Zürcher Nachrichten - 'A broken man': Russian sisters see father scarred by Ukraine fight

EUR -
AED 4.241201
AFN 76.219915
ALL 93.210974
AMD 421.7986
AOA 1060.156793
ARS 1727.958172
AUD 1.63908
AWG 2.081626
AZN 1.959559
BAM 1.954403
BBD 2.32254
BDT 142.738005
BHD 0.43488
BIF 3440.896583
BMD 1.154855
BND 1.478624
BOB 14.004993
BRL 5.916207
BSD 1.153151
BTN 109.628664
BWP 15.63742
BYN 3.410563
BYR 22635.15384
BZD 2.319233
CAD 1.618125
CDF 2611.126427
CHF 0.932311
CLF 0.026733
CLP 1055.559908
CNY 7.795147
CNH 7.793913
COP 3675.544784
CRC 522.915026
CUC 1.154855
CUP 30.603652
CVE 110.186265
CZK 24.201154
DJF 205.338828
DKK 7.47541
DOP 67.250199
DZD 153.530983
EGP 57.54318
ERN 17.322822
ETB 186.117873
FJD 2.553963
FKP 0.857848
GBP 0.857774
GEL 3.019946
GGP 0.857848
GHS 13.520339
GIP 0.857848
GMD 84.878181
GNF 10128.411837
GTQ 8.795715
GYD 241.227629
HKD 9.058306
HNL 30.907112
HRK 7.534038
HTG 150.767698
HUF 362.223087
IDR 20682.294394
ILS 3.477385
IMP 0.857848
INR 109.932764
IQD 1510.627108
IRR 1587694.361999
ISK 141.792902
JEP 0.857848
JMD 183.243508
JOD 0.818791
JPY 182.181232
KES 149.439303
KGS 100.991685
KHR 4673.518854
KMF 493.12343
KRW 1638.640772
KWD 0.357023
KYD 0.961017
KZT 541.135669
LAK 26067.486096
LBP 103263.512096
LKR 386.906578
LRD 208.141271
LSL 18.917964
LTL 3.409986
LVL 0.69856
LYD 7.339597
MAD 10.74762
MDL 20.03577
MGA 4908.365176
MKD 61.481068
MMK 2424.552772
MNT 4152.673297
MOP 9.316283
MRU 46.240358
MUR 54.209096
MVR 17.842347
MWK 1999.510632
MXN 19.917775
MYR 4.721853
MZN 73.807157
NAD 18.917964
NGN 1572.381111
NIO 42.438205
NOK 11.00856
NPR 175.401109
NZD 1.964222
OMR 0.444037
PAB 1.153176
PEN 3.903611
PGK 5.170149
PHP 70.148769
PKR 320.189388
PLN 4.30117
PYG 6876.93715
QAR 4.215887
RON 5.244777
RSD 117.358631
RUB 93.515578
RWF 1693.938243
SAR 4.333626
SBD 9.317771
SCR 16.99798
SDG 693.483603
SEK 10.953417
SGD 1.479663
SLE 28.408276
SOS 659.009126
SRD 43.501064
STD 23903.162464
STN 24.481764
SVC 10.089834
SZL 18.902002
THB 38.159872
TJS 10.643495
TMT 4.041992
TND 3.383582
TRY 54.964638
TTD 7.82126
TWD 37.289687
TZS 3055.166026
UAH 51.602087
UGX 4300.926733
USD 1.154855
UYU 46.366868
UZS 13708.204675
VES 871.004473
VND 30288.376519
VUV 137.825311
WST 3.151849
XAF 655.468764
XAG 0.018606
XAU 0.000271
XCD 3.121053
XCG 2.078224
XDR 0.815196
XOF 655.474435
XPF 119.331742
YER 273.556256
ZAR 18.867557
ZMK 10395.078432
ZMW 22.01327
ZWL 371.86277
  • CMSC

