Zürcher Nachrichten - India and US at odds on Kashmir truce: analysts

EUR -
AED 4.303863
AFN 82.246499
ALL 98.021992
AMD 449.671513
ANG 2.097286
AOA 1074.646617
ARS 1391.811212
AUD 1.792193
AWG 2.112377
AZN 1.996908
BAM 1.955241
BBD 2.364524
BDT 143.229075
BGN 1.96181
BHD 0.440474
BIF 3488.003358
BMD 1.171915
BND 1.494273
BOB 8.091688
BRL 6.421514
BSD 1.171065
BTN 100.139387
BWP 15.656526
BYN 3.832405
BYR 22969.536814
BZD 2.352328
CAD 1.606755
CDF 3376.287953
CHF 0.947843
CLF 0.028433
CLP 1091.108233
CNY 8.405566
CNH 8.406054
COP 4731.24812
CRC 590.631236
CUC 1.171915
CUP 31.055751
CVE 110.233503
CZK 24.729407
DJF 208.540413
DKK 7.459948
DOP 69.670093
DZD 151.08583
EGP 58.232361
ERN 17.578727
ETB 158.200997
FJD 2.626555
FKP 0.854244
GBP 0.864978
GEL 3.188067
GGP 0.854244
GHS 12.121536
GIP 0.854244
GMD 83.796446
GNF 10146.100911
GTQ 9.006427
GYD 244.900024
HKD 9.198773
HNL 30.599257
HRK 7.534833
HTG 153.526132
HUF 398.896931
IDR 19027.50725
ILS 3.968937
IMP 0.854244
INR 100.207124
IQD 1534.061666
IRR 49366.925837
ISK 141.989691
JEP 0.854244
JMD 187.676374
JOD 0.830934
JPY 169.511712
KES 151.356752
KGS 102.418398
KHR 4694.658575
KMF 492.794764
KPW 1054.746821
KRW 1598.902875
KWD 0.35836
KYD 0.975921
KZT 609.225923
LAK 25253.784127
LBP 104926.318947
LKR 351.19965
LRD 234.213077
LSL 20.971708
LTL 3.460361
LVL 0.70888
LYD 6.342188
MAD 10.573479
MDL 19.832333
MGA 5148.528888
MKD 61.512424
MMK 2460.534478
MNT 4199.800299
MOP 9.469694
MRU 46.702655
MUR 52.924131
MVR 18.051875
MWK 2030.619782
MXN 22.061348
MYR 4.955448
MZN 74.956135
NAD 20.971708
NGN 1809.132725
NIO 43.097686
NOK 11.809718
NPR 160.223219
NZD 1.935291
OMR 0.448972
PAB 1.171065
PEN 4.156612
PGK 4.83062
PHP 66.342555
PKR 332.139896
PLN 4.243905
PYG 9345.329718
QAR 4.26858
RON 5.081311
RSD 117.146527
RUB 92.123677
RWF 1691.016818
SAR 4.395033
SBD 9.782372
SCR 17.186389
SDG 703.739351
SEK 11.120893
SGD 1.495251
SHP 0.920941
SLE 26.372388
SLL 24574.478898
SOS 669.208784
SRD 44.293749
STD 24256.277385
SVC 10.247072
SYP 15237.425283
SZL 20.967009
THB 38.151742
TJS 11.546601
TMT 4.113422
TND 3.423522
TOP 2.744747
TRY 46.659846
TTD 7.948729
TWD 34.106291
TZS 3085.918247
UAH 48.826249
UGX 4209.797116
USD 1.171915
UYU 47.17652
UZS 14739.788336
VES 124.930261
VND 30581.125672
VUV 140.267499
WST 3.208176
XAF 655.769624
XAG 0.032565
XAU 0.000358
XCD 3.16716
XDR 0.815567
XOF 655.769624
XPF 119.331742
YER 283.896869
ZAR 20.941843
ZMK 10548.646794
ZMW 27.725078
ZWL 377.356198
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

India and US at odds on Kashmir truce: analysts
India and US at odds on Kashmir truce: analysts / Photo: Money SHARMA - AFP

India and US at odds on Kashmir truce: analysts

US President Donald Trump's claim to have helped end fighting between arch-rivals India and Pakistan has driven a wedge between him and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, analysts say.

