Zürcher Nachrichten - Ukraine invasion places sharp new focus on calls for UN reform

EUR -
AED 3.987216
AFN 76.828736
ALL 100.672482
AMD 421.61557
ANG 1.95687
AOA 947.286867
ARS 1006.830354
AUD 1.643746
AWG 1.953983
AZN 1.849317
BAM 1.958572
BBD 2.192403
BDT 127.580565
BGN 1.955563
BHD 0.409144
BIF 3127.926967
BMD 1.085546
BND 1.460066
BOB 7.502618
BRL 6.090241
BSD 1.085837
BTN 90.889336
BWP 14.732851
BYN 3.553429
BYR 21276.709006
BZD 2.188698
CAD 1.497419
CDF 3110.090711
CHF 0.959759
CLF 0.037274
CLP 1028.449366
CNY 7.885081
CNH 7.886809
COP 4377.346359
CRC 575.61467
CUC 1.085546
CUP 28.766979
CVE 110.42128
CZK 25.413733
DJF 193.353654
DKK 7.462605
DOP 64.280977
DZD 146.212634
EGP 52.497891
ERN 16.283196
ETB 62.764731
FJD 2.442804
FKP 0.836479
GBP 0.840218
GEL 2.947289
GGP 0.836479
GHS 16.829819
GIP 0.836479
GMD 73.54564
GNF 9357.243342
GTQ 8.424924
GYD 227.171517
HKD 8.477146
HNL 26.889056
HRK 7.498901
HTG 143.322845
HUF 393.521254
IDR 17608.322131
ILS 3.961935
IMP 0.836479
INR 90.867937
IQD 1422.413147
IRR 45706.93012
ISK 149.698961
JEP 0.836479
JMD 169.930503
JOD 0.769325
JPY 166.54345
KES 144.377532
KGS 91.432643
KHR 4459.31128
KMF 492.566586
KPW 976.99212
KRW 1498.195011
KWD 0.331775
KYD 0.904881
KZT 514.628355
LAK 24067.062203
LBP 97234.416234
LKR 329.606493
LRD 211.729662
LSL 19.878935
LTL 3.205336
LVL 0.656636
LYD 5.247427
MAD 10.735494
MDL 19.311331
MGA 4933.983085
MKD 61.707335
MMK 3525.812291
MNT 3745.135379
MOP 8.734362
MRU 42.975824
MUR 50.727492
MVR 16.673894
MWK 1882.764684
MXN 19.947989
MYR 5.072213
MZN 69.366404
NAD 19.878935
NGN 1727.918556
NIO 39.966565
NOK 11.960062
NPR 145.422817
NZD 1.825536
OMR 0.417873
PAB 1.085837
PEN 4.080776
PGK 4.197941
PHP 63.538148
PKR 302.398586
PLN 4.295206
PYG 8223.638947
QAR 3.961306
RON 4.970497
RSD 117.066414
RUB 93.569109
RWF 1426.118391
SAR 4.072254
SBD 9.201032
SCR 14.773244
SDG 636.130319
SEK 11.679182
SGD 1.456499
SHP 0.836479
SLE 24.801807
SLL 22763.368749
SOS 620.578307
SRD 31.645871
STD 22468.618312
SVC 9.500446
SYP 2727.468242
SZL 19.874128
THB 39.059007
TJS 11.563866
TMT 3.810268
TND 3.372473
TOP 2.579909
TRY 35.657594
TTD 7.380446
TWD 35.495522
TZS 2923.200566
UAH 44.779477
UGX 4038.71601
USD 1.085546
UYU 43.581681
UZS 13664.339191
VEF 3932448.782374
VES 39.635285
VND 27529.456143
VUV 128.878278
WST 3.043447
XAF 656.886694
XAG 0.036972
XAU 0.000447
XCD 2.933744
XDR 0.818959
XOF 656.886694
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.766681
ZAR 19.857851
ZMK 9771.225722
ZMW 28.285032
ZWL 349.545491
  • CMSD

