Zürcher Nachrichten - Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway

EUR -
AED 4.127425
AFN 79.221816
ALL 98.719773
AMD 436.096178
ANG 2.011113
AOA 1030.458576
ARS 1264.216617
AUD 1.731721
AWG 2.02552
AZN 1.913303
BAM 1.978295
BBD 2.267919
BDT 136.471842
BGN 1.960051
BHD 0.423541
BIF 3299.265644
BMD 1.123728
BND 1.466091
BOB 7.761359
BRL 6.308047
BSD 1.123288
BTN 95.811769
BWP 15.334093
BYN 3.675949
BYR 22025.070373
BZD 2.256266
CAD 1.563252
CDF 3226.223216
CHF 0.939459
CLF 0.027541
CLP 1056.866107
CNY 8.097978
CNH 8.089881
COP 4732.861742
CRC 570.798252
CUC 1.123728
CUP 29.778794
CVE 111.389579
CZK 24.934387
DJF 199.708983
DKK 7.459672
DOP 66.187401
DZD 149.654717
EGP 56.650612
ERN 16.855921
ETB 149.564786
FJD 2.53671
FKP 0.846333
GBP 0.842077
GEL 3.079374
GGP 0.846333
GHS 14.299431
GIP 0.846333
GMD 80.907899
GNF 9725.866387
GTQ 8.636204
GYD 234.998015
HKD 8.766377
HNL 28.958707
HRK 7.533585
HTG 146.86195
HUF 404.243759
IDR 18586.350075
ILS 4.002946
IMP 0.846333
INR 95.894688
IQD 1472.083785
IRR 47308.95239
ISK 145.713905
JEP 0.846333
JMD 178.944808
JOD 0.797173
JPY 164.323932
KES 145.24132
KGS 98.270188
KHR 4516.262872
KMF 495.005489
KPW 1011.383911
KRW 1568.982799
KWD 0.34531
KYD 0.936027
KZT 570.949652
LAK 24295.000867
LBP 100629.8496
LKR 335.677034
LRD 224.324282
LSL 20.597333
LTL 3.318076
LVL 0.679732
LYD 6.197367
MAD 10.45669
MDL 19.633911
MGA 5039.920138
MKD 61.523124
MMK 2359.135491
MNT 4020.301939
MOP 9.016468
MRU 44.500752
MUR 51.859743
MVR 17.361736
MWK 1950.79217
MXN 21.761916
MYR 4.829805
MZN 71.817273
NAD 20.597404
NGN 1801.100306
NIO 41.325094
NOK 11.566759
NPR 153.293715
NZD 1.886133
OMR 0.432641
PAB 1.123253
PEN 4.11425
PGK 4.576663
PHP 62.689433
PKR 316.610381
PLN 4.246012
PYG 8970.120318
QAR 4.090938
RON 5.104646
RSD 118.569858
RUB 90.339744
RWF 1595.693874
SAR 4.215049
SBD 9.395884
SCR 15.986822
SDG 674.793662
SEK 10.878711
SGD 1.457846
SHP 0.883074
SLE 25.565211
SLL 23564.01622
SOS 642.211833
SRD 41.016595
STD 23258.902464
SVC 9.828897
SYP 14610.380088
SZL 20.597676
THB 37.349316
TJS 11.647741
TMT 3.938667
TND 3.396467
TOP 2.631885
TRY 43.568444
TTD 7.622713
TWD 33.943891
TZS 3029.012918
UAH 46.680838
UGX 4110.799388
USD 1.123728
UYU 46.91346
UZS 14535.422542
VES 104.44601
VND 29149.506402
VUV 134.990964
WST 3.133593
XAF 663.489834
XAG 0.034221
XAU 0.000347
XCD 3.036931
XDR 0.825533
XOF 646.716307
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.695652
ZAR 20.458144
ZMK 10114.896444
ZMW 29.765869
ZWL 361.839983
  • CMSC

