Zürcher Nachrichten - Five things to know about South Africa's anti-migrant protests

EUR -
AED 4.123481
AFN 72.418756
ALL 91.601317
AMD 405.317443
ANG 2.009572
AOA 1030.730991
ARS 1699.002245
AUD 1.614042
AWG 2.021041
AZN 1.906165
BAM 1.961207
BBD 2.2599
BDT 138.521899
BGN 1.962466
BHD 0.423965
BIF 3359.873256
BMD 1.122801
BND 1.438929
BOB 13.145358
BRL 5.668231
BSD 1.122079
BTN 106.828522
BWP 15.414359
BYN 3.390633
BYR 22006.89006
BZD 2.256903
CAD 1.594674
CDF 2596.488722
CHF 0.92992
CLF 0.028115
CLP 1106.542613
CNY 7.514623
CNH 7.513894
COP 3590.300605
CRC 511.405368
CUC 1.122801
CUP 26.929123
CVE 110.570824
CZK 24.363143
DJF 199.808193
DKK 7.474876
DOP 68.718843
DZD 150.861743
EGP 59.593869
ERN 16.842008
ETB 183.277857
FJD 2.542638
FKP 0.847332
GBP 0.847293
GEL 2.92062
GGP 0.847332
GHS 13.089203
GIP 0.847332
GMD 83.087596
GNF 9870.950049
GTQ 8.57464
GYD 234.677898
HKD 8.810885
HNL 30.125787
HRK 7.530288
HTG 146.940343
HUF 363.821483
IDR 20140.795607
ILS 3.477985
IMP 0.847332
INR 106.659143
IQD 1701.141484
IRR 2010374.319286
ISK 136.408639
JEP 0.847332
JMD 178.207181
JOD 0.796089
JPY 177.113363
KES 145.773439
KGS 98.18912
KHR 4558.730632
KMF 496.277803
KPW 1010.520418
KRW 1517.071555
KWD 0.349764
KYD 0.935161
KZT 506.955397
LAK 25265.817562
LBP 100546.786195
LKR 371.372204
LRD 191.307426
LSL 18.582966
LTL 3.315338
LVL 0.679171
LYD 7.214046
MAD 11.053258
MDL 20.084282
MGA 5052.885588
MKD 61.745229
MMK 2357.912999
MNT 4041.721584
MOP 9.070366
MRU 44.949323
MUR 53.456625
MVR 17.358239
MWK 1945.847288
MXN 20.755995
MYR 4.582708
MZN 71.757889
NAD 18.497615
NGN 1493.470407
NIO 41.292739
NOK 10.650465
NPR 170.923707
NZD 1.995295
OMR 0.431724
PAB 1.122104
PEN 3.863517
PGK 5.092973
PHP 70.800992
PKR 310.666427
PLN 4.368379
PYG 6402.566068
QAR 4.090614
RON 5.335771
RSD 117.413503
RUB 93.894606
RWF 1655.549535
SAR 4.12898
SBD 9.070063
SCR 15.557764
SDG 675.366788
SEK 11.18068
SGD 1.439571
SHP 0.847173
SLE 27.699569
SLL 23544.570301
SOS 641.273676
SRD 42.343028
STD 23239.703699
STN 24.567403
SVC 9.818945
SYP 14598.65192
SZL 18.489811
THB 37.659824
TJS 10.356553
TMT 3.929802
TND 3.353947
TOP 2.703434
TRY 55.478133
TTD 7.631004
TWD 36.292264
TZS 2952.970979
UAH 50.431288
UGX 4533.539152
USD 1.122801
UYU 45.105559
UZS 13419.878513
VES 983.238206
VND 29054.708882
VUV 134.031712
WST 3.131051
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.019985
XAU 0.000270322124
XCD 3.034425
XCG 2.022456
XDR 0.793878
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 265.207887
ZAR 18.586447
ZMK 10106.555351
ZMW 22.302274
ZWL 361.541307
SSP 6454.445704
MXV 2.343835
  • RBGPF

    2.4700

    69.3

    +3.56%

  • BCC

    -0.1000

    73.98

    -0.14%

  • CMSC

    -0.0800

    19.71

    -0.41%

  • NGG

    0.2800

    78.51

    +0.36%

  • RYCEF

    0.3200

    17.92

    +1.79%

  • BTI

    1.0100

    56.66

    +1.78%

  • BCE

    0.1900

    19.67

    +0.97%

  • GSK

    1.6000

    47.87

    +3.34%

  • RIO

    -1.8100

    91.25

    -1.98%

  • RELX

    0.2300

    36.93

    +0.62%

  • CMSD

    -0.1750

    19.63

    -0.89%

  • JRI

    -0.1500

    10.4

    -1.44%

  • VOD

    -0.0450

    15.51

    -0.29%

  • AZN

    6.2100

    162.03

    +3.83%

  • BP

    0.2800

    48.81

    +0.57%

Five things to know about South Africa's anti-migrant protests
Five things to know about South Africa's anti-migrant protests / Photo: RODGER BOSCH - AFP

Five things to know about South Africa's anti-migrant protests

Anti-immigrant protests are flaring again in South Africa, with vigilantes threatening to remove undocumented migrants by June 30, reviving a politically charged issue in a country battered by economic hardship.

