Zürcher Nachrichten - Lacking oversight, Telegram thrives in Ukraine disinformation battle

EUR -
AED 4.002304
AFN 73.00692
ALL 98.450983
AMD 421.795421
ANG 1.965091
AOA 993.767096
ARS 1081.771634
AUD 1.646206
AWG 1.961382
AZN 1.8485
BAM 1.954001
BBD 2.201473
BDT 130.300029
BGN 1.95583
BHD 0.410625
BIF 3154.5562
BMD 1.089657
BND 1.434719
BOB 7.551255
BRL 6.311402
BSD 1.090296
BTN 91.70439
BWP 14.519032
BYN 3.568413
BYR 21357.271682
BZD 2.197837
CAD 1.512656
CDF 3098.983317
CHF 0.939475
CLF 0.03766
CLP 1039.151346
CNY 7.744954
CNH 7.757588
COP 4810.834412
CRC 559.584773
CUC 1.089657
CUP 28.875903
CVE 110.763657
CZK 25.330174
DJF 193.653936
DKK 7.458526
DOP 65.870107
DZD 145.010879
EGP 53.554996
ERN 16.344851
ETB 131.947844
FJD 2.444315
FKP 0.833772
GBP 0.839259
GEL 2.980215
GGP 0.833772
GHS 17.826724
GIP 0.833772
GMD 77.91317
GNF 9403.737167
GTQ 8.424244
GYD 228.316068
HKD 8.46933
HNL 27.317758
HRK 7.506678
HTG 143.487886
HUF 409.248885
IDR 17166.234011
ILS 4.08515
IMP 0.833772
INR 91.665138
IQD 1427.450301
IRR 45879.996373
ISK 148.901432
JEP 0.833772
JMD 172.281375
JOD 0.772896
JPY 165.876807
KES 140.566121
KGS 93.491947
KHR 4440.351248
KMF 493.069382
KPW 980.690801
KRW 1501.767072
KWD 0.333827
KYD 0.908688
KZT 532.779453
LAK 23907.068298
LBP 97633.241745
LKR 319.665674
LRD 209.05075
LSL 19.08029
LTL 3.217473
LVL 0.659122
LYD 5.241024
MAD 10.729816
MDL 19.463615
MGA 5028.766035
MKD 61.618207
MMK 3539.162517
MNT 3702.65356
MOP 8.729403
MRU 43.586229
MUR 50.156923
MVR 16.783562
MWK 1891.099436
MXN 21.96336
MYR 4.73567
MZN 69.629724
NAD 19.079534
NGN 1791.166788
NIO 40.072162
NOK 11.956106
NPR 146.726943
NZD 1.815602
OMR 0.419536
PAB 1.090426
PEN 4.106099
PGK 4.368975
PHP 63.539516
PKR 302.76083
PLN 4.360767
PYG 8587.09359
QAR 3.967004
RON 4.975436
RSD 117.033166
RUB 107.056772
RWF 1486.291764
SAR 4.09318
SBD 9.050929
SCR 14.619895
SDG 655.430168
SEK 11.644182
SGD 1.435838
SHP 0.833772
SLE 24.762415
SLL 22849.553073
SOS 622.19344
SRD 38.035566
STD 22553.694064
SVC 9.540216
SYP 2737.795487
SZL 19.079858
THB 36.627179
TJS 11.612528
TMT 3.824695
TND 3.376835
TOP 2.552089
TRY 37.429916
TTD 7.391398
TWD 34.791664
TZS 2934.85201
UAH 45.192505
UGX 3990.32598
USD 1.089657
UYU 45.428173
UZS 13963.950977
VEF 3947338.707134
VES 46.640617
VND 27611.901246
VUV 129.366267
WST 3.052329
XAF 655.371622
XAG 0.032303
XAU 0.0004
XCD 2.944852
XDR 0.819068
XOF 654.341741
XPF 119.331742
YER 272.250711
ZAR 19.030147
ZMK 9808.222785
ZMW 29.248875
ZWL 350.869019
  • RBGPF

    66.4100

    66.41

    +100%

  • RYCEF

    0.0100

    7.11

    +0.14%

  • BCC

    0.0500

    134.26

    +0.04%

  • CMSC

    0.1100

    24.64

    +0.45%

  • NGG

    0.1900

    64.45

    +0.29%

  • SCS

    0.1100

    12.25

    +0.9%

  • RELX

    -0.0200

    47.06

    -0.04%

  • CMSD

    0.1103

    24.92

    +0.44%

  • RIO

    -0.3200

    65.01

    -0.49%

  • VOD

    -0.0300

    9.32

    -0.32%

  • JRI

    0.0500

    13.1

    +0.38%

  • GSK

    0.0900

    36.97

    +0.24%

  • BTI

    0.0400

    35.11

    +0.11%

  • BCE

    -2.9800

    29.12

    -10.23%

  • AZN

    0.0100

    71.43

    +0.01%

  • BP

    0.5000

    29.73

    +1.68%

Lacking oversight, Telegram thrives in Ukraine disinformation battle
Lacking oversight, Telegram thrives in Ukraine disinformation battle