    -0.2250

    24.19

    -0.93%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    24.1

    0%

  • BCC

    -0.5600

    133.59

    -0.42%

  • SCS

    -0.4900

    13.61

    -3.6%

  • NGG

    0.6550

    62.695

    +1.04%

  • GSK

    0.3900

    39.23

    +0.99%

  • JRI

    -0.0890

    12.481

    -0.71%

  • BP

    -0.1100

    34.84

    -0.32%

  • RIO

    0.1900

    63.72

    +0.3%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2300

    5.69

    -4.04%

  • BTI

    0.0300

    33.38

    +0.09%

  • BCE

    0.1830

    33.073

    +0.55%

  • RBGPF

    1.3500

    58.25

    +2.32%

  • RELX

    -0.1150

    45.235

    -0.25%

  • AZN

    0.3200

    79.49

    +0.4%

  • VOD

    -0.0050

    9.075

    -0.06%

Ukraine invasion places sharp new focus on calls for UN reform
Ukraine invasion places sharp new focus on calls for UN reform

Ukraine invasion places sharp new focus on calls for UN reform

The long-simmering debate over UN reform -- and particularly over the role of the Security Council, which does not represent today's world and which failed to prevent Russia's invasion of Ukraine -- has suddenly become acute.

Text size:

Recently Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, in a blistering call for the UN to exclude Russia from the Security Council, asked bluntly, "Are you ready to close the UN" and abandon international law. "If your answer is no, then you need to act immediately."

And after the Security Council failed to prevent the brutal invasion of his country, he said in a separate address to Japanese lawmakers, "We have to develop a new tool" capable of doing so.

Created in 1945 with a vision of guaranteeing world peace and preventing a World War III, the United Nations conferred disproportionate power on the five permanent, veto-wielding members of the Security Council -- the US, Russia, China, Britain and France -- in a way that allows them to protect their own interests while keeping a heavy hand in world affairs.

Thus, since 2011, Moscow has exercised its Security Council veto some 15 times in votes regarding its ally Syria.

But the veto power also guarantees that Moscow can never be removed from the Council, since the UN Charter's Article 6 allows the General Assembly to exclude a member only ... upon the recommendation of the Security Council.

In that vein, the US and Britain invaded Iraq in 2003 without UN approval -- and without suffering any consequences for their permanent seats on the Security Council.

Beyond the veto question, and the lack of international balance among Security Council members -- no African or Latin American country holds a permanent seat -- the Council grants a near-monopoly on some issues to Washington, London and Paris.

The division of roles among the 15 Security Council members is uneven, according to the ambassador of one of the current 10 non-permanent members. The latter group, elected for two-year terms, is "given the bureaucratic jobs."

"We don't think it's a fair division of labor," the ambassador said, speaking on grounds of anonymity.

The Council has been widely denounced for its current -- and recurrent -- paralysis, with even UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres deploring its failures.

"There's a pretty fundamental problem there," US Secretary of State Antony Blinken admitted, a day after Zelensky's futile call for Russia to be expelled.

- 'Like cholesterol' -

To Bertrand Badie, a Paris-based international relations specialist, the United Nations is "like cholesterol": "There is the good," notably in the humanitarian aid the UN dispenses that saves lives around the world, and "there is the bad, with the Security Council."

But the ambassador, while conceding that there has been "intense criticism" of the world body, added: "Where would we be if we had none of that?" -- none of the "good" carried out by the UN.

Most proposals for reform call for the enlargement of the Security Council -- adding both permanent and non-permanent members.

But "positions are very polarized," the ambassador said, as to which nations might be added and which would enjoy veto power.

"The veto has to be a bit more disciplined," the diplomat said, adding that the point of it should not be "to block progress" but to "force the five permanent members to sit down and arrive at a solution acceptable to all."

At an informal meeting Friday on UN reform that included the five permanent members, the veto issue was again raised.

Among the ideas advanced: a French-Mexican proposal to limit its use in cases of "mass crimes," and a suggestion from Liechtenstein that would require any nation casting a veto to explain it before the General Assembly.

On Thursday, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, whose country hopes someday to join the permanent members of the Security Council, said that "the entire peace and security architecture of the United Nations needs to be overhauled."

The Council, he said, needed to be "democratized" to allow the world body to "move beyond the paralysis brought about by a few member states."

Other potential permanent members of the Council include major world players India, Japan, Brazil and Germany.

But several experts say the chances of reform will remain slim so long as the permanent members refuse to accept any dilution of their power.

A.P.Huber--NZN