Zürcher Nachrichten - Disinformation shifting views on Ukrainian refugees

EUR -
AED 4.13829
AFN 79.087751
ALL 97.963551
AMD 433.29456
ANG 2.016415
AOA 1033.175425
ARS 1287.232792
AUD 1.747458
AWG 2.03086
AZN 1.912611
BAM 1.954015
BBD 2.275122
BDT 136.904934
BGN 1.954183
BHD 0.424732
BIF 3353.140987
BMD 1.126691
BND 1.457913
BOB 7.803045
BRL 6.381126
BSD 1.126871
BTN 96.218102
BWP 15.247732
BYN 3.687631
BYR 22083.13851
BZD 2.263432
CAD 1.571024
CDF 3234.729232
CHF 0.939491
CLF 0.027662
CLP 1061.511342
CNY 8.122877
CNH 8.126015
COP 4705.623877
CRC 570.179127
CUC 1.126691
CUP 29.857305
CVE 110.164362
CZK 24.90663
DJF 200.662923
DKK 7.46098
DOP 66.399343
DZD 149.701112
EGP 56.399436
ERN 16.900361
ETB 151.750605
FJD 2.551447
FKP 0.848708
GBP 0.842117
GEL 3.08678
GGP 0.848708
GHS 13.860768
GIP 0.848708
GMD 81.681716
GNF 9758.085749
GTQ 8.652096
GYD 235.751958
HKD 8.810096
HNL 29.320215
HRK 7.53339
HTG 147.445305
HUF 402.366074
IDR 18540.653819
ILS 4.001842
IMP 0.848708
INR 96.269185
IQD 1476.151499
IRR 47447.735595
ISK 145.918183
JEP 0.848708
JMD 179.565962
JOD 0.7988
JPY 163.321147
KES 145.59131
KGS 98.529441
KHR 4516.97386
KMF 497.43542
KPW 1014.021666
KRW 1567.666391
KWD 0.346123
KYD 0.939021
KZT 575.514254
LAK 24368.495773
LBP 100965.405927
LKR 337.931291
LRD 225.371119
LSL 20.348012
LTL 3.326825
LVL 0.681523
LYD 6.21732
MAD 10.407093
MDL 19.639623
MGA 5070.525463
MKD 61.533675
MMK 2365.703411
MNT 4026.769715
MOP 9.07739
MRU 44.65121
MUR 52.075343
MVR 17.418096
MWK 1953.975694
MXN 21.9152
MYR 4.834648
MZN 71.995888
NAD 20.348012
NGN 1806.761805
NIO 41.462123
NOK 11.600244
NPR 153.949363
NZD 1.905527
OMR 0.433743
PAB 1.126806
PEN 4.154305
PGK 4.683721
PHP 62.750476
PKR 318.383149
PLN 4.269287
PYG 9000.777568
QAR 4.107148
RON 5.03753
RSD 117.132996
RUB 90.305018
RWF 1613.675995
SAR 4.225821
SBD 9.397084
SCR 16.017983
SDG 676.575663
SEK 10.904446
SGD 1.458079
SHP 0.885402
SLE 25.579909
SLL 23626.141719
SOS 644.031668
SRD 41.216035
STD 23320.223544
SVC 9.859993
SYP 14649.077337
SZL 20.342417
THB 37.244456
TJS 11.634833
TMT 3.949051
TND 3.391502
TOP 2.638824
TRY 43.761231
TTD 7.649012
TWD 33.969841
TZS 3027.984587
UAH 46.89486
UGX 4121.23515
USD 1.126691
UYU 47.007058
UZS 14555.703007
VES 106.141281
VND 29238.188056
VUV 136.467096
WST 3.130538
XAF 655.378654
XAG 0.03458
XAU 0.000347
XCD 3.044938
XDR 0.821734
XOF 655.358314
XPF 119.331742
YER 275.029402
ZAR 20.329765
ZMK 10141.562288
ZMW 30.399555
ZWL 362.793959
  • CMSC

