Zürcher Nachrichten - What's behind England's Six Nations slump?

EUR -
AED 4.183233
AFN 72.900796
ALL 94.178505
AMD 419.314312
ANG 2.039391
AOA 1044.526125
ARS 1682.963331
AUD 1.650836
AWG 2.050323
AZN 1.940938
BAM 1.953816
BBD 2.29467
BDT 140.137703
BGN 1.926028
BHD 0.429564
BIF 3383.764104
BMD 1.139068
BND 1.474203
BOB 7.873316
BRL 5.906116
BSD 1.139343
BTN 106.936538
BWP 15.483957
BYN 3.304345
BYR 22325.7403
BZD 2.291333
CAD 1.616088
CDF 2585.685641
CHF 0.921945
CLF 0.026716
CLP 1051.47848
CNY 7.750051
CNH 7.748997
COP 3924.853754
CRC 517.274756
CUC 1.139068
CUP 30.185312
CVE 110.152667
CZK 24.262503
DJF 202.435681
DKK 7.474852
DOP 66.942027
DZD 151.891398
EGP 56.388104
ERN 17.086026
ETB 183.690043
FJD 2.581248
FKP 0.861953
GBP 0.862588
GEL 3.012882
GGP 0.861953
GHS 12.846463
GIP 0.861953
GMD 83.152397
GNF 9982.863336
GTQ 8.692174
GYD 238.447299
HKD 8.931931
HNL 30.484046
HRK 7.534145
HTG 148.908797
HUF 353.806604
IDR 20318.644856
ILS 3.419541
IMP 0.861953
INR 107.482778
IQD 1492.484522
IRR 1566275.979936
ISK 143.990074
JEP 0.861953
JMD 179.437798
JOD 0.807645
JPY 184.248302
KES 147.464231
KGS 99.611968
KHR 4573.356185
KMF 494.356077
KPW 1025.161943
KRW 1749.07411
KWD 0.352667
KYD 0.949478
KZT 552.798685
LAK 25007.607115
LBP 102029.928944
LKR 382.987923
LRD 207.538374
LSL 18.727983
LTL 3.363373
LVL 0.689012
LYD 7.313542
MAD 10.683358
MDL 20.201374
MGA 4819.022121
MKD 61.650608
MMK 2391.4173
MNT 4078.140908
MOP 9.203718
MRU 45.46983
MUR 54.345384
MVR 17.599037
MWK 1975.671941
MXN 19.928917
MYR 4.656556
MZN 72.790718
NAD 18.727983
NGN 1569.96699
NIO 41.927427
NOK 11.321935
NPR 171.101263
NZD 2.019175
OMR 0.437978
PAB 1.139393
PEN 3.885055
PGK 4.999879
PHP 69.810658
PKR 317.086147
PLN 4.288536
PYG 6953.908432
QAR 4.152965
RON 5.240402
RSD 117.409287
RUB 89.840095
RWF 1668.578957
SAR 4.278556
SBD 9.171725
SCR 15.116694
SDG 683.441416
SEK 11.086063
SGD 1.474085
SHP 0.85043
SLE 28.253073
SLL 23885.698624
SOS 651.167384
SRD 42.695744
STD 23576.41575
STN 24.475148
SVC 9.968834
SYP 125.903618
SZL 18.716995
THB 37.997617
TJS 10.544809
TMT 3.986739
TND 3.377019
TOP 2.742604
TRY 53.107967
TTD 7.743002
TWD 36.285825
TZS 2987.418743
UAH 51.139324
UGX 4181.643799
USD 1.139068
UYU 45.735567
UZS 13685.704189
VES 707.080099
VND 29957.498463
VUV 136.632283
WST 3.172872
XAF 655.291613
XAG 0.019292
XAU 0.000279
XCD 3.07839
XCG 2.053315
XDR 0.816089
XOF 655.288739
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.810235
ZAR 18.752312
ZMK 10252.986409
ZMW 20.523521
ZWL 366.779554
  • CMSC

