Zürcher Nachrichten - Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway

EUR -
AED 4.17778
AFN 81.329858
ALL 98.904959
AMD 443.968452
ANG 2.049955
AOA 1037.324758
ARS 1329.397159
AUD 1.7785
AWG 2.047351
AZN 1.938125
BAM 1.958843
BBD 2.296498
BDT 138.190762
BGN 1.957336
BHD 0.428656
BIF 3334.90676
BMD 1.137417
BND 1.49495
BOB 7.859314
BRL 6.46406
BSD 1.137382
BTN 97.090115
BWP 15.677563
BYN 3.721902
BYR 22293.373977
BZD 2.28468
CAD 1.577643
CDF 3272.349235
CHF 0.941304
CLF 0.027715
CLP 1063.565001
CNY 8.289159
CNH 8.289899
COP 4801.446794
CRC 575.701977
CUC 1.137417
CUP 30.141552
CVE 110.675107
CZK 24.932982
DJF 202.142204
DKK 7.465681
DOP 67.164923
DZD 150.506481
EGP 57.961681
ERN 17.061256
ETB 151.791618
FJD 2.56761
FKP 0.854957
GBP 0.8537
GEL 3.116967
GGP 0.854957
GHS 17.414299
GIP 0.854957
GMD 81.894431
GNF 9844.344882
GTQ 8.759724
GYD 237.954906
HKD 8.822904
HNL 29.484639
HRK 7.532021
HTG 148.517258
HUF 405.63748
IDR 19132.037057
ILS 4.122034
IMP 0.854957
INR 97.095155
IQD 1489.940903
IRR 47885.25777
ISK 145.294091
JEP 0.854957
JMD 179.999639
JOD 0.806547
JPY 163.272849
KES 147.29983
KGS 99.467557
KHR 4567.86723
KMF 491.937185
KPW 1023.639069
KRW 1638.415559
KWD 0.348903
KYD 0.947785
KZT 585.657575
LAK 24596.643879
LBP 101855.696297
LKR 340.802976
LRD 227.476397
LSL 21.463751
LTL 3.358497
LVL 0.688013
LYD 6.223422
MAD 10.550166
MDL 19.630756
MGA 5065.937019
MKD 61.489971
MMK 2388.001001
MNT 4035.207792
MOP 9.087237
MRU 45.242696
MUR 51.559545
MVR 17.521954
MWK 1972.20728
MXN 22.233034
MYR 4.975106
MZN 72.806494
NAD 21.464223
NGN 1829.615356
NIO 41.855577
NOK 11.855542
NPR 155.341649
NZD 1.90655
OMR 0.437921
PAB 1.137382
PEN 4.177545
PGK 4.641067
PHP 63.926823
PKR 320.036018
PLN 4.275756
PYG 9097.773952
QAR 4.14554
RON 4.977455
RSD 117.433989
RUB 93.9816
RWF 1611.424688
SAR 4.267057
SBD 9.474726
SCR 16.199026
SDG 683.023113
SEK 11.000523
SGD 1.494845
SHP 0.893831
SLE 25.87666
SLL 23851.048143
SOS 650.018411
SRD 41.949121
STD 23542.236285
SVC 9.951066
SYP 14788.476686
SZL 21.445259
THB 38.175701
TJS 12.033459
TMT 3.992334
TND 3.407394
TOP 2.663949
TRY 43.699112
TTD 7.726105
TWD 37.034872
TZS 3063.064469
UAH 47.565532
UGX 4169.312303
USD 1.137417
UYU 47.482305
UZS 14702.323823
VES 94.760398
VND 29597.297497
VUV 138.076467
WST 3.16409
XAF 656.992114
XAG 0.034442
XAU 0.000345
XCD 3.073927
XDR 0.817753
XOF 656.977651
XPF 119.331742
YER 278.8382
ZAR 21.229931
ZMK 10238.122337
ZMW 31.760761
ZWL 366.247823
  • RBGPF