Text size:

Waves of xenophobic violence, including in 2008 when dozens were killed, reflect deeper structural problems in Africa's most industrialised nation, analysts say.

Here are five things to know about the latest unrest, which has drawn criticism from several African nations.

- What sparked the new wave? -

Mostly low-key demonstrations against migrants have been building for months after a flare-up late last year when undocumented foreign nationals were blocked from accessing clinics and hospitals.

It reflects growing public anger over issues such as soaring joblessness, crime and pressure on resources, with a steady influx of mostly African migrants becoming a convenient scapegoat, analysts say.

Some political forces also appear to be using the tensions to garner support ahead of municipal elections in November.

South Africa is under pressure from global shocks and domestic policy failures, said William Gumede, professor of public management at the University of the Witwatersrand.

"We are going into a very difficult period," he said, pointing to "self-inflicted toxic policies" by government and its failure to reverse economic decline.

There are roughly three million immigrants in the country, about 5.1 percent of the population, according to the national statistics agency.

More than 63 percent come from neighbouring countries in the 16-member Southern African Development Community (SADC) bloc that are facing their own economic crises and political instability.

With South Africa's unemployment rate of nearly 33 percent -- significantly higher when discouraged job seekers are included -- there is particular resentment towards working migrants.

- Who is behind the protests? -

Protesters have been whipped into action by a loose coalition of political parties and citizen-led xenophobic vigilante movements, some fronted by men in traditional Zulu dress.

Their charges that migrants are behind crime and taking jobs from locals inflame tensions in townships strained by poverty, unemployment and weak policing.

A virulent social media campaign that includes disinformation debunked by AFP contributes to the spread of anti-migrant sentiment.

"The main ingredient is right-wing political opportunism," political scientist Sandile Swana told AFP, warning it risks redirecting anger from structural failures.

"We are seeing a new form of black-on-black violence diverting attention from the true culprits of the economic crisis," he said.

- Why does xenophobia keep resurfacing? -

South Africa has experienced repeated waves of xenophobic violence over the past two decades.

In 2008, 62 people were killed in anti-immigrant riots and thousands displaced. Further outbreaks followed in 2015 and 2016.

Violence in 2019 saw armed mobs descend on foreign-owned businesses around Johannesburg, leaving at least 12 people dead -- 10 of them South African citizens.

Critics say weak law enforcement and limited prosecutions have entrenched a culture of impunity, allowing vigilante action to persist alongside anti-immigrant rhetoric.

"There is no law enforcement against illegal, unlawful vigilantism and afrophobia in South Africa, no prosecution at all," Swana said.

What sets the current wave apart is the growing acceptance of xenophobic rhetoric beyond fringe groups, Gumede said.

"That wasn't the case in the past, which is really a flashpoint," he said.

- How has the world reacted? -

Several African countries -- including Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, Lesotho and Zimbabwe -- have urged their citizens in South Africa to exercise caution.

Ghana has formally petitioned the African Union and initiated efforts to repatriate nationals.

The United Nations said it was "deeply concerned" while Human Rights Watch criticised a lack of adequate response from the authorities.

South Africa's government has meanwhile rejected accusations of xenophobia and urged other African nations to address the economic and governance crises driving migration.

- What comes next? -

While the bloodshed in this wave of anti-migrant action has been nothing compared to previous years, an order by vigilante groups for undocumented migrants to leave by June 30 is raising fears even though it has not legal weight.

Demonstrations have been announced in the lead-up, with groups also forcing small businesses run by foreign nationals to close.

South Africa's international standing has meanwhile been dented, undermining its post-apartheid image as a champion of human rights and African solidarity.

The government had "positioned South Africa as a moral authority but that is now heavily destroyed," Gumede said.

The violence "opened an angle that will probably be exploited later by people such as Donald Trump that we are a genocidal nation," he said, referring to a debunked claim that the white Afrikaner minority is systematically persecuted in South Africa.

J.Hasler--NZN