    0.0100

    22.06

    +0.05%

  • RBGPF

    1.5000

    64.5

    +2.33%

  • CMSD

    -0.0400

    22.02

    -0.18%

  • RYCEF

    0.2000

    10.9

    +1.83%

  • SCS

    -0.1600

    10.34

    -1.55%

  • RIO

    -0.5000

    62.14

    -0.8%

  • GSK

    0.0850

    37.725

    +0.23%

  • NGG

    0.3300

    71.61

    +0.46%

  • AZN

    0.5100

    69.32

    +0.74%

  • BCC

    -0.6050

    91.305

    -0.66%

  • RELX

    0.2500

    54.82

    +0.46%

  • JRI

    -0.1200

    12.78

    -0.94%

  • VOD

    0.1550

    9.605

    +1.61%

  • BTI

    0.6050

    43.245

    +1.4%

  • BP

    -0.5000

    29.26

    -1.71%

  • BCE

    0.0100

    21.57

    +0.05%

Disinformation shifting views on Ukrainian refugees
Disinformation shifting views on Ukrainian refugees / Photo: Michal Cizek - AFP

Disinformation shifting views on Ukrainian refugees

When Dominika Sokur speaks to her children in the playground, she overhears hostile reactions that she believes are being fuelled by disinformation.

Text size:

"When we come to the playground, people go: 'Ah, the Ukrainians have come, let’s get out of here'," said Sokur, 41, a Czech married to a Ukrainian who lives in the town of Holubice north of Prague.

"I have overheard them complaining that we get to ride buses and visit the zoo for free."

The attitude illustrates rising resentment against Ukrainian refugees in parts of Europe that experts link to false social media posts about Ukrainian refugees and the benefits they receive.

"Even my 65-year-old dad, who is not pro-Russian and supports Ukraine, is asking me what's all this talk about Ukrainian Nazis. The disinformation is simply everywhere," Sokur said.

Since Russia invaded Ukraine in February, European nations have taken in almost six million refugees, according to the UN refugee agency.

Countries including the Czech Republic, Poland, Romania and Slovakia opened their borders, homes and wallets to help those fleeing the war.

But runaway inflation, especially rampant in eastern Europe, has created a sense of economic dread that feeds disinformation portraying refugees as ingrates syphoning off resources from needy locals.

- Disinformation across borders -

From Warsaw to Bucharest, social media have been flooded with images of luxury cars with Ukrainian license plates and unsourced, anonymous claims that wealthy-looking Ukrainians have been spotted standing in line for government aid.

Comments express resentment and anger against the politicians supposedly helping Ukrainians instead of taking care of their own population.

The online claims vary from country to country, but they carry the same underlying message: Ukrainians are taking resources away "from us".

"Refugees are always mentioned in the context of non-working immigrants waiting for benefits, luxury cars and so-called 'health or benefit tourism'," the Czech Elves, a network of several hundred volunteers monitoring online disinformation, said in their June report.

In Poland a recent article on a blog known to spread disinformation misleadingly claimed that Ukrainian refugees were getting free shopping vouchers while needy Poles were left empty-handed.

In Romania, a Facebook post said sweepingly that "90 percent of those who cross the border are from the rich class, those who can afford to give 1,000-1,500 euros bribe to Ukrainian customs to cross over to us".

In the Czech Republic, which has accepted the biggest number of refugees per capita, a viral post falsely stated that a Ukrainian family of four can collect as much as 90,000 koruna (about $3,700) per month in aid -- far more than the income of an average Czech family.

Contrary to stereotypes shared on social media, most Ukrainian refugees start looking for work almost immediately after they reach the Czech Republic and often accept manual jobs in construction, healthcare or as cleaning personnel, according to data from the Czech labour office.

- Economic squeeze fuels resentment -

It is difficult to identify the main spreaders of such disinformation targeting Ukrainian refugees but such posts often feature on accounts linked to far-right parties.

Whipping up anti-Ukrainian sentiment bears the hallmarks of Russian propaganda, according to Gesine Schwan, political science professor and former presidential candidate for Germany’s Social Democratic Party (SPD) who has written extensively about refugees.

"Russia is extremely good at taking something that happened and misinterpreting it in such a way that it creates resentment," Schwan told AFP in a telephone interview.

"(President Vladimir) Putin knows that the war he's waging has provoked moral outrage. So he is trying to justify it by painting Ukrainians as the morally deficient ones."

So far, the impact of such propaganda and disinformation has been limited but that can change quickly as economic woes worsen, said Nikola Horejs, the director of international affairs at the STEM sociological research institute in Prague.

STEM's research shows that support for Ukraine, while still relatively high, has been rapidly decreasing in the past few weeks, he said, falling by as much as 100,000 people per week among the Czech Republic’s 10.7 million people.

"There is a great fear among people that this exodus will ruin our countries economically," Horejs said.

"The disinformation scene has adjusted. Their narrative is no longer that Putin is good or that the war doesn't exist; the main theme now is that the governments are not addressing people's economic problems, but helping Ukrainians instead."

F.Carpenteri--NZN