    -0.2600

    63.19

    -0.41%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    22.46

    +0.04%

  • RYCEF

    0.3100

    10.15

    +3.05%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    22.33

    -0%

  • SCS

    -0.0600

    9.89

    -0.61%

  • GSK

    -0.0700

    37.43

    -0.19%

  • NGG

    -0.2200

    72.04

    -0.31%

  • AZN

    0.0200

    69.57

    +0.03%

  • RELX

    0.3800

    53.55

    +0.71%

  • BCC

    -0.5800

    95.51

    -0.61%

  • VOD

    0.0400

    9.35

    +0.43%

  • BCE

    -0.3600

    21.65

    -1.66%

  • RIO

    -1.1300

    60.56

    -1.87%

  • JRI

    0.1400

    12.74

    +1.1%

  • BTI

    -0.4000

    42.05

    -0.95%

  • BP

    0.1900

    29.19

    +0.65%

Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway
Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway

Breeding ban for bulldogs and cavaliers in Norway

Cavalier King Charles Spaniels are known for their tiny heads, English bulldogs for their smushed wrinkled muzzles -- traits their owners love.

Text size:

But in an unprecedented move, Norway has banned the breeding of these dogs because being cute is causing them suffering.

In a recent ruling, the Oslo district court banned the breeding of the two purebreds on the grounds that it inflicts harm on them, in violation of Norwegian animal protection laws.

Hailed by animal rights activists and criticised by breeders, the verdict comes amid a growing debate: is the quest for cute pets going to extremes at the expense of the animals' well-being?

"A lot of our breeds are highly inbred and have a massive burden of disease," Ashild Roaldset, the head of the Norwegian Animal Welfare Society, told AFP.

Her organisation brought the legal case against dogbreeding companies and individuals.

"We need to change the way we breed dogs," she said. "The way we breed dogs was maybe acceptable 50 years ago but is not acceptable anymore."

Inbreeding has caused the two breeds to develop a "disease guarantee", a long list of hereditary illnesses that affect most individuals, if not all.

Fierce-looking but gentle -- and since World War II a symbol of British tenacity -- the English bulldog has developed respiratory difficulties due to its flattened muzzle, as well as dermatological, reproductive and orthopaedic problems.

More than half of all bulldogs born in Norway over the past 10 years had to be delivered by Caesarian section.

"The race's genetic inability to give birth naturally is reason alone for bulldogs not to be used for breeding," the district court judges wrote in their ruling.

As for cavaliers -- which have won the hearts of many over the years, from Queen Victoria to Ronald Reagan and Sylvester Stallone -- they often suffer headaches because their skull is too small. They also have heart and eye problems.

Roaldset said these diseases cannot be bred away with other purebreds from abroad due to an overall lack of genetic diversity.

The two breeds will eventually be led to extinction, she said.

"And it's going to be painful for them because they're just going to get more and more diseases," she said.

- 'Puppy factories' -

The January 31 court ruling has been appealed and has therefore not come into force yet.

But it delivered a shock to professional breeders.

"In the judgement it was said that the dogs are born with headaches, I cannot understand that," says Lise Gran-Henriksen, who has been a breeder for 25 years, as she watches five of her Cavalier King Charles Spaniels frolic on the ice outside her Oslo home.

"If so, they would not be so happy. They are happy dogs that run around and look very healthy, and that's what I think they are," she insists.

Professional breeders readily admit that the two breeds do pose "challenges", but say these can be overcome by selective breeding of individuals that meet certain requirements.

In addition, they note that the court ruling does not ban the ownership, sale or import of bulldogs or cavaliers -- only their breeding.

Walking her English bulldog Oscar in an Oslo park, Anne Grethe Holen fears a rise in "undocumented dogs" from "puppy factories" abroad.

"Demand will not decline. And the dogs that are sold will be more sick," she says.

"They won't be subjected to any veterinary requirements and you won't know anything about their pedigree," she adds.

Meanwhile, the Animal Welfare Society says the future of the two breeds lies in crossbreeding them with other types of dogs to get rid of their genetic flaws.

"If the cavalier gets a slightly larger skull to fit their brain, it's still... going to be the cutest dog in the world," says Roaldset.

"And if the bulldog gets a little bit less wrinkly, a little bit longer snout and a better skeleton, it's not going to be a horrible dog.

"It's going to look a little bit different, but you can still call it a bulldog."

L.Zimmermann--NZN