Zürcher Nachrichten - If Iran's Khamenei falls, what would replace him?

EUR -
AED 4.328809
AFN 82.32194
ALL 97.94282
AMD 453.235397
ANG 2.109145
AOA 1080.722757
ARS 1448.704312
AUD 1.793086
AWG 2.121376
AZN 2.031031
BAM 1.954659
BBD 2.379911
BDT 144.595584
BGN 1.954441
BHD 0.444297
BIF 3511.350038
BMD 1.178542
BND 1.500824
BOB 8.145245
BRL 6.397954
BSD 1.178712
BTN 100.500327
BWP 15.57091
BYN 3.857448
BYR 23099.422319
BZD 2.367718
CAD 1.601314
CDF 3400.09344
CHF 0.935026
CLF 0.028472
CLP 1092.31966
CNY 8.444725
CNH 8.438142
COP 4707.70941
CRC 595.052602
CUC 1.178542
CUP 31.231362
CVE 110.200664
CZK 24.651326
DJF 209.89746
DKK 7.461714
DOP 70.458865
DZD 152.874592
EGP 58.170709
ERN 17.678129
ETB 162.592277
FJD 2.634868
FKP 0.865172
GBP 0.862964
GEL 3.205274
GGP 0.865172
GHS 12.199878
GIP 0.865172
GMD 84.268441
GNF 10220.033439
GTQ 9.062709
GYD 246.606029
HKD 9.25149
HNL 30.796021
HRK 7.532029
HTG 154.769644
HUF 399.611163
IDR 19116.480855
ILS 3.955629
IMP 0.865172
INR 100.612561
IQD 1544.098539
IRR 49646.07983
ISK 142.414863
JEP 0.865172
JMD 188.310063
JOD 0.835601
JPY 169.552703
KES 152.303394
KGS 103.063387
KHR 4731.237855
KMF 492.63034
KPW 1060.719093
KRW 1605.021252
KWD 0.35962
KYD 0.982327
KZT 612.462438
LAK 25398.172285
LBP 105612.942075
LKR 353.623551
LRD 236.332027
LSL 20.643348
LTL 3.479928
LVL 0.712888
LYD 6.347294
MAD 10.575626
MDL 19.849412
MGA 5176.977627
MKD 61.504051
MMK 2474.002727
MNT 4225.405565
MOP 9.530036
MRU 46.747708
MUR 52.880919
MVR 18.14229
MWK 2044.006688
MXN 22.146442
MYR 4.976963
MZN 75.379359
NAD 20.643348
NGN 1801.519941
NIO 43.374677
NOK 11.877523
NPR 160.800123
NZD 1.942211
OMR 0.453159
PAB 1.178712
PEN 4.197949
PGK 4.866159
PHP 66.38768
PKR 334.497117
PLN 4.249392
PYG 9397.513635
QAR 4.295592
RON 5.060894
RSD 117.185988
RUB 92.898619
RWF 1693.211486
SAR 4.419782
SBD 9.825415
SCR 17.01932
SDG 707.691851
SEK 11.253896
SGD 1.500555
SHP 0.926149
SLE 26.45788
SLL 24713.439845
SOS 673.606741
SRD 44.012627
STD 24393.439003
SVC 10.313979
SYP 15323.143366
SZL 20.652943
THB 38.157066
TJS 11.427628
TMT 4.136682
TND 3.429098
TOP 2.760261
TRY 46.977858
TTD 7.986337
TWD 34.066105
TZS 3107.271779
UAH 49.216967
UGX 4228.53134
USD 1.178542
UYU 47.222431
UZS 14842.334892
VES 129.019113
VND 30877.799222
VUV 140.18651
WST 3.066014
XAF 655.574269
XAG 0.031993
XAU 0.000352
XCD 3.185068
XDR 0.814826
XOF 655.574269
XPF 119.331742
YER 285.383588
ZAR 20.651705
ZMK 10608.311781
ZMW 28.436399
ZWL 379.490029
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

If Iran's Khamenei falls, what would replace him?
If Iran's Khamenei falls, what would replace him? / Photo: ATTA KENARE - AFP

If Iran's Khamenei falls, what would replace him?

