Zürcher Nachrichten - What's behind England's Six Nations slump?

EUR -
AED 4.283293
AFN 76.976985
ALL 92.174014
AMD 423.861482
ANG 2.087448
AOA 1070.675861
ARS 1763.287834
AUD 1.623725
AWG 2.096449
AZN 2.000094
BAM 1.954256
BBD 2.346905
BDT 143.394863
BGN 1.978495
BHD 0.439345
BIF 3478.783045
BMD 1.166314
BND 1.480516
BOB 13.418456
BRL 6.004648
BSD 1.165239
BTN 111.132767
BWP 15.602138
BYN 3.515472
BYR 22859.745013
BZD 2.343608
CAD 1.616528
CDF 2657.456563
CHF 0.937022
CLF 0.027064
CLP 1065.159708
CNY 7.838035
CNH 7.837813
COP 3610.836682
CRC 528.655125
CUC 1.166314
CUP 30.907308
CVE 110.177007
CZK 24.068398
DJF 207.500047
DKK 7.475568
DOP 68.242572
DZD 155.171499
EGP 58.796774
ERN 17.494703
ETB 188.075105
FJD 2.5572
FKP 0.855138
GBP 0.855543
GEL 3.038229
GGP 0.855138
GHS 12.993511
GIP 0.855138
GMD 85.704053
GNF 10238.38417
GTQ 8.890899
GYD 243.808417
HKD 9.144487
HNL 31.254163
HRK 7.533805
HTG 152.437146
HUF 360.232843
IDR 20665.909279
ILS 3.469036
IMP 0.855138
INR 111.107931
IQD 1526.587332
IRR 1603214.56613
ISK 141.205274
JEP 0.855138
JMD 184.941196
JOD 0.826912
JPY 185.494026
KES 150.979148
KGS 101.993951
KHR 4715.788958
KMF 493.350126
KPW 1049.682512
KRW 1615.888085
KWD 0.359994
KYD 0.971129
KZT 533.586138
LAK 26154.887087
LBP 104350.781186
LKR 382.747754
LRD 211.500178
LSL 18.639234
LTL 3.44382
LVL 0.705492
LYD 7.377918
MAD 10.768138
MDL 20.1364
MGA 4986.888937
MKD 61.476429
MMK 2448.87236
MNT 4197.368838
MOP 9.407964
MRU 46.725282
MUR 54.548293
MVR 18.030821
MWK 2020.634241
MXN 19.765358
MYR 4.69555
MZN 74.533246
NAD 18.639793
NGN 1570.953802
NIO 42.885382
NOK 10.875378
NPR 177.805373
NZD 1.958894
OMR 0.448441
PAB 1.165384
PEN 3.91096
PGK 5.166873
PHP 71.816334
PKR 323.280396
PLN 4.301644
PYG 6985.062024
QAR 4.248007
RON 5.255759
RSD 117.292675
RUB 97.562603
RWF 1717.625126
SAR 4.379639
SBD 9.353106
SCR 16.114598
SDG 701.534844
SEK 11.037997
SGD 1.481148
SHP 0.864082
SLE 28.749606
SLL 24457.010478
SOS 665.928187
SRD 44.228972
STD 24140.335108
STN 24.4794
SVC 10.1969
SYP 15164.408291
SZL 18.637636
THB 38.160558
TJS 10.744173
TMT 4.09376
TND 3.395588
TOP 2.808203
TRY 56.119975
TTD 7.916576
TWD 37.124808
TZS 3089.422199
UAH 52.06318
UGX 4346.491398
USD 1.166314
UYU 46.842388
UZS 13724.156842
VES 914.019438
VND 30431.452391
VUV 137.684964
WST 3.160747
XAF 655.427921
XAG 0.016885
XAU 0.000251
XCD 3.152021
XCG 2.100232
XDR 0.824644
XOF 655.416691
XPF 119.331742
YER 276.522362
ZAR 18.570428
ZMK 10498.275715
ZMW 22.192135
ZWL 375.552478
  • RBGPF

