pyssanko, who runs the hospital.

The Russian soldiers "are thoughtless youngsters" who are fed to the back teeth on "propaganda", he says.

They say they want to free Ukraine but "they want to kill as many Ukrainians as possible".

Even so, the hospital is trying to save as many as possible with the sole aim of "swapping them for our own soldiers", Pyssanko explains.

- Black humour -

Several prisoner exchanges have taken place since the Russian invasion began, the most high profile of which involved the mayor of the southern city of Melitopol, who was captured on March 11 then freed a few days later.

Russia's rights ombudsman Tatiana Moskalkova said he was swapped for nine Russians.

The latest prisoner exchange was on Friday, when 41 Ukrainians -- 28 soldiers and 13 civilians -- were freed, among them 11 women and a cleric. Kyiv never says how many Russians were handed back to Moscow.

Three wounded Russian soldiers were brought to Zaporizhzhia's main civilian hospital in early April with gunshot wounds and shelling injuries.

They stayed for three weeks, under constant guard, and were then handed to the Ukrainian security forces at the end of April, recalls Vasily, a doctor at the hospital who did not want to give his surname.

Vasily doesn't know what happened to them afterwards.

"They looked very depressed, devastated, not aggressive. Scared," he said.

"Because of that, we... never felt the need to express contempt" for them.

Between the doctors, where black humour is very common, "we joked about harming them. But it all ended when it came to performing and keeping our Hippocratic Oath," Vasily said.

"Yes, those are our enemies... (but) I never felt a desire to strangle" them in their beds, he said.

"If I did have those kinds of thoughts I wouldn't be working as a doctor."

T.Gerber--NZN