Zürcher Nachrichten - 'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran

EUR -
AED 4.229821
AFN 74.864237
ALL 93.228828
AMD 421.085566
AOA 1056.160267
ARS 1720.733086
AUD 1.637784
AWG 2.076039
AZN 1.954916
BAM 1.955775
BBD 2.318931
BDT 142.528208
BHD 0.434189
BIF 3440.726871
BMD 1.151756
BND 1.477381
BOB 13.98346
BRL 5.846768
BSD 1.151366
BTN 109.880188
BWP 15.656803
BYN 3.393457
BYR 22574.408206
BZD 2.315671
CAD 1.619057
CDF 2605.270629
CHF 0.931862
CLF 0.026904
CLP 1062.322075
CNY 7.777342
CNH 7.775035
COP 3736.43312
CRC 522.084371
CUC 1.151756
CUP 30.521521
CVE 110.263614
CZK 24.202703
DJF 205.024752
DKK 7.475452
DOP 67.149156
DZD 153.146465
EGP 57.871799
ERN 17.276333
ETB 185.837664
FJD 2.548778
FKP 0.857335
GBP 0.856578
GEL 3.006302
GGP 0.857335
GHS 13.488479
GIP 0.857335
GMD 85.229454
GNF 10111.872879
GTQ 8.78189
GYD 241.04383
HKD 9.033562
HNL 30.861746
HRK 7.534208
HTG 150.536801
HUF 362.376716
IDR 20712.019529
ILS 3.484118
IMP 0.857335
INR 109.655937
IQD 1508.281039
IRR 1583951.78019
ISK 141.999677
JEP 0.857335
JMD 182.047711
JOD 0.816595
JPY 181.232211
KES 149.014032
KGS 100.721368
KHR 4660.900938
KMF 492.951678
KRW 1642.904407
KWD 0.356388
KYD 0.959467
KZT 542.391408
LAK 26041.672617
LBP 103089.392874
LKR 386.57514
LRD 207.822876
LSL 18.980961
LTL 3.400835
LVL 0.696685
LYD 7.334908
MAD 10.727965
MDL 20.154309
MGA 4902.938363
MKD 61.529226
MMK 2418.302526
MNT 4128.236531
MOP 9.301781
MRU 46.030421
MUR 54.17888
MVR 17.794357
MWK 1996.448901
MXN 19.912067
MYR 4.713674
MZN 73.578865
NAD 18.981044
NGN 1570.371947
NIO 42.369467
NOK 10.994201
NPR 175.81079
NZD 1.956723
OMR 0.442841
PAB 1.151386
PEN 3.895551
PGK 5.083936
PHP 70.025536
PKR 319.707481
PLN 4.306816
PYG 6864.943499
QAR 4.197165
RON 5.250796
RSD 117.352727
RUB 93.295072
RWF 1695.341888
SAR 4.314394
SBD 9.295999
SCR 15.438728
SDG 691.053528
SEK 10.992758
SGD 1.476953
SLE 28.160726
SOS 657.991728
SRD 43.543221
STD 23839.013893
STN 24.499267
SVC 10.074873
SZL 18.977597
THB 38.375353
TJS 10.627028
TMT 4.031144
TND 3.382357
TRY 54.772537
TTD 7.816902
TWD 37.32091
TZS 3055.023466
UAH 51.483653
UGX 4311.870919
USD 1.151756
UYU 46.389618
UZS 13747.827169
VES 861.341978
VND 30249.131118
VUV 137.224539
WST 3.146845
XAF 655.948754
XAG 0.019431
XAU 0.000283
XCD 3.112677
XCG 2.075074
XDR 0.816719
XOF 655.948754
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.582072
ZAR 18.940458
ZMK 10367.187916
ZMW 21.786321
ZWL 370.864808
  • BCC

