Zürcher Nachrichten - Dealing with the dead in the ruins of Sudan's war

EUR -
AED 4.307417
AFN 72.718969
ALL 95.471663
AMD 435.43563
ANG 2.099328
AOA 1076.707935
ARS 1630.157403
AUD 1.635059
AWG 2.111192
AZN 1.99683
BAM 1.956859
BBD 2.358476
BDT 143.677749
BGN 1.956491
BHD 0.44264
BIF 3483.084824
BMD 1.172885
BND 1.495809
BOB 8.091379
BRL 5.848943
BSD 1.170934
BTN 110.299687
BWP 15.860583
BYN 3.317095
BYR 22988.539937
BZD 2.355074
CAD 1.602805
CDF 2715.227953
CHF 0.920427
CLF 0.02672
CLP 1051.620069
CNY 8.018187
CNH 8.008943
COP 4169.464329
CRC 532.888365
CUC 1.172885
CUP 31.081444
CVE 110.324701
CZK 24.350904
DJF 208.522839
DKK 7.473785
DOP 69.757748
DZD 155.246009
EGP 61.635078
ERN 17.59327
ETB 181.021557
FJD 2.5858
FKP 0.866737
GBP 0.866216
GEL 3.143033
GGP 0.866737
GHS 13.000035
GIP 0.866737
GMD 86.209802
GNF 10278.562104
GTQ 8.951844
GYD 244.982569
HKD 9.190901
HNL 31.115838
HRK 7.533322
HTG 153.302958
HUF 364.559496
IDR 20202.938796
ILS 3.502292
IMP 0.866737
INR 110.534471
IQD 1533.930065
IRR 1544689.137153
ISK 143.806913
JEP 0.866737
JMD 184.789997
JOD 0.83157
JPY 186.811795
KES 151.407607
KGS 102.513871
KHR 4691.538877
KMF 492.611668
KPW 1055.596177
KRW 1724.034866
KWD 0.360967
KYD 0.975828
KZT 543.934343
LAK 25658.884958
LBP 104859.343212
LKR 373.25198
LRD 214.866272
LSL 19.471437
LTL 3.463223
LVL 0.709466
LYD 7.430021
MAD 10.833863
MDL 20.363019
MGA 4865.632971
MKD 61.673374
MMK 2463.303098
MNT 4195.561368
MOP 9.449614
MRU 46.73529
MUR 54.925835
MVR 18.120758
MWK 2030.498777
MXN 20.373835
MYR 4.637004
MZN 74.958782
NAD 19.471437
NGN 1586.69042
NIO 43.093319
NOK 10.904661
NPR 176.479499
NZD 1.990356
OMR 0.450564
PAB 1.170934
PEN 4.059897
PGK 5.08275
PHP 71.142528
PKR 326.434045
PLN 4.243585
PYG 7425.017948
QAR 4.26861
RON 5.085864
RSD 117.483575
RUB 88.252768
RWF 1711.526169
SAR 4.399259
SBD 9.436218
SCR 17.356392
SDG 704.328763
SEK 10.80571
SGD 1.49534
SHP 0.875677
SLE 28.882302
SLL 24594.801024
SOS 669.162108
SRD 43.940365
STD 24276.345052
STN 24.513265
SVC 10.245544
SYP 129.633066
SZL 19.463532
THB 37.92933
TJS 11.007056
TMT 4.110961
TND 3.41935
TOP 2.824025
TRY 52.814292
TTD 7.952303
TWD 36.859065
TZS 3047.448768
UAH 51.598322
UGX 4356.357384
USD 1.172885
UYU 46.385101
UZS 14068.613039
VES 566.696433
VND 30916.067561
VUV 137.882726
WST 3.200224
XAF 656.312154
XAG 0.015432
XAU 0.000249
XCD 3.16978
XCG 2.110342
XDR 0.816242
XOF 656.312154
XPF 119.331742
YER 279.909028
ZAR 19.361042
ZMK 10557.370392
ZMW 22.159992
ZWL 377.668392
  • BCC

    0.3300

    84.15

    +0.39%

  • RBGPF

    64.0000

    64

    +100%

  • BCE

    -0.2200

    23.88

    -0.92%

  • NGG

    0.4600

    87.42

    +0.53%

  • JRI

    0.0100

    12.89

    +0.08%

  • CMSC

    0.0400

    22.95

    +0.17%

  • RELX

    0.4000

    36.53

    +1.09%

  • BTI

    0.8100

    58.09

    +1.39%

  • RIO

    0.7600

    99.61

    +0.76%

  • GSK

    -1.1900

    54.44

    -2.19%

  • CMSD

    0.0900

    23.32

    +0.39%

  • AZN

    -2.5500

    189.75

    -1.34%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    15.63

    +0.06%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1200

    15.3

    -0.78%

  • BP

    -0.1000

    46.25

    -0.22%

Dealing with the dead in the ruins of Sudan's war
Dealing with the dead in the ruins of Sudan's war / Photo: Khaled DESOUKI - AFP

Dealing with the dead in the ruins of Sudan's war

At a makeshift morgue in Khartoum, engineer turned mortician Ali Gebbai clicked through a spreadsheet of the dead. Thousands of entries, each with a photo and burial site, keep a harrowing record of Sudan's war.