    -0.0200

    22.06

    -0.09%

  • JRI

    -0.1300

    12.88

    -1.01%

  • CMSD

    0.0900

    22.39

    +0.4%

  • SCS

    -0.1100

    10.71

    -1.03%

  • BCC

    0.6100

    93.71

    +0.65%

  • GSK

    -1.0200

    36.35

    -2.81%

  • BCE

    -0.5800

    21.98

    -2.64%

  • RIO

    0.8600

    62.27

    +1.38%

  • NGG

    0.0000

    67.53

    0%

  • AZN

    -1.2300

    67.72

    -1.82%

  • RBGPF

    63.8100

    63.81

    +100%

  • BTI

    -0.2900

    40.69

    -0.71%

  • RYCEF

    0.3200

    10.7

    +2.99%

  • BP

    0.3700

    30.56

    +1.21%

  • VOD

    -0.0100

    9.06

    -0.11%

  • RELX

    0.5700

    52.4

    +1.09%

Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway
Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway

Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway

Cavalier King Charles Spaniels are known for their tiny heads, English bulldogs for their smushed wrinkled muzzles -- traits their owners love.

Text size:

But in an unprecedented move, Norway has banned the breeding of these dogs because being cute is causing them suffering.

In a recent ruling, the Oslo district court banned the breeding of the two purebreds on the grounds that it inflicts harm on them, in violation of Norwegian animal protection laws.

Hailed by animal rights activists and criticised by breeders, the verdict comes amid a growing debate: is the quest for cute pets going to extremes at the expense of the animals' well-being?

"A lot of our breeds are highly inbred and have a massive burden of disease," Ashild Roaldset, the head of the Norwegian Animal Welfare Society, told AFP.

Her organisation brought the legal case against dogbreeding companies and individuals.

"We need to change the way we breed dogs," she said. "The way we breed dogs was maybe acceptable 50 years ago but is not acceptable anymore."

Inbreeding has caused the two breeds to develop a "disease guarantee", a long list of hereditary illnesses that affect most individuals, if not all.

Fierce-looking but gentle -- and since World War II a symbol of British tenacity -- the English bulldog has developed respiratory difficulties due to its flattened muzzle, as well as dermatological, reproductive and orthopaedic problems.

More than half of all bulldogs born in Norway over the past 10 years had to be delivered by Caesarian section.

"The race's genetic inability to give birth naturally is reason alone for bulldogs not to be used for breeding," the district court judges wrote in their ruling.

As for cavaliers -- which have won the hearts of many over the years, from Queen Victoria to Ronald Reagan and Sylvester Stallone -- they often suffer headaches because their skull is too small. They also have heart and eye problems.

Roaldset said these diseases cannot be bred away with other purebreds from abroad due to an overall lack of genetic diversity.

The two breeds will eventually be led to extinction, she said.

"And it's going to be painful for them because they're just going to get more and more diseases," she said.

- 'Puppy factories' -

The January 31 court ruling has been appealed and has therefore not come into force yet.

But it delivered a shock to professional breeders.

"In the judgement it was said that the dogs are born with headaches, I cannot understand that," says Lise Gran-Henriksen, who has been a breeder for 25 years, as she watches five of her Cavalier King Charles Spaniels frolic on the ice outside her Oslo home.

"If so, they would not be so happy. They are happy dogs that run around and look very healthy, and that's what I think they are," she insists.

Professional breeders readily admit that the two breeds do pose "challenges", but say these can be overcome by selective breeding of individuals that meet certain requirements.

In addition, they note that the court ruling does not ban the ownership, sale or import of bulldogs or cavaliers -- only their breeding.

Walking her English bulldog Oscar in an Oslo park, Anne Grethe Holen fears a rise in "undocumented dogs" from "puppy factories" abroad.

"Demand will not decline. And the dogs that are sold will be more sick," she says.

"They won't be subjected to any veterinary requirements and you won't know anything about their pedigree," she adds.

Meanwhile, the Animal Welfare Society says the future of the two breeds lies in crossbreeding them with other types of dogs to get rid of their genetic flaws.

"If the cavalier gets a slightly larger skull to fit their brain, it's still... going to be the cutest dog in the world," says Roaldset.

"And if the bulldog gets a little bit less wrinkly, a little bit longer snout and a better skeleton, it's not going to be a horrible dog.

"It's going to look a little bit different, but you can still call it a bulldog."

L.Zimmermann--NZN