Zürcher Nachrichten - 'Cruel measure': Dominican crackdown on Haitian hospitals

EUR -
AED 4.303866
AFN 82.246636
ALL 98.022155
AMD 449.672262
ANG 2.097289
AOA 1074.647591
ARS 1391.81353
AUD 1.792196
AWG 2.112381
AZN 1.983424
BAM 1.955245
BBD 2.364528
BDT 143.229313
BGN 1.955245
BHD 0.441775
BIF 3488.009166
BMD 1.171917
BND 1.494276
BOB 8.091701
BRL 6.421523
BSD 1.171067
BTN 100.139554
BWP 15.656552
BYN 3.832411
BYR 22969.575067
BZD 2.352332
CAD 1.609804
CDF 3376.293764
CHF 0.947844
CLF 0.028433
CLP 1091.11005
CNY 8.405576
CNH 8.406068
COP 4731.255999
CRC 590.63222
CUC 1.171917
CUP 31.055803
CVE 110.233686
CZK 24.729442
DJF 208.54076
DKK 7.459954
DOP 69.670209
DZD 151.086081
EGP 58.232458
ERN 17.578756
ETB 158.20126
FJD 2.62656
FKP 0.854056
GBP 0.864979
GEL 3.187919
GGP 0.854056
GHS 12.121557
GIP 0.854056
GMD 83.802267
GNF 10146.117808
GTQ 9.006442
GYD 244.900432
HKD 9.197188
HNL 30.599308
HRK 7.534842
HTG 153.526388
HUF 398.896875
IDR 19027.538938
ILS 3.968943
IMP 0.854056
INR 100.146758
IQD 1534.064221
IRR 49367.008147
ISK 141.98978
JEP 0.854056
JMD 187.676687
JOD 0.830867
JPY 171.117466
KES 151.357004
KGS 102.418534
KHR 4694.666393
KMF 492.800389
KPW 1054.725415
KRW 1599.174691
KWD 0.358361
KYD 0.975923
KZT 609.226938
LAK 25253.826183
LBP 104926.493688
LKR 351.200235
LRD 234.213467
LSL 20.971743
LTL 3.460367
LVL 0.708881
LYD 6.342198
MAD 10.573496
MDL 19.832366
MGA 5148.537463
MKD 61.512526
MMK 2460.63412
MNT 4200.047241
MOP 9.46971
MRU 46.702733
MUR 52.923561
MVR 18.058624
MWK 2030.623164
MXN 22.100029
MYR 4.95545
MZN 74.955972
NAD 20.971743
NGN 1809.134841
NIO 43.097757
NOK 11.809736
NPR 160.223486
NZD 1.935294
OMR 0.448972
PAB 1.171067
PEN 4.156619
PGK 4.830628
PHP 66.342269
PKR 332.140449
PLN 4.240795
PYG 9345.345282
QAR 4.268587
RON 5.081312
RSD 117.146722
RUB 92.123831
RWF 1691.019635
SAR 4.393252
SBD 9.782389
SCR 17.186418
SDG 703.739475
SEK 11.120913
SGD 1.494165
SHP 0.920943
SLE 26.367183
SLL 24574.519824
SOS 669.209899
SRD 44.293815
STD 24256.317781
SVC 10.247089
SYP 15237.096358
SZL 20.967044
THB 38.151768
TJS 11.54662
TMT 4.113429
TND 3.423527
TOP 2.744751
TRY 46.659877
TTD 7.948742
TWD 34.106297
TZS 3085.923386
UAH 48.82633
UGX 4209.804127
USD 1.171917
UYU 47.176599
UZS 14739.812883
VES 124.93046
VND 30581.176601
VUV 139.344496
WST 3.208109
XAF 655.770716
XAG 0.032565
XAU 0.000358
XCD 3.167165
XDR 0.815568
XOF 655.770716
XPF 119.331742
YER 283.896734
ZAR 20.854193
ZMK 10548.660838
ZMW 27.725124
ZWL 377.356827
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

'Cruel measure': Dominican crackdown on Haitian hospitals
'Cruel measure': Dominican crackdown on Haitian hospitals / Photo: Erickson POLANCO - AFP

'Cruel measure': Dominican crackdown on Haitian hospitals

Still in pain from giving birth, a Haitian mother carrying her newborn was helped onto a migration services bus in the Dominican Republic, joining a family member who was arrested when he visited her in hospital.

