Zürcher Nachrichten - How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help?

EUR -
AED 4.122742
AFN 72.968564
ALL 90.896689
AMD 405.485229
ANG 2.009211
AOA 1029.423385
ARS 1703.797403
AUD 1.606967
AWG 2.022082
AZN 1.906551
BAM 1.955703
BBD 2.259147
BDT 138.751238
BGN 1.962114
BHD 0.423686
BIF 3367.332345
BMD 1.122599
BND 1.434948
BOB 13.106523
BRL 5.667549
BSD 1.121624
BTN 106.420597
BWP 15.37944
BYN 3.346574
BYR 22002.942504
BZD 2.255847
CAD 1.580462
CDF 2597.129288
CHF 0.92615
CLF 0.028019
CLP 1102.796365
CNY 7.511535
CNH 7.499417
COP 3566.78924
CRC 509.465558
CUC 1.122599
CUP 26.9203
CVE 110.258528
CZK 24.341541
DJF 199.743614
DKK 7.474517
DOP 68.985336
DZD 150.91275
EGP 60.612381
ERN 16.838987
ETB 183.215114
FJD 2.536457
FKP 0.842677
GBP 0.84209
GEL 2.907796
GGP 0.842677
GHS 13.107523
GIP 0.842677
GMD 82.51355
GNF 9928.373019
GTQ 8.575573
GYD 234.631453
HKD 8.810416
HNL 30.109099
HRK 7.534776
HTG 146.73008
HUF 363.381407
IDR 20254.438265
ILS 3.489762
IMP 0.842677
INR 106.541335
IQD 1700.48504
IRR 2016050.475836
ISK 136.394728
JEP 0.842677
JMD 178.251125
JOD 0.795928
JPY 177.656916
KES 145.780946
KGS 98.171388
KHR 4566.833645
KMF 493.943925
KPW 1010.339153
KRW 1492.551587
KWD 0.348858
KYD 0.934766
KZT 507.103786
LAK 25238.29378
LBP 100447.941009
LKR 371.718181
LRD 191.253033
LSL 18.438118
LTL 3.314743
LVL 0.679049
LYD 7.198642
MAD 10.969858
MDL 20.000271
MGA 5084.656255
MKD 61.64748
MMK 2356.912396
MNT 4037.328691
MOP 9.06777
MRU 44.907364
MUR 53.042586
MVR 17.355645
MWK 1945.037812
MXN 20.756156
MYR 4.58301
MZN 71.764844
NAD 18.438036
NGN 1497.076059
NIO 41.278129
NOK 10.556798
NPR 170.271798
NZD 1.979698
OMR 0.431651
PAB 1.121624
PEN 3.869625
PGK 5.101655
PHP 70.72489
PKR 310.504009
PLN 4.371395
PYG 6469.591442
QAR 4.088542
RON 5.32606
RSD 117.422786
RUB 92.785748
RWF 1657.83961
SAR 4.224959
SBD 9.053366
SCR 15.598211
SDG 675.31476
SEK 11.104615
SGD 1.435933
SHP 0.847277
SLE 27.705904
SLL 23540.346919
SOS 641.076648
SRD 42.428073
STD 23235.535004
STN 24.498344
SVC 9.81438
SYP 14596.03324
SZL 18.432082
THB 37.677232
TJS 10.330824
TMT 3.940323
TND 3.348389
TOP 2.702949
TRY 55.627603
TTD 7.609486
TWD 36.444285
TZS 2969.238672
UAH 50.575632
UGX 4665.809258
USD 1.122599
UYU 45.038159
UZS 13510.086659
VES 986.664252
VND 29069.142586
VUV 133.558232
WST 3.129608
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.01948
XAU 0.000269545189
XCD 3.03388
XCG 2.021599
XDR 0.793736
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 265.101884
ZAR 18.455069
ZMK 10104.738933
ZMW 22.406184
ZWL 361.476455
SSP 6455.814903
MXV 2.343158
  • RYCEF

    -0.3900

    17.61

    -2.21%

  • CMSC

    0.0100

    19.89

    +0.05%

  • NGG

    2.1500

    81.22

    +2.65%

  • BCE

    0.1500

    20.33

    +0.74%

  • BCC

    0.6500

    76.13

    +0.85%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    19.86

    +0.05%

  • RBGPF

    3.9200

    75.42

    +5.2%

  • VOD

    0.2600

    16.11

    +1.61%

  • RIO

    0.1100

    90.32

    +0.12%

  • GSK

    0.4900

    49.51

    +0.99%

  • JRI

    0.0800

    10.56

    +0.76%

  • AZN

    -1.2700

    165.41

    -0.77%

  • RELX

    0.6400

    39.06

    +1.64%

  • BP

    1.7700

    50.21

    +3.53%

  • BTI

    2.0000

    60

    +3.33%

How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help?
How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help? / Photo: - - AFP

How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help?

