Zürcher Nachrichten - Ukraine crisis stretches Indian 'neutrality' to the limit

EUR -
AED 3.938361
AFN 75.940226
ALL 100.157487
AMD 416.977517
ANG 1.933105
AOA 916.235945
ARS 971.18739
AUD 1.608002
AWG 1.931386
AZN 1.825571
BAM 1.951483
BBD 2.165809
BDT 126.03118
BGN 1.954847
BHD 0.404157
BIF 3084.048372
BMD 1.072248
BND 1.448382
BOB 7.411603
BRL 5.815441
BSD 1.072617
BTN 89.453202
BWP 14.47584
BYN 3.510334
BYR 21016.058003
BZD 2.162117
CAD 1.470888
CDF 3050.545029
CHF 0.954553
CLF 0.036304
CLP 1001.736783
CNY 7.784954
CNH 7.811733
COP 4463.231706
CRC 560.646605
CUC 1.072248
CUP 28.414568
CVE 110.021598
CZK 24.878287
DJF 190.9857
DKK 7.458266
DOP 63.308466
DZD 144.224833
EGP 51.153297
ERN 16.083718
ETB 61.877665
FJD 2.404784
FKP 0.841288
GBP 0.84416
GEL 3.045453
GGP 0.841288
GHS 16.197167
GIP 0.841288
GMD 72.644458
GNF 9233.486569
GTQ 8.323586
GYD 224.413528
HKD 8.368198
HNL 26.521707
HRK 7.525505
HTG 142.174141
HUF 396.413252
IDR 17684.101399
ILS 3.985278
IMP 0.841288
INR 89.657613
IQD 1405.191284
IRR 45128.236178
ISK 149.514028
JEP 0.841288
JMD 166.966725
JOD 0.759905
JPY 169.879431
KES 137.516108
KGS 93.604241
KHR 4419.182193
KMF 491.631446
KPW 965.023212
KRW 1486.478449
KWD 0.328751
KYD 0.893922
KZT 494.037038
LAK 23531.940096
LBP 96054.896965
LKR 327.315876
LRD 208.309156
LSL 19.288029
LTL 3.166069
LVL 0.648592
LYD 5.200447
MAD 10.699629
MDL 19.146642
MGA 4825.279992
MKD 61.572826
MMK 3482.619215
MNT 3699.255212
MOP 8.625418
MRU 42.04201
MUR 50.021856
MVR 16.509922
MWK 1859.768275
MXN 19.750487
MYR 5.050822
MZN 68.29687
NAD 19.288029
NGN 1597.649063
NIO 39.482285
NOK 11.317265
NPR 143.122033
NZD 1.749882
OMR 0.412762
PAB 1.072627
PEN 4.089154
PGK 4.181651
PHP 63.102077
PKR 298.727337
PLN 4.323257
PYG 8078.12869
QAR 3.912744
RON 4.976836
RSD 117.057619
RUB 91.224926
RWF 1407.752794
SAR 4.022768
SBD 9.10293
SCR 14.643937
SDG 644.420705
SEK 11.21479
SGD 1.450231
SHP 1.354731
SLE 24.497971
SLL 22484.503499
SOS 613.029497
SRD 33.384972
STD 22193.365786
SVC 9.385237
SYP 2694.055366
SZL 19.300122
THB 39.411509
TJS 11.343205
TMT 3.76359
TND 3.359967
TOP 2.528469
TRY 34.95683
TTD 7.285881
TWD 34.702552
TZS 2798.567096
UAH 43.475214
UGX 4006.13719
USD 1.072248
UYU 42.215229
UZS 13544.036417
VEF 3884274.19294
VES 38.962887
VND 27292.996959
VUV 127.299384
WST 3.002954
XAF 654.493798
XAG 0.035514
XAU 0.000459
XCD 2.897803
XDR 0.814091
XOF 654.502934
XPF 119.331742
YER 268.437316
ZAR 19.455412
ZMK 9651.510884
ZMW 27.379428
ZWL 345.263373
  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    56.5