    1.7800

    84.81

    +2.1%

  • RIO

    2.7700

    98.67

    +2.81%

  • BTI

    -0.2400

    59.32

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.0700

    51.44

    -0.14%

  • BCE

    -0.2850

    21.505

    -1.33%

  • CMSC

    0.0300

    21.79

    +0.14%

  • NGG

    -0.2100

    79.65

    -0.26%

  • RBGPF

    3.9500

    69.95

    +5.65%

  • RYCEF

    0.4500

    20.65

    +2.18%

  • AZN

    -0.5750

    157.395

    -0.37%

  • CMSD

    0.0450

    22.065

    +0.2%

  • VOD

    0.0350

    15.645

    +0.22%

  • JRI

    0.0100

    12.83

    +0.08%

  • RELX

    0.2600

    36.42

    +0.71%

  • BP

    -1.7000

    42.56

    -3.99%

'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran
'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran / Photo: Mohsen KARIMI - AFP

'No good choice': the Afghans forced to return from Iran

Exhausted Afghans cross the border from Iran in a sandstorm, leaving behind a country in the grip of war to return to a homeland that is battered by conflict and humanitarian crisis.

Text size:

At the Islam Qala crossing point in Herat province, western Afghanistan, Talibshah, who did not to give his family name, said he had been working in agriculture northwest of Tehran.

He was cheated by money changers at the border and was trying to figure out how to get back to Sar-e-Pol province in the north, hundreds of kilometres away on difficult, mountainous roads.

Talibshah's work in Qazvin in northern Iran helped support seven people -- his mother, father, brothers and sisters -- at a time when drought had made farming difficult, if not impossible, back home.

"I don't know whether I will be able to find a job or not. We are left without prospects," he told AFP.

"If I don't find a job here, I'll have to emigrate again. We have no choice. We can't starve," he added.

- Funding shortfall -

The United Nations has warned that nearly half of Afghanistan -- 21.9 million people -- will need humanitarian aid this year.

Since February 26, the country has been hit by fresh clashes with neighbouring Pakistan to the east, which have killed at least 56 civilians and forced about 115,000 from their homes.

The UN refugee agency's representative in Afghanistan, Arafat Jamal, said there was "no good choice" for those coming back.

"They're fleeing war in Iran and coming to a country that is also itself at war," he said. "In other words, these people are coming into a country that is wracked by drought, that has unemployment, and that now has conflict inside it."

Since the war began in the Middle East on February 28, about 1,700 people have returned every day. But the UNHCR is expecting bigger numbers in the future if there is no let-up in the conflict.

The agency is ready in terms of staff and infrastructure to receive those leaving Iran but funding was lacking for the relief effort, said Jamal.

- '50 times greater' -

At the Islam Qala border post, more people arrived on Tuesday than the previous week, said an AFP correspondent on the ground.

Families crossed quickly, their faces expressionless, with one or two suitcases holding their meagre belongings.

Mohammad Kabir Nazari, 48, had been working for the last 11 months as a security guard in Tehran, and was in the country during the 12-day war last June.

He described the latest strikes as "50 times greater".

"Missiles were coming from all sides, every day," he said. "For Afghans, there was no shelter. The situation was very bad."

Nazari, originally from Ghazni province in eastern Afghanistan, said he had been travelling to Iran for the last 32 years.

Then, the markets were busy around the Persian new year, Nowruz, and for the end of Ramadan but were currently empty, he added.

The slowdown in Iran's economy has consequences for the many Afghan migrant workers: one friend of Nazari told him he had been sacked with other Afghans, and forced to return.

- 'Waves and waves' -

Naeemullah Rahimi, 24, was also working as a security guard, at a factory in the Tehran suburbs. He said he was forced to shelter from air strikes in the basement.

"When we saw that the situation was very bad, we had to come back to Afghanistan," he said.

Jobs are scarce in his home province of Wardak in central Afghanistan.

"I don't know what to do," said Rahimi. "But if I find a job, I'll work."

The UNHCR's Jamal said "waves and waves" of people have been deported to Afghanistan from Iran and Pakistan since September 2023. Last year alone, 2.8 million Afghans returned.

"That was the largest such movement in the world," he added.

"If we start to experience similar numbers this year, will Afghanistan really be able to cope? Perhaps, but it needs international support.

"We cannot afford to let Afghanistan fail," he said, warning that forgetting the region will had an even more destabilising effect in the world.

D.Smith--NZN