    -0.0600

    21.73

    -0.28%

  • RYCEF

    0.6000

    21

    +2.86%

  • BCE

    0.0600

    22.06

    +0.27%

  • JRI

    -0.0500

    12.67

    -0.39%

  • CMSD

    0.0200

    22.04

    +0.09%

  • NGG

    -0.1600

    80.26

    -0.2%

  • GSK

    -0.0700

    51.46

    -0.14%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.74

    0%

  • BCC

    -1.6900

    84.8

    -1.99%

  • RIO

    2.5000

    101.51

    +2.46%

  • RELX

    -0.1900

    36.61

    -0.52%

  • BTI

    0.1500

    59.27

    +0.25%

  • VOD

    -0.3800

    15.31

    -2.48%

  • BP

    -1.2300

    41.21

    -2.98%

  • AZN

    5.8800

    161.5

    +3.64%

'A broken man': Russian sisters see father scarred by Ukraine fight
'A broken man': Russian sisters see father scarred by Ukraine fight / Photo: Olga MALTSEVA - AFP

'A broken man': Russian sisters see father scarred by Ukraine fight

In the picture, Anastasaia and Elizaveta Grigoryeva's father is faintly smiling, smartly dressed from head to toe in military uniform and holding a puppy to the camera.

Text size:

It's an image of their father no longer recognisable to the 18-year-old twin sisters -- not since he left to fight in Ukraine some six months ago and returned a "broken man".

"He was there for the most intense fighting, under shelling, everything," Elizaveta tells AFP.

"He says himself, being shelled for six hours will change a man. And so many deaths. He needs medical help," she adds.

The psychological scars her father has brought home from the battlefield has built pressure on a family already at odds over whether the conflict is justified.

And their story points to a broader issue, one uncomfortable for the Kremlin -- that fighting in Ukraine is taking a harsh toll at home and tearing apart some families. Elizaveta believes many more veterans will return traumatised.

The sisters, who are staunchly opposed to the military intervention in Ukraine, live in Pskov near Russia's border with Estonia.

The medieval city of around 200,000 people is also home to the 76th Guards Air Assault Division -- their father's paratrooper unit.

In January, Grigoryev told his daughters he was leaving just for a few days for military drills in Belarus.

He wouldn't return for six months.

- 'War is a crime' -

His unit took part in the calamitous assault for Kyiv that ended with the Russia's withdrawal from northern of Ukraine in March.

Investigative journalists have placed the unit around that time near the Ukrainian town of Bucha, where Kyiv and international investigators have accused Russian forces of executing civilians.

Russia denies harming civilians but Anastasia and Elizaveta wonder if their father could have somehow been involved.

"He says he didn't kill anyone," says Elizaveta.

"But war is a crime in and of itself," Anastasia answers.

"Yeah, so, supporting or taking part in the war is already a crime," concludes Elizaveta.

The sisters were shocked when Putin announced Russia's military invention, and in early March took to the streets, carrying signs that read: "Peace in Ukraine, Freedom in Russia."

Turnout was low at the protest in Pskov and the sisters were immediately detained.

They were threatened with jail time by police but eventually released.

Instead there were ordered to pay a fine equivalent to around 330 euros for "organising" an illegal gathering.

While Anastasia and Elizaveta were entangled in legal problems at home, their father's well-being was deteriorating.

In May, the 43-year-old soldier asked his family to start the administrative process needed to return him from the front.

He left the battlefield "for health reasons" in mid-June and is now going through the procedure to be discharged from the army after around 20 years of service.

"That much stress has changed how he sees the world. He lost comrades. He saw corpses everywhere," Elizaveta says.

New legislation introduced in Russia against maligning the military means he could face jail time if he speaks publically about his experiences in Ukraine.

- Need 'democracy at home' -

But in the privacy of his home and cottage in the countryside, his daughters said he spoke openly about what he witnessed.

They say however that he sometimes becomes aggressive, and the three fight regularly. He is not seeking psychological help.

The girls left the family home last month after the situation there had become untenable.

A women's rights organisation helped them find a flat to live in, and they are partly living off money they gathered from a crowd-funding campaign for their fine.

Still, they do not want to break ties entirely with their family.

"We love our father. We're not going to reject our own family," Elizaveta says.

But she and Anastasia say they avoid speaking about the conflict with their father and 38-year-old mother.

Unlike their parents -- who like many Russians of their generation stay clear of politics -- the sisters are still politically active and became interested in politics from an early age.

They said they had been drawn in by the sleek video investigations and political statements of Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny, who is serving a sentence for fraud.

The sisters say they have no intention of halting their political activism despite their parents' disapproval.

They are "absolutely not afraid" of being imprisoned and even admire "the strength" of Ukrainian people who they say are facing extreme violence.

"We're liberal," says Elizaveta. "We criticise the government. We need to build democracy at home."

E.Leuenberger--NZN