Zürcher Nachrichten - Syria's military hospital where detainees were tortured, not treated

EUR -
AED 4.210499
AFN 72.796213
ALL 94.461752
AMD 422.020011
ANG 2.052384
AOA 1052.326771
ARS 1679.881759
AUD 1.63659
AWG 2.066251
AZN 1.953303
BAM 1.955297
BBD 2.308106
BDT 140.663801
BGN 1.938299
BHD 0.432188
BIF 3421.780125
BMD 1.146325
BND 1.479519
BOB 7.918997
BRL 5.906215
BSD 1.146005
BTN 108.029372
BWP 15.573585
BYN 3.184181
BYR 22467.97
BZD 2.304717
CAD 1.624933
CDF 2613.621415
CHF 0.926076
CLF 0.026285
CLP 1034.512913
CNY 7.760166
CNH 7.776084
COP 3957.893401
CRC 519.866215
CUC 1.146325
CUP 30.377613
CVE 110.510194
CZK 24.17726
DJF 203.72533
DKK 7.470032
DOP 66.949832
DZD 152.856753
EGP 57.300762
ERN 17.194875
ETB 181.549268
FJD 2.562614
FKP 0.86629
GBP 0.867794
GEL 3.038209
GGP 0.86629
GHS 12.867544
GIP 0.86629
GMD 84.259302
GNF 10059.002282
GTQ 8.74175
GYD 239.719355
HKD 8.983611
HNL 30.589728
HRK 7.535022
HTG 149.691478
HUF 351.715881
IDR 20434.733348
ILS 3.402911
IMP 0.86629
INR 108.133415
IQD 1501.68575
IRR 1576196.875404
ISK 143.898619
JEP 0.86629
JMD 181.073402
JOD 0.81279
JPY 184.907999
KES 148.338813
KGS 100.246562
KHR 4596.763652
KMF 492.350937
KPW 1031.692901
KRW 1751.183826
KWD 0.352988
KYD 0.954929
KZT 559.241447
LAK 25282.198275
LBP 102653.40415
LKR 382.461576
LRD 208.803536
LSL 18.805507
LTL 3.3848
LVL 0.6934
LYD 7.307867
MAD 10.574893
MDL 20.237262
MGA 4814.565397
MKD 61.595297
MMK 2406.686258
MNT 4104.327632
MOP 9.251919
MRU 45.922214
MUR 54.852085
MVR 17.711155
MWK 1991.16692
MXN 19.883752
MYR 4.743383
MZN 73.262063
NAD 18.804002
NGN 1559.506815
NIO 41.96739
NOK 11.122344
NPR 172.851518
NZD 1.99898
OMR 0.441315
PAB 1.14601
PEN 3.879208
PGK 5.029788
PHP 69.600846
PKR 319.05095
PLN 4.257165
PYG 7037.250395
QAR 4.173201
RON 5.236532
RSD 117.120453
RUB 83.800079
RWF 1678.2198
SAR 4.296702
SBD 9.241012
SCR 15.685465
SDG 688.372376
SEK 10.992483
SGD 1.481515
SHP 0.855847
SLE 28.371969
SLL 24037.866288
SOS 655.128936
SRD 42.875425
STD 23726.613079
STN 24.531355
SVC 10.02742
SYP 126.705707
SZL 18.803912
THB 37.703052
TJS 10.628811
TMT 4.012138
TND 3.337812
TOP 2.760076
TRY 53.257148
TTD 7.771034
TWD 36.355741
TZS 3015.963923
UAH 51.481152
UGX 4170.926637
USD 1.146325
UYU 45.818209
UZS 13761.632008
VES 695.398184
VND 30159.81075
VUV 135.418733
WST 3.154451
XAF 655.788237
XAG 0.017686
XAU 0.000276
XCD 3.098001
XCG 2.065269
XDR 0.806666
XOF 647.674005
XPF 119.331742
YER 273.517259
ZAR 18.861706
ZMK 10318.306372
ZMW 20.541803
ZWL 369.116182
  • NGG

    -1.2400

    79.44

    -1.56%

  • BCC

    3.8500

    74.66

    +5.16%

  • RELX

    -0.8300

    31.18

    -2.66%

  • CMSC

    0.0500

    22.37

    +0.22%

  • BCE

    0.0000

    23.28

    0%

  • RBGPF

    -0.5300

    60.61

    -0.87%

  • RIO

    -2.5900

    100.08

    -2.59%

  • GSK

    -1.4800

    50.67

    -2.92%

  • AZN

    -2.9600

    174.93

    -1.69%

  • JRI

    0.0500

    12.67

    +0.39%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0300

    18.4

    -0.16%

  • BTI

    -0.5800

    58.91

    -0.98%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    22.29

    0%

  • VOD

    -0.2300

    14.3

    -1.61%

  • BP

    -1.0400

    39.1

    -2.66%

Syria's military hospital where detainees were tortured, not treated
Syria's military hospital where detainees were tortured, not treated / Photo: Bakr ALKASEM - AFP

Syria's military hospital where detainees were tortured, not treated

Former Syrian detainee Mohammed Najib has suffered for years from torture-induced back pain. Yet he dreaded being taken by his jailers to a military hospital, where he received beatings instead of treatment.

