Zürcher Nachrichten - 'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran

EUR -
AED 4.117613
AFN 72.877611
ALL 91.227262
AMD 406.670309
ANG 2.006709
AOA 1028.141551
ARS 1701.703875
AUD 1.606823
AWG 2.019563
AZN 1.906758
BAM 1.954207
BBD 2.265179
BDT 138.3772
BGN 1.95967
BHD 0.425449
BIF 3366.885457
BMD 1.121201
BND 1.43904
BOB 13.13306
BRL 5.678435
BSD 1.124903
BTN 106.741615
BWP 15.411712
BYN 3.386829
BYR 21975.540274
BZD 2.261982
CAD 1.580058
CDF 2593.896677
CHF 0.924593
CLF 0.027948
CLP 1099.943205
CNY 7.502181
CNH 7.491013
COP 3562.818103
CRC 511.185578
CUC 1.121201
CUP 26.997992
CVE 110.17568
CZK 24.339585
DJF 200.274766
DKK 7.474963
DOP 69.004058
DZD 150.717474
EGP 60.261867
ERN 16.818016
ETB 183.746236
FJD 2.533298
FKP 0.841627
GBP 0.841187
GEL 2.904046
GGP 0.841627
GHS 13.13635
GIP 0.841627
GMD 82.405035
GNF 9896.021357
GTQ 8.595032
GYD 235.349201
HKD 8.799354
HNL 30.198518
HRK 7.533464
HTG 147.30598
HUF 363.064514
IDR 20225.345459
ILS 3.485198
IMP 0.841627
INR 106.468969
IQD 1705.317487
IRR 2013539.711087
ISK 136.203185
JEP 0.841627
JMD 178.817424
JOD 0.794899
JPY 177.361672
KES 145.632615
KGS 98.049146
KHR 4572.313583
KMF 493.328374
KPW 1009.080887
KRW 1490.760489
KWD 0.348413
KYD 0.93744
KZT 509.047312
LAK 25306.067272
LBP 100714.391592
LKR 372.488288
LRD 191.753498
LSL 18.487255
LTL 3.310616
LVL 0.678203
LYD 7.222599
MAD 10.928497
MDL 20.176324
MGA 5062.963155
MKD 61.59479
MMK 2353.977122
MNT 4032.300645
MOP 9.094127
MRU 44.97094
MUR 52.976469
MVR 17.333676
MWK 1950.644695
MXN 20.778549
MYR 4.57686
MZN 71.639261
NAD 18.491127
NGN 1495.132448
NIO 41.396624
NOK 10.560845
NPR 170.825796
NZD 1.980731
OMR 0.431108
PAB 1.124898
PEN 3.869346
PGK 5.107791
PHP 70.7091
PKR 311.408205
PLN 4.369197
PYG 6423.417518
QAR 4.111866
RON 5.325254
RSD 117.440212
RUB 93.058421
RWF 1660.376135
SAR 4.219809
SBD 9.042091
SCR 15.594753
SDG 674.387756
SEK 11.114981
SGD 1.434846
SHP 0.846221
SLE 27.67122
SLL 23511.030021
SOS 642.887407
SRD 42.375227
STD 23206.597716
STN 24.479827
SVC 9.84302
SYP 14577.855496
SZL 18.484262
THB 37.661701
TJS 10.366096
TMT 3.935416
TND 3.355879
TOP 2.699583
TRY 55.558471
TTD 7.636775
TWD 36.424459
TZS 2962.278203
UAH 50.457569
UGX 4646.233266
USD 1.121201
UYU 45.283289
UZS 13561.12685
VES 985.435469
VND 29036.864388
VUV 133.3919
WST 3.12571
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.019493
XAU 0.000268768092
XCD 3.030102
XCG 2.027356
XDR 0.792747
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 264.771893
ZAR 18.471759
ZMK 10092.14707
ZMW 22.515927
ZWL 361.026276
SSP 6447.7749
MXV 2.345686
  • RBGPF

