Zürcher Nachrichten - The shadowy messengers delivering threats to Hong Kong civil society

EUR -
AED 4.109274
AFN 78.314666
ALL 98.397081
AMD 432.900753
ANG 2.00226
AOA 1025.922471
ARS 1273.264389
AUD 1.746459
AWG 2.013806
AZN 1.922366
BAM 1.955007
BBD 2.260584
BDT 136.024847
BGN 1.954732
BHD 0.421548
BIF 3283.623349
BMD 1.118781
BND 1.455175
BOB 7.735967
BRL 6.356888
BSD 1.119596
BTN 95.665487
BWP 15.171527
BYN 3.664078
BYR 21928.11504
BZD 2.248969
CAD 1.562434
CDF 3210.902409
CHF 0.935323
CLF 0.027388
CLP 1051.005439
CNY 8.063033
CNH 8.061312
COP 4698.881794
CRC 567.995086
CUC 1.118781
CUP 29.647707
CVE 110.843266
CZK 24.934843
DJF 198.829801
DKK 7.459476
DOP 65.952347
DZD 148.913177
EGP 56.111591
ERN 16.781721
ETB 148.582746
FJD 2.543941
FKP 0.841177
GBP 0.841139
GEL 3.065668
GGP 0.841177
GHS 13.884243
GIP 0.841177
GMD 80.552287
GNF 9683.616935
GTQ 8.601512
GYD 234.235027
HKD 8.733129
HNL 29.032565
HRK 7.53589
HTG 146.337206
HUF 402.470475
IDR 18482.044634
ILS 3.978443
IMP 0.841177
INR 95.588737
IQD 1465.603607
IRR 47100.696195
ISK 144.680499
JEP 0.841177
JMD 178.467639
JOD 0.793553
JPY 162.983665
KES 144.887419
KGS 97.837332
KHR 4495.264022
KMF 492.834098
KPW 1006.85955
KRW 1564.044831
KWD 0.343879
KYD 0.933034
KZT 571.743733
LAK 24188.053236
LBP 100242.811343
LKR 334.179439
LRD 223.309998
LSL 20.171951
LTL 3.303471
LVL 0.676739
LYD 6.176799
MAD 10.39425
MDL 19.503354
MGA 5073.673251
MKD 61.551031
MMK 2348.935324
MNT 3999.804794
MOP 9.004649
MRU 44.32589
MUR 51.329962
MVR 17.296474
MWK 1942.204225
MXN 21.797887
MYR 4.791186
MZN 71.492617
NAD 20.305897
NGN 1791.828671
NIO 41.126165
NOK 11.656639
NPR 153.064779
NZD 1.904904
OMR 0.430553
PAB 1.119561
PEN 4.122149
PGK 4.548978
PHP 62.424057
PKR 315.053432
PLN 4.24695
PYG 8938.375852
QAR 4.073475
RON 5.10477
RSD 117.197719
RUB 89.501511
RWF 1589.78834
SAR 4.196374
SBD 9.346708
SCR 16.222445
SDG 671.809547
SEK 10.880316
SGD 1.451959
SHP 0.879187
SLE 25.393737
SLL 23460.286378
SOS 639.869156
SRD 40.658192
STD 23156.515747
SVC 9.79651
SYP 14545.677413
SZL 20.305891
THB 37.199151
TJS 11.593199
TMT 3.921329
TND 3.375919
TOP 2.620304
TRY 43.417069
TTD 7.603189
TWD 33.766167
TZS 3012.521361
UAH 46.433156
UGX 4086.343154
USD 1.118781
UYU 46.643173
UZS 14516.188123
VES 105.208003
VND 29029.579847
VUV 134.312142
WST 3.093872
XAF 655.720437
XAG 0.034283
XAU 0.000345
XCD 3.023563
XDR 0.821899
XOF 645.536963
XPF 119.331742
YER 273.11901
ZAR 20.18897
ZMK 10070.373934
ZMW 29.899278
ZWL 360.247148
  • RBGPF

    0.8100

    63.81

    +1.27%

  • CMSC

    0.1350

    22.1

    +0.61%

  • RYCEF

    0.2600

    10.79

    +2.41%

  • SCS

    -0.0400

    10.5

    -0.38%

  • GSK

    1.3500

    37.57

    +3.59%

  • CMSD

    0.1200

    22.38

    +0.54%

  • BCC

    0.2500

    90.99

    +0.27%

  • JRI

    0.1035

    12.74

    +0.81%

  • RIO

    0.7200

    62.75

    +1.15%

  • BCE

    0.3700

    21.63

    +1.71%

  • VOD

    0.2300

    9.27

    +2.48%

  • BTI

    0.8200

    41.37

    +1.98%

  • RELX

    0.9800

    54.04

    +1.81%

  • NGG

    2.6000

    70.03

    +3.71%

  • AZN

    1.7300

    67.96

    +2.55%

  • BP

    -0.2500

    30.11

    -0.83%

The shadowy messengers delivering threats to Hong Kong civil society
The shadowy messengers delivering threats to Hong Kong civil society

The shadowy messengers delivering threats to Hong Kong civil society

Covert meetings, whispered threats, and mysterious phone calls –- warnings of reprisals by authorities from shadowy messengers are hounding Hong Kong's civil society as China flattens a pro-democracy movement.