Text size:

The prison guards forbade him from revealing his condition, only sending him to hospital for his likely tuberculosis symptoms -- widespread in the notorious Saydnaya prison where he was detained.

Doctors at Tishreen Hospital, the largest military health facility in Damascus, never inquired about the hunch on his back -- the result of sustained abuse.

Freed just hours after the fall of Bashar al-Assad, Najib has a tennis ball-sized bulge on his lower back.

The 31-year-old can barely walk, and the pain is unbearable.

But he insisted on showing AFP around a jail in the military hospital compound.

"I hated being brought here," Najib said as he returned with two friends who had shared the same cell with him after they were accused of ties to the armed rebellion that sought Assad's overthrow.

"They hit us all the time, and because I couldn't walk easily, they hit me" even more, he said, referring the guards.

Because he was never allowed to say he had anything more than the tuberculosis symptoms of "diarrhoea and fever", he never received proper treatment

"I went back and forth for nothing," he said.

Assad fled Syria last month after Islamist-led rebels wrested city after city from his control until Damascus fell, ending his family's five-decade rule.

The Assads left behind a harrowing legacy of abuse at detention facilities that were sites of extrajudicial executions, torture and forced disappearances.

Hours after Assad fled, Syrian rebels broke into the notorious Saydnaya prison, freeing thousands, some there since the 1980s.

Since then, Tishreen Hospital has been out of service pending an investigation.

- 'Assisting torture' -

Human rights advocates say Syria's military hospitals, most notably Tishreen, have a record of neglect and ill-treatment.

"Some medical practitioners that were in some of these military hospitals (were) assisting... interrogations and torture, and maybe even withholding treatments to detainees," Hanny Megally of the UN Commission of Inquiry on Syria told AFP.

Former Saydnaya detainees told AFP about the ordeals they went through after they got sick.

It would begin with a routine examination by two of the jail's military doctors.

One of them used to beat prisoners, sometimes to death, four ex-detainees said.

Guards relentlessly beat them from the moment they were pulled from their cells to the hospital jail, then to its main building to meet the doctors, and finally escorted back to prison.

At the hospital's jail, those who were too ill were left to die or even killed, several former detainees said.

Three years ago, Najib and other inmates were tortured using the "tyre" method inside Saydnaya for merely talking to each other.

They were forced into vehicle tyres and beaten with their foreheads against their knees or ankles.

After a first check-up by a military doctor at Saydnaya, Najib was prescribed painkillers for his back pain.

The doctor eventually accepted to transfer him to Tishreen Hospital for tuberculosis symptoms.

Former prisoners said guards looking to minimise their workload would order them to say they suffered from "diarrhoea and fever" so they could transfer everyone to the same department.

- 'Clean him' -

When Omar al-Masri, 39, was taken to the hospital with a torture-induced leg injury, he too told a doctor he had an upset stomach and a fever.

While he was awaiting treatment, a guard ordered him to "clean" a very sick inmate.

Masri wiped the prisoner's face and body, yet when the guard returned, he angrily repeated the same order: "Clean him".

As Masri repeated the task, the sick prisoner soon took his last breath. An agitated Masri called out to the guard who gave him a chilling response: "Well done."

"That is when I learnt that by 'clean him', he meant 'kill him'," he said.

According to a 2023 report by the Association of Detainees and the Missing in Sednaya Prison, security forces at the hospital jail and even medical and administrative staff inflicted physical and psychological violence on detainees.

A civilian doctor told AFP she and other medical staff at Tishreen were under strict orders to keep conversations with prisoners to a minimum.

"We weren't allowed to ask what the prisoner's name was or learn anything about them," she said, requesting anonymity for fear of reprisals.

She said that despite reports about ill treatment at the hospital, she had not witnessed it herself.

But even if a doctor was courageous enough to ask about a prisoner's name, the scared detainee would only give the number assigned to him by the guards.

"They weren't allowed to speak," she said.

After a beating in his Saydnaya cell, Osama Abdul Latif's ribs were broken, but the prison doctors only transferred him to the hospital four months later with a large protrusion on his side.

Abdul Latif and other detainees had to stack the bodies of three fellow inmates into the transfer vehicle and unloaded them at Tishreen hospital.

"I was jailed for five years," Abdul Latif said.

But "250 years wouldn't be enough to talk about all the suffering" he endured.

O.Meier--NZN