    0%

  • RYCEF

    0.1400

    5.97

    +2.35%

  • CMSC

    0.1260

    24.556

    +0.51%

  • GSK

    0.2900

    40.95

    +0.71%

  • RELX

    0.1000

    45.58

    +0.22%

  • BP

    0.2800

    35.39

    +0.79%

  • NGG

    0.7000

    56.5

    +1.24%

  • RIO

    0.2700

    66.26

    +0.41%

  • VOD

    0.0500

    8.91

    +0.56%

  • AZN

    -0.8900

    78.42

    -1.13%

  • BTI

    0.1800

    31.12

    +0.58%

  • SCS

    0.0900

    12.59

    +0.71%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    24.3

    0%

  • BCC

    -0.5600

    126.29

    -0.44%

  • BCE

    -0.1400

    32.5

    -0.43%

  • JRI

    -0.2000

    11.85

    -1.69%

Ukraine crisis stretches Indian 'neutrality' to the limit
Ukraine crisis stretches Indian 'neutrality' to the limit

Ukraine crisis stretches Indian 'neutrality' to the limit

Russia's invasion of Ukraine has left India's traditional balancing act between Moscow and the West looking wobblier than ever, with experts saying New Delhi has few good diplomatic options.

Text size:

Last week India abstained on a UN Security Council resolution deploring Russia's "aggression" against Ukraine, winning praise from Moscow for its "independent and balanced position".

But while New Delhi hoped this would be seen as neutrality, in many capitals its failure to condemn the invasion was taken as de facto backing of Moscow that gave President Vladimir Putin useful diplomatic cover.

And India is also reportedly looking to bolster its rupee-rouble trade pact with Moscow, potentially undermining Western efforts to isolate Russia from the global financial system.

The crisis has left India facing a dilemma: it leant towards the Soviet Union during the Cold War -- while Pakistan was in the Western camp -- and their close relations outlived the fall of the Iron Curtain, with Moscow still by far its biggest arms supplier.

At the same time it needs Western support to contend with Xi Jinping's increasingly assertive China: Beijing is extending its reach into the Indian Ocean, and the two countries had a deadly border clash in 2020.

Together with the US, Japan and Australia, India is also a member of the "Quad alliance" that is seen as a bulwark against China.

Its decision to abstain at the Friday Security Council vote left it alongside only Beijing and the United Arab Emirates, while Russia vetoed the resolution.

"There are not many choices that India has," said Nandan Unnikrishnan of the Observer Research Foundation.

It "has as much investment in a relationship with Russia as it has in maintaining a relationship with the United States", he told AFP.

"India's challenges in the maritime is where it needs the United States and India's challenges on the continental shelf is where it requires Russia."

- Hug the bear -

Putin visited India last year, in a rare foreign trip for the Russian president, bear-hugging Prime Minister Narendra Modi as the two men bolstered military and energy ties.

New Delhi is the world's second largest importer of arms after Saudi Arabia and according to the Business Standard, between 2016-2020, 49.4 percent of its purchases were from Russia.

Late last year it began taking delivery from Russia of the S-400 missile defence system that it agreed to buy for over $5 billion in 2018, despite the threat of US sanctions.

And while New Delhi is looking to develop its own capacity and diversify its suppliers, US imports accounted for just 11 percent.

The Asian giant of 1.4 billion people is also a major consumer of Russian oil. Total annual bilateral trade runs at around $9 billion, with much smaller quantities of pharmaceuticals, tea and coffee going the other way.

Russia has also repeatedly vetoed UN resolutions condemning Delhi over its behaviour in Indian-administered Kashmir where a violent insurgency has raged for decades.

According to Happymon Jacob from Jawaharlal Nehru University, Russia is perhaps India's "only partner of consequence" in the territory to its north.

- 'East-West conflict' -

While New Delhi aspires to a permanent seat on the UN Security Council, a role that would bring greater responsibility on the world stage, it has been careful to avoid explicitly condemning Russia.

So far it has not referred to Moscow's operation as an invasion and instead emphasised narrow domestic aspects of the crisis, primarily the evacuation of Indian students from Ukraine.

Officially, Washington has kept its annoyance quiet, saying India and Russia "have a relationship... that we don't have" and calling on Delhi to use its "leverage" with Moscow.

But ex-officials have been more vocal, with former US diplomat Richard Haass calling India's "careful, avoid angering Putin at all costs response" a sign that it "remains unprepared to step up to major power responsibilities or be a dependable partner."

But commentator Sanjaya Baru said Western countries should be more indulgent of India's ties to Russia -- precisely because of its role in confronting China.

"Only a vibrant India can take the edge off an aggressive China," he wrote in the Times of India.

There is "no reason why India should be taking sides in what is essentially an East-West conflict, centred in Europe and a continuation of the Cold War", he added.

X.Blaser--NZN