    1.3300

    69.89

    +1.9%

  • RYCEF

    0.5500

    20.8

    +2.64%

  • CMSC

    0.1120

    21.34

    +0.52%

  • NGG

    0.7500

    81.17

    +0.92%

  • CMSD

    0.2000

    21.26

    +0.94%

  • AZN

    2.9500

    169.66

    +1.74%

  • RIO

    2.0100

    106.81

    +1.88%

  • BCE

    -0.2600

    23.59

    -1.1%

  • BTI

    -0.2400

    56.47

    -0.43%

  • GSK

    0.2900

    52.07

    +0.56%

  • RELX

    -0.5100

    35.88

    -1.42%

  • BCC

    -1.2000

    81.04

    -1.48%

  • BP

    -0.8800

    42.86

    -2.05%

  • VOD

    0.1500

    16.13

    +0.93%

  • JRI

    0.1100

    12.48

    +0.88%

What's behind England's Six Nations slump?
What's behind England's Six Nations slump? / Photo: Adrian Dennis - AFP

What's behind England's Six Nations slump?

England entered the Six Nations Championship with genuine hope of dethroning title-holders France and they launched their bid to be crowned rugby champions of Europe for the first time since 2020 with a 48-7 rout of Wales.

Text size:

But hopes of championship glory effectively disappeared after Saturday's record 42-21 Twickenham defeat by Ireland which came just a week after an almost as emphatic 31-20 loss away to Scotland.

AFP Sport looks at three key aspects of England's striking collapse:

- Approach -

Before the championship even started, England coach Steve Borthwick set his sights on a title-decider away to France in the final round of matches, saying: "On March 14 in Paris, we want to be in a position entering that game where we can achieve what we’re all aiming to achieve."

A team with England's rugby resources, both playing and financial, ought to be ambitious and there is nothing fundamentally wrong with aiming high.

But the issue was more that for a coach who had made such a mantra out of a 'one game at a time' approach, such a bullish public statement jarred.

To borrow an old Irish expression, it was maybe just a sign that Borthwick had, ever so slightly, "lost the run of himself" and with it the team as well.

In that respect, hammering one of the weakest Wales teams in living memory, which gave his side a 12th successive win against all opponents, may have worked against Borthwick's men, with Red Rose prop Ellis Genge telling the BBC after Saturday's loss to Ireland: "We probably believed the hype from the first week too much. We can't let the noise in now."

- 'Awful' defence -

For two games in a row, England's defence has been ruthlessly exposed, with both Scotland and Ireland scoring a flurry of early tries.

The Scots led 17-0 after just 16 minutes at Murrayfield and the Irish were 22-0 up on the half-hour mark as they powered away to a win that would surpass their previous largest Twickenham triumph -- a 32-15 success in 2022.

Both games were eminently losable -- Ireland have now won six of their last seven Tests against England and Scotland five of the past six -- but a particular concern for Borthwick's men during the past two matches has been an inability to cope with disruption, be it yellow cards or injuries.

"The spacing is all wrong," wrote former England centre Will Greenwood in his Telegraph Sport column, with the 2003 World Cup-winner adding: "The defence was abject, awful. Quick ball kills England because they are too slow to react."

- Lack of composure -

Followig this thumping loss, it was easy to forget that England did manage sustained spells of possession early on at Twickenham but they lacked the wit to unlock a committed Ireland defence that refused to buckle in the face of repeated forward drives.

And as Ireland continued to make their tackles, England undid much of their good work with self-inflicted wounds such as when an 18-phase move ended with Genge dropping a pass from George Ford.

It was a tough day for veteran fly-half Ford as he failed to find touch with one early penalty and sent another dead before drawing ironic cheers from the Twickenham faithful when he finally located the sideline.

"George has done so much good for England for such a long period of time," Borthwick told a post-match press conference. But he must now decide if Ford keeps the No 10 shirt when England resume their Six Nations campaign against Italy in Rome on March 7.

F.Carpenteri--NZN