Lacking oversight, Telegram thrives in Ukraine disinformation battle

Two days after Russia invaded Ukraine, an account on the Telegram messaging platform posing as President Volodymyr Zelensky urged his armed forces to surrender.

Text size:

The message was not authentic, with the real Zelensky soon denying the claim on his official Telegram channel, but the incident highlighted a major problem: disinformation quickly spreads unchecked on the encrypted app.

The fake Zelensky account reached 20,000 followers on Telegram before it was shut down, a remedial action that experts say is all too rare.

For Oleksandra Tsekhanovska, head of the Hybrid Warfare Analytical Group at the Kyiv-based Ukraine Crisis Media Center, the effects are both near- and far-reaching.

"For Telegram, accountability has always been a problem, which is why it was so popular even before the full scale war with far-right extremists and terrorists from all over the world," she told AFP from her safe house outside the Ukrainian capital.

Telegram boasts 500 million users, who share information individually and in groups in relative security. But Telegram's use as a one-way broadcast channel -- which followers can join but not reply to -- means content from inauthentic accounts can easily reach large, captive and eager audiences.

False news often spreads via public groups, or chats, with potentially fatal effects.

"Someone posing as a Ukrainian citizen just joins the chat and starts spreading misinformation, or gathers data, like the location of shelters," Tsekhanovska said, noting how false messages have urged Ukrainians to turn off their phones at a specific time of night, citing cybersafety.

Such instructions could actually endanger people -- citizens receive air strike warnings via smartphone alerts.

- 'Wild West' -

In addition, Telegram's architecture limits the ability to slow the spread of false information: the lack of a central public feed, and the fact that comments are easily disabled in channels, reduce the space for public pushback.

Although some channels have been removed, the curation process is considered opaque and insufficient by analysts.

Emerson Brooking, a disinformation expert at the Atlantic Council's Digital Forensic Research Lab, said: "Back in the Wild West period of content moderation, like 2014 or 2015, maybe they could have gotten away with it, but it stands in marked contrast with how other companies run themselves today."

WhatsApp, a rival messaging platform, introduced some measures to counter disinformation when Covid-19 was first sweeping the world.

For example, WhatsApp restricted the number of times a user could forward something, and developed automated systems that detect and flag objectionable content.

Unlike Silicon Valley giants such as Facebook and Twitter, which run very public anti-disinformation programs, Brooking said: "Telegram is famously lax or absent in its content moderation policy."

As a result, the pandemic saw many newcomers to Telegram, including prominent anti-vaccine activists who used the app's hands-off approach to share false information on shots, a study from the Institute for Strategic Dialogue shows.

- 'Unverified information' -

Again, in contrast to Facebook, Google, and Twitter, Telegram's founder Pavel Durov runs his company in relative secrecy from Dubai.

On February 27, however, he admitted from his Russian-language account that "Telegram channels are increasingly becoming a source of unverified information related to Ukrainian events."

He said that since his platform does not have the capacity to check all channels, it may restrict some in Russia and Ukraine "for the duration of the conflict," but then reversed course hours later after many users complained that Telegram was an important source of information.

Oleksandra Matviichuk, a Kyiv-based lawyer and head of the Center for Civil Liberties, called Durov’s position, "very weak," and urged concrete improvements.

"He has to start being more proactive and to find a real solution to this situation, not stay in standby without interfering. It's a very irresponsible position from the owner of Telegram," she said.

In the United States, Telegram's lower public profile has helped it mostly avoid high level scrutiny from Congress, but it has not gone unnoticed.

Some people used the platform to organize ahead of the storming of the US Capitol in January 2021, and last month Senator Mark Warner sent a letter to Durov urging him to curb Russian information operations on Telegram.

Asked about its stance on disinformation, Telegram spokesperson Remi Vaughn told AFP: "As noted by our CEO, the sheer volume of information being shared on channels makes it extremely difficult to verify, so it's important that users double-check what they read."

But the Ukraine Crisis Media Center's Tsekhanovska points out that communications are often down in zones most affected by the war, making this sort of cross-referencing a luxury many cannot afford.

F.Carpenteri--NZN