Text size:

Every time the team of volunteers finds a body, they post to social media and wait 72 hours in the hopes that the victim's loved ones will come across the picture and claim the person.

"We photograph every body. We check if there's anything in their pockets to help us identify them, and we mark the spot where we buried them," Gebbai told AFP.

It was a blazing April day and a dead woman lay on the ground of the small, air-conditioned room in the Sudanese capital, her brown-speckled thobe pulled over her face and body.

If no one came to identify her, the team would prepare a clean white shroud, wash her according to Muslim custom and bury her nearby.

It is all anyone in Khartoum can hope for by way of a morgue. And it is far more than what most victims of Sudan's war receive: a shallow grave, hastily dug into the dirt where they fell.

The conflict, now in its fourth year, between Sudan's army and the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces has no confirmed toll, though it has killed at least tens of thousands, and aid workers give estimates of more than 200,000.

"It's disheartening, all these estimations. When you have a population not knowing what has happened, that trauma and the impact cannot be overlooked," Jose Luis Pozo Gil, the International Committee of the Red Cross's deputy Sudan chief, told AFP.

In the year since the army recaptured Khartoum, authorities have exhumed and reburied "around 28,000 people", Hisham Zein al-Abdeen, head of forensic medicine at Sudan's health ministry, told AFP. And they have only cleared a little over half the capital.

Gebbai said he and his teams have buried 7,000 dead since the war began.

Ethnic massacres in Darfur, meanwhile, have killed thousands of people at a time, and this year alone at least 700 died in drone strikes on Kordofan.

- Morgues destroyed -

Across the country, there is nowhere to store the dead, and no way to count them.

During the worst massacres, when firebombs tear through mosques and markets, rescuers routinely run out of shrouds. The dead are buried where they lay, wrapped in their own clothes or plastic bags, often in villages with no clinic to speak of, much less a morgue that can send information to a central authority.

Zein al-Abdeen, one of only two forensic doctors in Khartoum, said the capital's morgues "were already full before the war".

According to the ICRC, Khartoum's four morgues were all forced out of service by the war, but the dead remained inside.

"When we went inside the Omdurman morgue, there were still many bodies. And there hadn't been any electricity for a long time -- you can imagine the state," Pozo Gil said.

The Omdurman morgue was "completely destroyed" in a strike, Zein al-Abdeen said, its compressors looted while bodies lay rotting everywhere they looked.

His team has been exhuming Khartoum's dead for a year, focusing on "those buried in shallow graves, in public spaces, in sewers and along the Nile".

As bullets flew and artillery arched over the river to crash into homes and hospitals, trapped civilians could not reach the next street over, much less the cemetery. So people buried their loved ones in courtyards, at playgrounds and on street corners.

Over three years, it turned Khartoum into an open-air graveyard.

"That leaves a mark on society, it destroys human dignity and it normalises death," Zein al-Abdeen said.

The same is true for the rest of Sudan: in Darfur, where pools of blood could be seen in satellite images; in al-Jazira, where bodies were dumped in canals; and in Kordofan, where killer drones still stalk civilians.

- Finding the missing -

Most of those exhumed and reburied in Khartoum are identified, Zein al-Abdeen said, by families who buried their loved ones themselves but needed authorities to give them a proper resting place.

But many are not. From every anonymous body, authorities remove a small bone or a piece of hair, in hopes they will one day be identified. But Sudan has no working DNA labs to test the samples, and nowhere to store them until then.

"The safest place to keep the DNA samples is buried separately in the ground, and marked clearly," Zein al-Abdeen told AFP, "or we'll exhume the bodies again later."

According to the ICRC, there are at least 11,000 missing persons in Sudan.

"We know that the lack of closure for families leaves an open wound. In any kind of recovery in the future, in order to find closure, to rebuild trust, the issue of the missing has to be addressed," Pozo Gil said.

Gebbai the mortician spoke with steely-eyed resolve, but it began to crack when he remembered one young man.

"He was looking for his father and his uncle for over a year. When he came to us, he found out they had both been shot dead in the street in the early weeks of the war. It broke him, he collapsed and cried for a long time."

But at last, at least, he could visit their graves.

A.P.Huber--NZN