Text size:

A week since Trump announced a surprise truce between India and Pakistan to end a brief but intense conflict, New Delhi and Washington differ about the way it was achieved.

The US administration thought "an intervention at this stage might give them some basic benefit in terms of highlighting Trump's role," Indian foreign policy expert Harsh V. Pant told AFP.

"That... became the driver and in a sense the hurry which with Trump announced the ceasefire," said Pant from the New Delhi-based Observer Research Foundation (ORF) think tank.

Fighting began when India launched strikes on May 7 against what it called "terrorist camps" in Pakistan following an April militant attack in Indian-administered Kashmir that killed 26 people.

New Delhi blamed Islamabad for backing the militants it claimed were behind the attack, which Pakistan denies.

Trump announced the truce after four days of missile, drone and artillery attacks from both sides, killing about 70 people, including dozens of civilians, and sent thousands fleeing.

He later boasted about bringing India and Pakistan "back from the brink", telling Fox News on Friday it was "a bigger success than I'll ever be given credit for".

New Delhi however shrugs off these claims, which go against decades-long Indian policy that opposes foreign mediation in conflicts with Islamabad.

India and Pakistan claim the currently divided Kashmir in full. New Delhi considers the Himalayan region an internal matter, with politicians long viewing external mediation as a sign of weakness.

Modi's first speech since the ceasefire did not mention US involvement and his government has since insisted that talks with Pakistan are "strictly bilateral".

India was also quick to dismiss Trump's suggestion that trade pressures hastened a truce.

"The issue of trade did not come up" in discussions with US officials, the Indian foreign ministry said this week.

- 'Upstaged' -

According to ORF fellow Manoj Joshi, Trump's rhetoric is "irritating" for India -- whose strategic location and massive market size have made the country an important ally for the United States.

But India is being "very cautious" because it is in negotiations for a trade deal with Washington to avoid steep tarriffs, he said.

"We (India) would like the agenda to go in a different direction," said Joshi.

It is also a thorny matter domestically.

Main opposition Congress party said Trump's announcement had "upstaged" the Hindu nationalist leader's "much-delayed address".

It also demanded an all-party meeting to ask whether India is changing its policy on "third-party mediation" for Kashmir, disputed between Pakistan and India.

The two South Asian rivals had in the 1970s agreed to settle "differences by peaceful means through bilateral negotiations".

- 'Irritating' -

Modi has previously poked fun at former Congress governments for "weak" responses against Pakistan in various skirmishes.

"So India would obviously respond to that and deny that... about as politely as they feel they can get away with," said South Asia researcher Pramit Pal Chaudhuri of political consultancy Eurasia Group.

Trump's claimed mediation was welcomed by Islamabad, which "needed an American intervention to give them the off-ramp they needed to get out of a conflict", Chaudhuri added.

On Thursday, Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar reaffirmed that "where Pakistan is concerned, our relations, our dealings with them will be bilateral, and strictly bilateral."

But the same day, speaking from Qatar, Trump repeated claims of brokering a ceasefire and using trade as a tool.

"(I said) let's do trade instead of war. And Pakistan was very happy with that, and India was very happy with that," Trump said in his speech.

It has been a decade since Modi last met a Pakistani leader. Since then, relations have deteriorated, coming to a head when India unilaterally revoked Kashmir's limited autonomy in 2019.

According to Joshi, "the hyphenation of India and Pakistan" is also "irritating" for New Delhi, which has tried to carve out a separate identity on the global stage.

"The optics of Trump hammering it day after day... is politically damaging for Modi," Sushant Singh, a former Indian soldier and South Asian studies lecturer at Yale University, wrote on X.

"(Modi) can't personally counter Trump, and despite attempts by India's big media to play it down, social media amplifies Trump," Singh said.

T.Furrer--NZN