    3.9200

    75.42

    +5.2%

  • RYCEF

    -0.3900

    17.61

    -2.21%

  • RELX

    0.6400

    39.06

    +1.64%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    19.86

    +0.05%

  • GSK

    0.4900

    49.51

    +0.99%

  • BCE

    0.1500

    20.33

    +0.74%

  • RIO

    0.1100

    90.32

    +0.12%

  • CMSC

    0.0100

    19.89

    +0.05%

  • VOD

    0.2600

    16.11

    +1.61%

  • BCC

    0.6500

    76.13

    +0.85%

  • NGG

    2.1500

    81.22

    +2.65%

  • BTI

    2.0000

    60

    +3.33%

  • JRI

    0.0800

    10.56

    +0.76%

  • AZN

    -1.2700

    165.41

    -0.77%

  • BP

    1.7700

    50.21

    +3.53%

'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran
'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran / Photo: Mohsen KARIMI - AFP

'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran

Exhausted Afghans cross the border from Iran in a sandstorm, leaving behind a country in the grip of war to return to a homeland that is battered by conflict and humanitarian crisis.

Text size:

At the Islam Qala crossing point in Herat province, western Afghanistan, Talibshah, who did not to give his family name, said he had been working in agriculture northwest of Tehran.

He was cheated by money changers at the border and was trying to figure out how to get back to Sar-e-Pol province in the north, hundreds of kilometres away on difficult, mountainous roads.

Talibshah's work in Qazvin in northern Iran helped support seven people -- his mother, father, brothers and sisters -- at a time when drought had made farming difficult, if not impossible, back home.

"I don't know whether I will be able to find a job or not. We are left without prospects," he told AFP.

"If I don't find a job here, I'll have to emigrate again. We have no choice. We can't starve," he added.

- Funding shortfall -

The United Nations has warned that nearly half of Afghanistan -- 21.9 million people -- will need humanitarian aid this year.

Since February 26, the country has been hit by fresh clashes with neighbouring Pakistan to the east, which have killed at least 56 civilians and forced about 115,000 from their homes.

The UN refugee agency's representative in Afghanistan, Arafat Jamal, said there was "no good choice" for those coming back.

"They're fleeing war in Iran and coming to a country that is also itself at war," he said. "In other words, these people are coming into a country that is wracked by drought, that has unemployment, and that now has conflict inside it."

Since the war began in the Middle East on February 28, about 1,700 people have returned every day. But the UNHCR is expecting bigger numbers in the future if there is no let-up in the conflict.

The agency is ready in terms of staff and infrastructure to receive those leaving Iran but funding was lacking for the relief effort, said Jamal.

- '50 times greater' -

At the Islam Qala border post, more people arrived on Tuesday than the previous week, said an AFP correspondent on the ground.

Families crossed quickly, their faces expressionless, with one or two suitcases holding their meagre belongings.

Mohammad Kabir Nazari, 48, had been working for the last 11 months as a security guard in Tehran, and was in the country during the 12-day war last June.

He described the latest strikes as "50 times greater".

"Missiles were coming from all sides, every day," he said. "For Afghans, there was no shelter. The situation was very bad."

Nazari, originally from Ghazni province in eastern Afghanistan, said he had been travelling to Iran for the last 32 years.

Then, the markets were busy around the Persian new year, Nowruz, and for the end of Ramadan but were currently empty, he added.

The slowdown in Iran's economy has consequences for the many Afghan migrant workers: one friend of Nazari told him he had been sacked with other Afghans, and forced to return.

- 'Waves and waves' -

Naeemullah Rahimi, 24, was also working as a security guard, at a factory in the Tehran suburbs. He said he was forced to shelter from air strikes in the basement.

"When we saw that the situation was very bad, we had to come back to Afghanistan," he said.

Jobs are scarce in his home province of Wardak in central Afghanistan.

"I don't know what to do," said Rahimi. "But if I find a job, I'll work."

The UNHCR's Jamal said "waves and waves" of people have been deported to Afghanistan from Iran and Pakistan since September 2023. Last year alone, 2.8 million Afghans returned.

"That was the largest such movement in the world," he added.

"If we start to experience similar numbers this year, will Afghanistan really be able to cope? Perhaps, but it needs international support.

"We cannot afford to let Afghanistan fail," he said, warning that forgetting the region will had an even more destabilising effect in the world.

D.Smith--NZN