Text size:

Both were detained in a series of raids on Dominican health facilities, launched just over a week ago in the country's latest drive to eject undocumented migrants.

Since early 2024, more than 350,000 Haitians have been deported from the comparatively wealthy and stable Dominican Republic, shuttled across the 340-kilometer (211-mile) border with poverty and gang-violence riddled Haiti.

Dominican President Luis Abinader has championed a MAGA-style hard line on migration since first coming to power in 2020, with mass expulsions of Haitians and the construction of a wall that so far stretches across more than half the border.

Now, his administration has turned its attention to public hospitals, flushing out migrants who may have gone under the radar if it wasn't for the fact that they needed medical attention.

Arresting and deporting new mothers, "I don't like that.... women must be respected," Haitian Erony Auguste, 42, told AFP from the migration bus next to his sister-in-law who had recently given birth.

He claimed he was detained at the hospital despite having residency papers.

For William Charpentier, coordinator of the National Bureau for Migration and Refugees, a Dominican-based rights group, "mixing health with the issue of border control... is really a violation of human rights. It seems a very cruel measure."

Migrants seek the group's help daily, he told AFP, adding they are afraid to seek medical and maternal care for fear of being arrested and expelled from the country so many Haitians see as their only hope for a better life.

The measure "puts people, mainly women, at risk," said Charpentier.

Martin Ortiz Garcia of the Dominican National Health Service (SNS), confirmed the number of Haitians seeking hospital treatment has dropped.

- 'Everyone is afraid' -

Since 2010, the Dominican Republic does not grant birthright citizenship to children born in the country to undocumented migrants. A 2013 court ruling backdated the restriction to people born as far back as 1929.

Last year, Abinader's government deported over 276,200 Haitians and is on track to exceed that number with more than 86,400 deportations in the first quarter of 2025 alone.

"Of course, everyone is afraid. Sometimes even people with papers are arrested, even Dominicans are arrested if they leave home without papers," merchant Marie Casale, 63, told AFP in the capital Santo Domingo.

The Dominican Migration Service reported that on Day 1 of the hospital crackdown, 48 pregnant women, 39 new mothers, and 48 children were arrested and taken to a detention center for deportation.

At the center, 34-year-old Dominican national Santo Heredia waited, desperate for news of his wife, who is five months pregnant and was detained after a prenatal appointment.

His wife, said Heredia, was born in the Dominican Republic to Haitian parents, but has not been able to legalize her status in the country as they did not have enough money to file the paperwork.

The couple has another daughter, 4.

"She is alone, she has no money on her, she has no means of communicating with anyone," he told AFP. "This has me really tormented, honestly."

Last year, 36 out of every 100 births in Dominican hospitals were to Haitian women, according to Ortiz Garcia of the SNS.

Public hospitals require patients to provide identification, proof of employment and residence, and payment for services rendered.

But Ortiz Garcia insisted care is not denied to the undocumented.

"Illegals are treated in emergencies. If they need admission, they are admitted, and then after their medical event, they go through the migration protocol," he told AFP.

Many migrants from Haiti, a Creole- and French-speaking nation of some 11 million people of mainly African descent, are fleeing violent gangs that control about 85 percent of Port-au-Prince, the capital of the poorest country in the Americas.

Many in the Spanish-speaking Dominican Republic have turned on those of their neighbors who cross the border, accusing them of usurping Dominican jobs and resources.

A nationalist group calling itself "Ancient Dominican Order," has been campaigning against the "Haitianization" of the country and has urged the authorities to be "vigilant at all maternity wards."

On Sunday, two migration trucks with Haitians being deported were jeered at as they drove past a group of nationalist protesters shouting "Go back to your country" and "Out! Out!"

S.Scheidegger--NZN