Text size:

Unlike the Chinese mainland, Hong Kong long hosted a vibrant landscape of citizens' groups who cultivated rights advocacy, union mobilisation and civil disobedience as a key fabric of the once-outspoken city.

But a national security law imposed by Beijing in 2020 to snuff out dissent has knee-capped the sector, leaving people fearful that the law's vaguely defined crimes will be used to target their work.

More than 50 civil society groups specialising on issues ranging from labour to education have since announced their closure or been shuttered after national security arrests.

Often the pre-emptive shutdowns came after staff were subjected to a shadowy campaign of threats and intimidation, according to five people AFP spoke to with firsthand knowledge.

The warnings typically arrived via phone calls and messages from so-called "middlemen", who assumed a conversational tone while revealing knowledge of each recipient's personal life. Some came face to face.

Veteran NGO worker Mario -- using a pseudonym due to fears for his safety -- said his colleagues received disconcerting messages from several middlemen last summer.

"They would tell you different stories but at some point the conversation would reach the same conclusion: you must shut down," he told AFP.

A month after first contact, Mario's organisation made the decision to close.

- 'We respect civil society' -

Hong Kong's civil society groups have in recent years been labelled "anti-China elements" by officials and state media.

Beijing has made clear it believes they were a key part of democracy protests that exploded in 2019 with huge rallies and frequent clashes with police.

The national security law's vague language, combined with the middlemen's warnings, suddenly made the threat of lengthy jail terms very real for people like Mario.

"Every normal thing civil society did in the past three decades is now subject to political reprisal," he said.

Shuttered organisations range from the city's largest trade union to Amnesty International, as well as the Hong Kong Alliance -- which used to organise the annual vigil remembering victims of China's Tiananmen Square crackdown in 1989.

Hong Kong's leader Carrie Lam has repeatedly denied that a deliberate campaign targeting organisations is taking place, insisting "we respect civil society".

China's ruling Communist Party and its Liaison Office in Hong Kong have openly accused some groups of violating the law, calling the collapse of these organisations "a choice of their own making".

Both China's Public Security Ministry and its Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office did not respond to requests for comment from AFP.

The city's Security Bureau and the Committee for Safeguarding National Security also declined to comment on what they called "allegations by individuals".

- New sheriff in town -

Under a "One Country, Two Systems" principle that Beijing agreed to before the 1997 handover by Britain, Hong Kong was allowed to retain key freedoms and autonomy for 50 years.

These included the city being left to police itself using its own laws.

The national security law changed all that, toppling the legal firewall that existed between the financial hub and Beijing.

Among the legislation's many precedent-setting provisions was a clause empowering the mainland's security apparatus to operate openly in Hong Kong.

Days after the law's enactment, mainland security officials requisitioned a hotel for their staff -- unbound by local laws -- as they conducted investigations on perceived threats to China.

The middlemen are regarded as an extension of this new sheriff in town, according to two sources who told AFP they had been contacted directly.

Both described similar face-to-face meetings but asked for key details to be omitted to maintain anonymity.

The meetings were held in a pre-booked private room at public businesses and featured a Cantonese-speaking man claiming to be a mainland security agent.

The conversations stayed largely polite but could flip -- with one source saying the agent he met sounded at times "as if he was interrogating me".

Another said the middleman asked what he thought about disbanding his group, citing various possible security law breaches.

"At first I thought it would be silly to disband when we didn't know what offences we have committed," he told AFP.

"But when he could name a very specific charge, we started to worry."

The messengers possessed personal information, both recalled, dropping details of their relatives and daily habits into conversation.

AFP was not able to independently verify the sources' accounts.

- 'Approach of intimidation' -

The use of middlemen to channel information and deliver political messages is not new.

Beijing's presence in Hong Kong is maintained through the Liaison Office, which has played an increasingly prominent advisory role in recent years -- at times calling in local establishment politicians to be briefed by Chinese officials.

For opposition figures, Beijing preferred using middlemen, according to Ted Hui, a former opposition lawmaker now in Australia.

Such meetings were commonplace -- mainly as intelligence-gathering for authorities' decisions -- until one year before the 2019 protests, he said.

"But after the security law came in, it became an approach of intimidation... So under the table, they can send those middlemen to say things the government cannot openly say."

More than 160 people have been arrested under the national security law so far -- most of them opposition politicians, journalists and rights workers.

Against the backdrop of these detentions, the slow-burn whisper campaign has been an effective tool to shut down organisations critical of the government.

"We are so inexperienced that many of us decided to disband under these threats," said Connie, a rights worker who said she received a call from a stranger giving her a deadline to quit.

Oliver, another rights worker, said he got a text message from someone posing as a "friend" warning he could be arrested.

With so many other groups shuttering and new arrests each month, Oliver felt compelled to take the threat seriously and decided to fold.

"If all those big groups... were not spared, how could you be?"

W.Odermatt--NZN