    -0.1160

    21.93

    -0.53%

  • RIO

    -1.3700

    93.74

    -1.46%

  • JRI

    0.2100

    12.79

    +1.64%

  • RYCEF

    0.7000

    18.7

    +3.74%

  • CMSD

    -0.1600

    21.77

    -0.73%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    61.3

    0%

  • BCC

    1.2600

    81.02

    +1.56%

  • BCE

    -0.2800

    22.92

    -1.22%

  • NGG

    -0.4100

    83.01

    -0.49%

  • BTI

    0.2800

    62.76

    +0.45%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    13.89

    +0.22%

  • GSK

    0.6100

    52.5

    +1.16%

  • RELX

    0.4200

    31.34

    +1.34%

  • AZN

    2.7300

    188.41

    +1.45%

  • BP

    -0.5900

    37.13

    -1.59%

What's behind England's Six Nations slump?
What's behind England's Six Nations slump? / Photo: Adrian Dennis - AFP

What's behind England's Six Nations slump?

England entered the Six Nations Championship with genuine hope of dethroning title-holders France and they launched their bid to be crowned rugby champions of Europe for the first time since 2020 with a 48-7 rout of Wales.

Text size:

But hopes of championship glory effectively disappeared after Saturday's record 42-21 Twickenham defeat by Ireland which came just a week after an almost as emphatic 31-20 loss away to Scotland.

AFP Sport looks at three key aspects of England's striking collapse:

- Approach -

Before the championship even started, England coach Steve Borthwick set his sights on a title-decider away to France in the final round of matches, saying: "On March 14 in Paris, we want to be in a position entering that game where we can achieve what we’re all aiming to achieve."

A team with England's rugby resources, both playing and financial, ought to be ambitious and there is nothing fundamentally wrong with aiming high.

But the issue was more that for a coach who had made such a mantra out of a 'one game at a time' approach, such a bullish public statement jarred.

To borrow an old Irish expression, it was maybe just a sign that Borthwick had, ever so slightly, "lost the run of himself" and with it the team as well.

In that respect, hammering one of the weakest Wales teams in living memory, which gave his side a 12th successive win against all opponents, may have worked against Borthwick's men, with Red Rose prop Ellis Genge telling the BBC after Saturday's loss to Ireland: "We probably believed the hype from the first week too much. We can't let the noise in now."

- 'Awful' defence -

For two games in a row, England's defence has been ruthlessly exposed, with both Scotland and Ireland scoring a flurry of early tries.

The Scots led 17-0 after just 16 minutes at Murrayfield and the Irish were 22-0 up on the half-hour mark as they powered away to a win that would surpass their previous largest Twickenham triumph -- a 32-15 success in 2022.

Both games were eminently losable -- Ireland have now won six of their last seven Tests against England and Scotland five of the past six -- but a particular concern for Borthwick's men during the past two matches has been an inability to cope with disruption, be it yellow cards or injuries.

"The spacing is all wrong," wrote former England centre Will Greenwood in his Telegraph Sport column, with the 2003 World Cup-winner adding: "The defence was abject, awful. Quick ball kills England because they are too slow to react."

- Lack of composure -

Followig this thumping loss, it was easy to forget that England did manage sustained spells of possession early on at Twickenham but they lacked the wit to unlock a committed Ireland defence that refused to buckle in the face of repeated forward drives.

And as Ireland continued to make their tackles, England undid much of their good work with self-inflicted wounds such as when an 18-phase move ended with Genge dropping a pass from George Ford.

It was a tough day for veteran fly-half Ford as he failed to find touch with one early penalty and sent another dead before drawing ironic cheers from the Twickenham faithful when he finally located the sideline.

"George has done so much good for England for such a long period of time," Borthwick told a post-match press conference. But he must now decide if Ford keeps the No 10 shirt when England resume their Six Nations campaign against Italy in Rome on March 7.

F.Carpenteri--NZN