Zürcher Nachrichten - Lacking other options, UN Security Council takes watchdog role in Ukraine war

EUR -
AED 4.228067
AFN 80.383983
ALL 98.10387
AMD 441.284464
ANG 2.061135
AOA 1055.770402
ARS 1363.739473
AUD 1.777413
AWG 2.072395
AZN 1.977516
BAM 1.958821
BBD 2.326509
BDT 140.809629
BGN 1.954731
BHD 0.434468
BIF 3430.881144
BMD 1.151331
BND 1.479921
BOB 7.962489
BRL 6.406806
BSD 1.152307
BTN 99.153795
BWP 15.488293
BYN 3.770849
BYR 22566.083632
BZD 2.31457
CAD 1.568993
CDF 3312.378533
CHF 0.935882
CLF 0.028015
CLP 1075.066731
CNY 8.259189
CNH 8.271316
COP 4783.779464
CRC 580.795812
CUC 1.151331
CUP 30.510266
CVE 110.435334
CZK 24.834295
DJF 205.186477
DKK 7.45892
DOP 68.055559
DZD 150.132323
EGP 57.264772
ERN 17.269962
ETB 155.454722
FJD 2.591996
FKP 0.847369
GBP 0.850344
GEL 3.148903
GGP 0.847369
GHS 11.868615
GIP 0.847369
GMD 81.177303
GNF 9984.399807
GTQ 8.854734
GYD 241.071826
HKD 9.037319
HNL 30.073646
HRK 7.539262
HTG 151.114389
HUF 403.406161
IDR 18789.258084
ILS 4.142275
IMP 0.847369
INR 99.124399
IQD 1509.441253
IRR 48471.026532
ISK 144.192657
JEP 0.847369
JMD 184.484547
JOD 0.81628
JPY 165.932675
KES 148.80932
KGS 100.683605
KHR 4620.246597
KMF 491.046275
KPW 1036.286653
KRW 1577.547681
KWD 0.352424
KYD 0.960206
KZT 591.01671
LAK 24861.345814
LBP 103244.533238
LKR 345.015144
LRD 230.457456
LSL 20.736764
LTL 3.399581
LVL 0.696428
LYD 6.29571
MAD 10.535441
MDL 19.73295
MGA 5203.025078
MKD 61.587897
MMK 2417.238479
MNT 4122.005399
MOP 9.315568
MRU 45.744954
MUR 52.14346
MVR 17.73629
MWK 1997.981661
MXN 21.887892
MYR 4.887976
MZN 73.627742
NAD 20.736764
NGN 1784.769935
NIO 42.406143
NOK 11.442153
NPR 158.646072
NZD 1.916534
OMR 0.442694
PAB 1.152307
PEN 4.159087
PGK 4.813466
PHP 64.713991
PKR 326.666383
PLN 4.274706
PYG 9194.260965
QAR 4.20332
RON 5.033383
RSD 117.206698
RUB 91.813859
RWF 1663.909749
SAR 4.321075
SBD 9.610608
SCR 16.897497
SDG 691.370833
SEK 10.964262
SGD 1.477693
SHP 0.904765
SLE 25.386493
SLL 24142.807011
SOS 658.532872
SRD 43.06345
STD 23830.222981
SVC 10.082551
SYP 14969.701767
SZL 20.723504
THB 37.346289
TJS 11.63775
TMT 4.029658
TND 3.409518
TOP 2.696531
TRY 45.402497
TTD 7.814052
TWD 34.045424
TZS 2987.703348
UAH 47.795519
UGX 4152.440737
USD 1.151331
UYU 47.37348
UZS 14640.708801
VES 116.233613
VND 30020.950546
VUV 138.117784
WST 3.164809
XAF 656.987448
XAG 0.031756
XAU 0.000336
XCD 3.111529
XDR 0.812537
XOF 656.970302
XPF 119.331742
YER 280.176324
ZAR 20.728904
ZMK 10363.353262
ZMW 27.856692
ZWL 370.728047
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Lacking other options, UN Security Council takes watchdog role in Ukraine war
Lacking other options, UN Security Council takes watchdog role in Ukraine war

Lacking other options, UN Security Council takes watchdog role in Ukraine war

Unable to assure global peace, the UN Security Council is consigned to a watchdog role in the Russia-Ukraine conflict, with little else to do but set more urgent sessions this week on the crisis.

Text size:

After five meetings since Russia's invasion of its eastern European neighbor on February 24, the 15-member council will gather again on Monday for two sessions on humanitarian aid -- one public and one behind closed doors.

"Exposing the situation in the Security Council, even if you know that the outcome is going to be stopped through a veto, is still worthwhile," said the European Union's ambassador to the UN, Olof Skoog.

"Pressure" is the aim, several council members told AFP, with representatives even vying to call for sessions. The United States and Albania joined together to convene the first meeting on the conflict, while France and Mexico are pushing for a resolution, though its future is unclear.

With its veto power, Russia -- one of the five permanent members of the council that also includes 10 other members elected for two years -- has the power to block any declaration or resolution.

As the founding document of the organization established after World War II, the UN Charter cannot oust one of the five permanent members even if the state violates the body's fundamental principle of not resorting to violence to resolve a crisis -- as Russia stands accused of doing.

However, the charter does provide for cases in which the Security Council can take action.

Article 27 stipulates that a council member can abstain from voting when it is party to a conflict on which there is a vote. In practice, this doesn't always happen.

Russia has never abstained from a vote on Syria -- deploying its veto some 15 times in 10 years -- nor has the United States or Britain on Iraq, France on Mali or the United Arab Emirates over Yemen.

"There has not been any real appetite to go after" Article 27, said a Western ambassador on condition of anonymity.

- 'Privilege' of permanence -

A spokesperson for British Prime Minister Boris Johnson recently said that expelling Russia from the Security Council figures among the "options."

But in reality, "no," it's not on the table, said another diplomat, also speaking on condition of anonymity.

Article 6 of the UN Charter says if a member "has persistently violated the Principles" of the document, it "may be expelled from the Organization by the General Assembly upon recommendation of the Security Council."

Therein lies the issue: veto-wielding Russia will never recommend its own expulsion to the 193-member General Assembly.

Such an attempt has only been made once in the history of the global body, in 1974, when several countries urged the Security Council to exclude South Africa, according to SC Procedure, a specialized news outlet.

The resolution received 10 votes in favor, but France, Britain and the United States vetoed, it added.

The permanent members, which also include China, sometimes "have each other's back," the Western ambassador said.

"They don't agree with all substance always, but they do agree that the privilege is something that sets them a little bit above the rest of us."

Under the impetus of the EU, the General Assembly -- where there are no vetoes -- had looked to succeed where the Security Council failed by adopting a resolution condemning Russia on March 2.

A record 141 countries from across every continent approved the non-binding text, with just five in opposition: Russia, Belarus, Eritrea, Syria and North Korea.

Beyond the council and the assembly, the UN has deployed other wings to try to help mitigate the fallout of the war.

The UN humanitarian affairs agency OCHA, the refugees body UNHCR and the World Food Programme have stepped up responses to the crisis, while the Human Rights Council recently backed the creation of an international commission of inquiry into abuses in Ukraine.

UN chief Antonio Guterres, who has long denounced the "dysfunction" of global governance, is working behind the scenes but to little avail so far, having offered mediation to Russia, which rebuffed any idea of the secretary-general going to Moscow, according to an official.

P.Gashi--NZN