Shirin, a Tehran resident, was one of many who celebrated the death of Iranian supreme leader Ali Khamenei. She drank wine and danced with friends. But as the war drags on, she's begun to question its logic.

Text size:

A woman in her thirties, whose identity AFP is protecting for her safety, Shirin agreed to share her feelings about the 11-day conflict as part of an attempt to gauge the feelings of critics of the Islamic republic.

Before the war, huge crowds of protesters took to the streets in January for some of the biggest anti-government demonstrations in recent history. Thousands were killed in the subsequent crackdown by the country's Islamic authorities, rights groups say.

US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have advanced various justifications for their war on Iran, which they launched on February 28.

One of them was that it would help Iranians realise their dream of a different nation, with Trump telling them the "hour of your freedom is at hand".

"At the beginning I was in favour of the war," Shirin explained. "After the death of Khamenei (on February 28), I celebrated that with my friends."

But when air strikes struck fuel storage facilities in Tehran on Sunday, causing thick, oil-filled smoke that blotted out the sun, Shirin felt her sympathies shift.

"This isn't what we wanted. We didn't want them to bomb our national assets to make us even poorer than we already are," she explained.

Others fret about the country descending into civil war, which could spur support for the status quo.

"A lot of people are worried about the post-Islamic period. Like my father, he thinks it might get worse after they are gone," a shopkeeper in the southern city of Shiraz told AFP, referring to the current clerical leadership.

"You get happy at their destruction. But the fact that it is so costly, that so many innocent people are dying, it makes me feel horrible," a young pro-opposition woman in her twenties in Tehran told AFP.

- Still 'hopeful' -

In his message to an AFP journalist in recent days, the shopkeeper in Shiraz said he remained optimistic, convinced that the short-term pain and cost of the war would be worth it.

"The majority of people I know are hopeful things are going to get better and we will have freedom finally," he explained.

Others have said they have not fled so they can celebrate the end of the Islamic republic, if it comes.

Thousands of US and Israeli air strikes have pummelled military targets, but also domestic security infrastructure such as police and paramilitary buildings.

"They don't hit normal buildings. They hit police stations, mosques, military locations and the airport. But the noise of the bombing scares us a lot. A lot," another woman in Tehran told AFP.

"If a police station is hit at the end of your street, all your windows shatter. That's what many have experienced," she added.

Iran's health ministry said on Monday that more than 1,200 civilians had been killed -- figures that align with estimates from an overseas human rights group -- and more than 10,000 have been injured.

AFP has not been able to access the sites of the many airstrikes in order to verify incidents as described by Iran's authorities nor obtain independent confirmation of the tolls.

- 'Depth of hatred' -

While sustaining huge material damage, the Islamic republic system has sought to project an image of solidity and continuity.

Officials named Khamenei's 56-year-old son, Mojtaba Khamenei, as their new supreme leader on Sunday. He is a hardliner believed to have been involved in suppressing waves of protests going back to the 2009 pro-democracy Green movement.

Tens of thousands of people turned out for a pro-government rally for him in Tehran on his first day in power on Monday, while other similar demonstrations around the country have been reported by state media.

Ali Ansari, a professor of Iranian history at the University of St Andrews in Scotland, told AFP it was extremely difficult to assess the consequences of the war on Iranian public opinion.

He said he was sceptical about any idea of a "bounce" for the government or a nationalist "rally round the flag" outpouring.

After a 12-day war with Israel in June last year, thousands of Iranian protesters demanding the end of the Islamic republic were back on the streets by the end of the year.

"I don't think that bombing a fuel depot was a good idea, but I would be surprised if the depth of the hatred for the regime is dissipated for very long," Ansari explained.

"Once the bombing stops, that's when we've got to keep an eye out and see what happens," he continued.

"I think if the regime survives, it will be so badly crippled it won't be able to do much."

burs-adp/sw/rmb

D.Smith--NZN