Israel increasingly appears eager to oust the clerical leadership that has ruled Iran since the 1979 Islamic revolution but is taking a gamble given the Iranian opposition is divided and there is no guarantee new rulers would be any less hardline, analysts say.

Text size:

By striking targets other than nuclear or ballistic facilities, such as Iran's IRIB broadcaster, expectations have grown that Israel has goals beyond degrading Iranian atomic and missile capabilities and eyes removing supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

But while President Donald Trump has warned "we know" where Khamenei "is hiding", what would follow his removal after over three-and-a-half decades in power is shrouded in uncertainty and risk.

European leaders are haunted by the aftermath of the US-led invasion of Iraq in 2003 and the NATO-led intervention in Libya in 2011.

They resulted in the removal of dictators Saddam Hussein and Moamer Kadhafi but also in years of bloody mayhem in both countries.

"The biggest mistake today is to seek regime change in Iran through military means because that would lead to chaos," French President Emmanuel Macron said at the end of the G7 summit in Canada.

"Does anyone think that what was done in Iraq in 2003... or what was done in Libya the previous decade was a good idea? No!" Macron said.

Analysts say ousting Khamenei and his fellow clerical leaders risks creating a vacuum that could be filled by hardline elements in the Revolutionary Guards (IRGC) ideological force or the Iranian military.

"Israel's strikes seem more focused on regime change than non-proliferation," said Nicole Grajewski, fellow at the Carnegie Endowment.

"Of course Israel is targeting ballistic missile and military related facilities but they are also targeting leadership and symbols of the regime like the IRIB," she told AFP.

"If the regime were to fall, the hope would be for a liberal and democratic government.

"However, there is a strong likelihood that other powerful entities like the IRGC could emerge as the replacement," she said.

- 'No organised alternative' -

Among the highest-profile opposition figures is the US-based Reza Pahlavi, the son of ousted shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi.

He has declared that the Islamic republic is "on the verge of collapse", accusing Khamenei of "hiding underground" like a "frightened rat".

Pahlavi has long called for the restoration of the warm relationship that existed between his late father and Israel, to reverse the Islamic republic's refusal to recognise the existence of Israel.

Monarchists would like such a rapprochement to be termed the "Cyrus Accords" after the ancient Persian king credited with freeing the Jews from Babylon.

But Pahlavi is far from enjoying universal support inside Iran or among exiles.

The nationalism of supporters and his ties with Israel are divisive, especially after he refused to condemn the Israeli air strikes on Iran.

Another major organised group is the People's Mujahedin (MEK), whose leader Maryam Rajavi told the European Parliament on Wednesday: "The people of Iran want the overthrow of this regime."

But the MEK is despised by other opposition factions and regarded with suspicion by some Iranians for its support of Saddam Hussein in the Iran-Iraq war.

"Part of the challenge in thinking about alternatives to the Islamic Republic in case it collapses is that there is no organised, democratic alternative," said Thomas Juneau, professor at the University of Ottawa.

He said that while Reza Pahlavi is the opposition leader "who has by far the most name recognition both in and out of Iran", his supporters "tend to exaggerate his support inside the country".

"The only alternative -- and this is among the worrying scenarios -- is a coup d'etat by the Revolutionary Guards or changing from a theocracy to a military dictatorship."

- 'Unpredictable scenario' -

Analysts also warn that a potential -- and often overlooked -- factor for future instability could be Iran's complex ethnic make-up.

Large Kurdish, Arab, Baluch and Turkic minorities co-exist alongside the Persian population.

"There will also be an effort to capitalise on ethnic divisions by hostile countries," said Grajewski.

Analysts at the US-based think tank Soufan Center said that with the survival of the Iranian regime now viewed as a "strategic failure", the prospect of an "Iraq 2.0" is looming.

"The post-regime-change scenario remains unpredictable and could trigger regional destabilisation on a scale greater than Iraq, with global ramifications," they said.

E.Leuenberger--NZN